I know I risk condemnation for saying this, but I am relieved by this result. Right from the beginning, I have thought that the evidence against Kelly Ellard was frightening in its unreliability.
The source of the evidence was essentially:
1) a group of punks who would swarm a single individual and had lied before, and
2) a bunch of teenagers who someone like Kelly Ellard might consider it "cool" to brag about a killing to.
There was ample reason to doubt all the evidence - both the evidence included in the Crown's case, and the evidence from Kelly Ellard herself.
If Kelly Ellard did the crime (and I think it reasonably likely she did) I want her to be convicted and punished harshly.
But even more, I want there to remain in place the important protection, that the evidence in a case must establish that the Crown has proved a case beyond a reasonable doubt, in the minds of ALL twelve independent individuals, who observed all the evidence, and have the opportunity to discuss the evidence between them, with the knowledge that their thoughts and opinions are revealed only to the extent that the jury is unanimous in their verdict.
If you attend trials, or read transcripts, or read appeal decisions, you may start to gain an enhanced appreciation for the wisdom of relying on a jury system that requires unanimity, and prohibits disclosure of the details of jury deliberations. Even though we, in Canada, are prohibited by law from learning about the details of jury deliberation, it is remarkable how prudent jury decisions usually appear to be, when you know details about the evidence thatr they observed.
This protection is particularly important when you are dealing with someone as objectionable as Kelly Ellard appears to be.
For all those who want to remove this safeguard, I pose three questions:
1) have you ever been falsely accused of anything (no matter how minor) by someone in a position of authority? and
2) have you ever been the subject of gossip that was both hurtful and false? and
3) have you ever believed and shared gossip that later turned out to be false?
The dissenting juror may very well be wrong, but if he or she truly had a doubt, based on reason and the evidence observed by him/her, and that doubt survived 4 and one-half days of being sequestered with eleven others who disagreed with him/her, then I applaud that person for having the courage to stand strong in his/her belief.
I also commend the the other eleven jurors. They too could have shirked their responsibility, decided that they didn't want to believe anyone, and voted to acquit, just so they could go home early.
My heart goes out to the Virk family, and the Ellard family too, for that matter. But you do not replace a system that has provided protection for centuries because sometimes the result is neither pleasant or convenient.