Kelly Ellard

Kelly Ellard killed Reena Virk and

  • Will be found guilty

    Votes: 47 61.0%
  • Will be found not guilty

    Votes: 1 1.3%
  • I believe she did it

    Votes: 34 44.2%
  • I believe she is innocent

    Votes: 1 1.3%
  • Either way it can't be proven without a shadow of a doubt

    Votes: 5 6.5%

  • Total voters
    77

BDAClub

New member
Jun 23, 2004
561
1
0
Lower Mainland
Lisa...........The Crown erred in asking Ellard, who testified in her own defence, why witnesses would have lied, the Appeal Court ruled in a unanimous decision.

"There is no dispute this is an improper line of questioning and (the Crown) did not try to defend it," Justice Ian Donald wrote on behalf of the three-judge panel.

The Crown did argue that the judge told the jury not to take Ellard's lack of an explanation into account.

But at trial the prosecutor asked Ellard 18 times, in one way or another, to explain why witnesses would give false testimony against her.

..This is why they granted her a New Trial they said it switches the burden of proof from the crown to the accused..........bunch of crap in my opinion
 

LonelyGhost

Telefunkin
Apr 26, 2004
3,933
1
0
the burden of proof is upon the crown

to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt based on the fact that you are considered innocent until 'proven' guilty ... the crown erred in asking Ellard why because then she has to prove her innocence which is a given in our system.

it is up to the defense to discredit the testimony of the witnesses, but this is a double-edged sword ... if the defense can create doubt in the witness or the testimony of the witness, then there is an arguement for reasonable doubt ... but if all the witnesses stick to their stories and seem to be truthful, then the defense has just lost the ability to claim that burden of proof has not been met.

so, while emotionally we can be pissed about this ellard trial (I certainly am) the fact that we are still innocent until proven guilty and not required to prove it is a good thing.

it is more frustrating that the one juror decided the fate of two families in such a callous manner ... neither family can move on until this is settled for better or worse but leaving them to go through it again is just plain torture.
 

wilde

Sinnear Member
Jun 4, 2003
3,041
48
48
All of the crown's so called star witnesses have all lied under oath before. And some of them will get one kind of deal or another for testifying against Ellard. If that is not reasonable doubt, I don't know what is. So don't shit on that 12th juror so much, ever considered the level of prejudice on the other 11? The crown knew that their chances were good but it was by no mean a slam dunk. But with this case being so public and so tragic. The crown had no choice but to go for 2nd degree murder instead of 1st degree manslaughter as well as some other lesser charges. If they went that route, I guarantee any defense lawyer worth his salt would have taken any offer from the crown. The case wouldn't even make it to trial.
 

LonelyGhost

Telefunkin
Apr 26, 2004
3,933
1
0
wilde said:


She is making the fatal mistake that she has "power" over men. When the looks are not quite there anymore and the men will not even shell out $$, all she has to fall back on is her memory of sleeping with undersirable men. The one guy who she might meet and fall for will take her money and laugh all the way to the bank, thats assuming she has any left. Which I doubt she will have due to her HIGH life (both living and drug wise).
that's funny wilde ... telling me not to shit on a juror that lets a potential murderer free and then you shit all over this woman who is trying to make a living ...
 

wilde

Sinnear Member
Jun 4, 2003
3,041
48
48
You said it pal - the key word being POTENTIAL. You have already made up your mind that she is guity. But I haven't. See my earlier post in this thread
wilde said:
She has shown no remorse whatsoever, so even if she did not put the final nail in the poor girl's coffin. She should rot in hell.
Without a doubt, this working gal is trying to make a living but there are better ways to go about it, don't you think? There is no need to bite the hand that feeds you. Or at the very least, show a little respect.

Besides, I am a recovering schizophrenic. :p

BTW, did I piss you off on one of my reply to your posts? I don't kiss ass, I just tell it how I see it.
 
Last edited:

LonelyGhost

Telefunkin
Apr 26, 2004
3,933
1
0
wilde

1. as for this working 'gal' we don't even know if she exists, as we only have Manhatten's story to go by and it may be biased for whatever reason.

2. even if she has an 'attitude' that does not give anyone the right to put her in her place ... but yes, it pisses me off to be told not to 'shit' on the hold-out juror (which I was not, I clearly stated that this juror's actions or inactions had a horrific affect on two families!) and then you go off in another thread and shit on some putative sp who seems to be getting uppity by biting the hand that feeds her?!?!?!

3. we are entitled to our opions and feelings ... this incident with Reena Virk says a lot about us and how we treat others ... and whether Kelly Ellard actually stood there and held the girl's head under the water or what her actual role was, she is either an incredible scape-goat or somehow culpable in the whole event.

Is she guilty of doing the deed? I don't know ... is she guilty of instigating it or not stopping it? more than likely. should this fiasco be put to bed once and for all ... yes ... and that 12th juror for whatever reason just made it necessary to go through the whole thing all over again ...

nice.
 

ezsmile

Member
Jan 5, 2003
280
2
18
"There is no dispute this is an improper line of questioning and (the Crown) did not try to defend it," Justice Ian Donald wrote on behalf of the three-judge panel.
The Crown did argue that the judge told the jury not to take Ellard's lack of an explanation into account
But at trial the prosecutor asked Ellard 18 times, in one way or another, to explain why witnesses would give false testimony against her.
Sounds like the prosecutor in the first trial was also letting their emotions run away with them, and trying to play on those of the jurors as well.
Maybe they were seeing her as a 15 year-old, and asking the typical "why do you think....." question, that you ask of 15 yr-olds, and had forgotten she was being tried as an adult (she was wasn't she? - not sure on that one)
I think it is a good thing that the appeal judges didn't forget.
I wonder what happened to the prosecuting team of the first trial. After all, how many times can you ask that type of question before you understand that you are blowing it?
 

wilde

Sinnear Member
Jun 4, 2003
3,041
48
48
Re: wilde

LonelyGhost said:

2) and then you go off in another thread and shit on some putative sp who seems to be getting uppity by biting the hand that feeds her?!?!?!

3)we are entitled to our opions and feelings

Is she guilty of doing the deed? I don't know ... is she guilty of instigating it or not stopping it? more than likely. should this fiasco be put to bed once and for all ... yes ... and that 12th juror for whatever reason just made it necessary to go through the whole thing all over again ...
2) I saw a lot more than uppity, I saw disrespect, contempt, and manipulation.
Or perhaps, I was just too damn sensitive.;)

3) That we agree on.

Ever consider that the 12th juror could be RIGHT? If Ellard did not put the final nail in Virk's coffin, is this not justice served?
 

wilde

Sinnear Member
Jun 4, 2003
3,041
48
48
In my opinion

The best thing for both families right now regardless of whether Ellard is really guilty or not is not trial #3. The crown should make an offer to Ellard for the minimum sentence for 2nd degree murder counting time served. If she won't get a lot of additional jail time she should accept the plea and bring some sense of closure to everyone involved.
 

Massagegirl

Banned
Mar 25, 2003
891
1
0
Something that not everyone might know is that the only reason a search was even begun for Reena Virk is that allegaedly Kelly Ellard was bragging at school that she killed her and that she (Virk) had a hairy ass. That is partly why they found her guilty the first time, how would she know that unless she was holding her under water when her pants came off? She was trying to make herself look tough and cool, and bragged about it. Why would she do that if she wasn't involved and risk being called a liar or why would everyone say she was saying it?
 

ezsmile

Member
Jan 5, 2003
280
2
18
Why would she do that if she wasn't involved and risk being called a liar or why would everyone say she was saying it?
Isn't this the type of question that resulted in a mistrial?
Asking me that question forces me to speculate.
Better to give your opinion (as coming from prosecution or defense) and back it up with the facts.

I saw on the news that there is some thought that to reach a guilty verdict 11 to 1 would be sufficient and that 10 to 2 would be cause for mistrial. Apparently they have gone that way in some states in the U.S. Not sure I agree with that one.

Maybe we should go the way of screening witnesses more thoroughly. In Canada the prosecuting and defense teams do not ask any questions of the selected witnesses. There is a selection process, but they just look at your age, gender, job, etc. and do not ask you any direct questions.
 

Massagegirl

Banned
Mar 25, 2003
891
1
0
You mean jurors, not witnesses right?

And good point about speculation so let me rephrase that...

Miss Ellard braged about murdering Reena Virk at school and then the police started looking and found Reena Virks dead body floating in the Gorge waterway. Therefore miss Ellard is guilty of second degree murder.
 
Last edited:

wilde

Sinnear Member
Jun 4, 2003
3,041
48
48
So you consider bragging amongst 15 year olds a very reliable source of evidence. When you are at that age you brag about the things that make you popuplar among your peers. Granted not too many 15 year olds brag about killing people, but if you are in with a rough crowd it may not be that far fetched. The contents of the bragging can change fairly rapidly as well. Maybe she bragged about beating her up and by the time the story is told the 20th time, it became that she killed her. There is no question that she was involved but just how involved was she, thats the question. Besides, it was hear say. Still reasonable doubt.
 

ezsmile

Member
Jan 5, 2003
280
2
18
oops....

yah right I meant jurors..sorry about that...dohhh!

When you rephrase your statement the way you have it is much more compelling. Too bad the prosecution didn't think of that - ok I am now talking about things I know nothing about (course what else is new lol)- so it's time I think for me to sit back.
 

carefulone

caring but cautious
Nov 5, 2003
68
0
6
Delta
I know I risk condemnation for saying this, but I am relieved by this result. Right from the beginning, I have thought that the evidence against Kelly Ellard was frightening in its unreliability.

The source of the evidence was essentially:
1) a group of punks who would swarm a single individual and had lied before, and
2) a bunch of teenagers who someone like Kelly Ellard might consider it "cool" to brag about a killing to.

There was ample reason to doubt all the evidence - both the evidence included in the Crown's case, and the evidence from Kelly Ellard herself.

If Kelly Ellard did the crime (and I think it reasonably likely she did) I want her to be convicted and punished harshly.

But even more, I want there to remain in place the important protection, that the evidence in a case must establish that the Crown has proved a case beyond a reasonable doubt, in the minds of ALL twelve independent individuals, who observed all the evidence, and have the opportunity to discuss the evidence between them, with the knowledge that their thoughts and opinions are revealed only to the extent that the jury is unanimous in their verdict.

If you attend trials, or read transcripts, or read appeal decisions, you may start to gain an enhanced appreciation for the wisdom of relying on a jury system that requires unanimity, and prohibits disclosure of the details of jury deliberations. Even though we, in Canada, are prohibited by law from learning about the details of jury deliberation, it is remarkable how prudent jury decisions usually appear to be, when you know details about the evidence thatr they observed.

This protection is particularly important when you are dealing with someone as objectionable as Kelly Ellard appears to be.

For all those who want to remove this safeguard, I pose three questions:
1) have you ever been falsely accused of anything (no matter how minor) by someone in a position of authority? and
2) have you ever been the subject of gossip that was both hurtful and false? and
3) have you ever believed and shared gossip that later turned out to be false?

The dissenting juror may very well be wrong, but if he or she truly had a doubt, based on reason and the evidence observed by him/her, and that doubt survived 4 and one-half days of being sequestered with eleven others who disagreed with him/her, then I applaud that person for having the courage to stand strong in his/her belief.

I also commend the the other eleven jurors. They too could have shirked their responsibility, decided that they didn't want to believe anyone, and voted to acquit, just so they could go home early.

My heart goes out to the Virk family, and the Ellard family too, for that matter. But you do not replace a system that has provided protection for centuries because sometimes the result is neither pleasant or convenient.
 

BYSON

No Gunt
Oct 7, 2003
740
1
18
54
West Coast Of BC
Kelly Ellard has been to court way to Much, If the Crown can't convict the first and second time why keep going,waist of tax payers money, keep trying her over and over and sure they will get what they want.
 

fanichio

Member
May 22, 2004
31
0
6
Burnaby
Personally, I can't believe that some of you are saying that "whether or not she pounded the final nail in virks coffin, she deserves to rot in jail", or that it is more important to get closure for the families than to get justice? What kind of ideas are these? So just because a person is a bad person, they deserve to go to jail for life for a crime they may or may not have commited? Or that this woman's life should just be thrown away so that the families involved can get "closure"? I agree completely with carefulone. None of the witness are reliable, there is no real evidence. How can we say that this woman is guilty? While it sucks when a person slips through the loopholes, and personally i think she probably did do it, my personal opinion is irrelevant. What matters is proof. End of story. If we allow anything else to influence our judicial system, then we are in serious trouble, and far more innocent people will be proven "guilty" than guilty people now get away with crimes. I applaud the 12th juror for sticking to his/her guns and not simply collapsing to the pressure of society and his/her peers.
 

Massagegirl

Banned
Mar 25, 2003
891
1
0
It kinda reminds me of Trevor Mc Callums murder. For those not in the know, he went to a Donut shop on the Gorge (hmm stay away from the Gorge) with his dad and picked a fight (thats the way I heard it anyway, not sure if it was him that started it) with 5 men of the same minority. A scuffle occurred and one of the 5 pulled a shotgun out and shot Trevor point blank right there in the parking lot. The 5 then returned to Vancouver where they reside and were all picked up by the RCMP. But because they were similar in looks, McCallum senior couldn't pick out the perp who did the shooting, and because none of the 5 talked, they all got off scott free. So I would be interested in knowing what everyones thoughts are in that particular case. Should they all have been charged with obstruction of justice at least? Or what?

It kinda makes me wonder, in another country, would they have gotten off, or would the truth have been ascertained somehow?

PS I tried to search for more info but there isn't even a memorial site for him, and one article I did find mentions it but not factually and it said the 5 were being charged with second degree murder in 1995, a year later. Does anyone remember the details? Also I had McCallum senior pointed out to me once,and does he ever look like a broken man, I don't think anyone would get over having their son die in their arms, but his eyes were haunted and 3 years had passed by then!:(
 

brianwarner

Banned
Jul 20, 2003
123
0
0
51
All I know is, don't hang around teenage girls. They could kill you.
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts