What makes a bad or useless review

angry anderson

Well-known member
Nov 8, 2014
1,963
2,274
113
Ok. I NEVER do this, but that 👆 is triggering.

It's spelled "SHILL" which means it's pronounced "shill".

If you spell it "SCHILL" it's pronounced "skill" as in school.
So why don't they spell it Schill saw?
Why don't they pronounce Schopenhauer Skopenhauer?
Why don't they pronounce Scheisse Skeisse?
Or pronounce Auschwitz Auskwits?
 
Last edited:

GeeBeeP

On a secret journey through PleasureTown.
Dec 28, 2019
593
1,190
93
To be fair Drifting off topic is kind of a tradition on here :)

Back on topic. Perhaps an unpopular opinion but I honestly don’t need to read a complete play by play of a guys time. I guess it's a good way to tell the reader what services were on the table, but it often reads like Penthouse Forum fiction most of the time. I often get the sense that the reviewer is telling us about his time here because he can’t tell anyone else in his life about how he spent his evening. (and hey, I can sympathise with that problem)

Just tell me that she’s real, pics are accurate, incall was clean and in a safe location, and if you found her to be a nice person to spend time with. Maybe add is some spice to give an impression of the service, but I don’t need an x-rated romance novel. We get it, ya got laid and enjoyed it. :)
 

OF_manager

Banned
Jan 4, 2024
92
279
53
If it lacks details on the photographs in ad being recent or accurate depictions of their present physical state. Women take photos of themselves seventeen times a day but post ads with photos from pre Covid lockdowns and get upset when we walk.
There really isnt an excuse for pictures that are out dated.
One of those "boudoir" photoshoots costs like $100 and alot of photographers would be willing to do it for free.
Iphone cameras are better than a lot of professional cameras today, get one of your friends to snap some pics for you, or get a $15 tripod off amazon and take them yourself.
I thought we were supposed to champion sex work as "real work" maybe do some work then.

I dont want to come off as an asshole but I think its safe to assume that any provider who isn't using pictures that were taken in the past year in their ads is basically telling us that they are aging poorly, have put on weight, and look worse now than they did when their pictures were taken.
 

GeeBeeP

On a secret journey through PleasureTown.
Dec 28, 2019
593
1,190
93
There really isnt an excuse for pictures that are out dated.
One of those "boudoir" photoshoots costs like $100 and alot of photographers would be willing to do it for free.
Iphone cameras are better than a lot of professional cameras today, get one of your friends to snap some pics for you, or get a $15 tripod off amazon and take them yourself.
I thought we were supposed to champion sex work as "real work" maybe do some work then.

I dont want to come off as an asshole but I think its safe to assume that any provider who isn't using pictures that were taken in the past year in their ads is basically telling us that they are aging poorly, have put on weight, and look worse now than they did when their pictures were taken.
This is a big reason I like to use Twitter when considering a new SP (Yeah I’m still calling it Twitter, suck it Elon)

Candid shots of a girls vacation, dates, and times with other SP friends give a much more accurate impression of not only her personality but her current look.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Giselle Montreal

grusse

Well-known member
Feb 18, 2010
3,869
2,087
113
To be fair Drifting off topic is kind of a tradition on here :)

Back on topic. Perhaps an unpopular opinion but I honestly don’t need to read a complete play by play of a guys time. I guess it's a good way to tell the reader what services were on the table, but it often reads like Penthouse Forum fiction most of the time. I often get the sense that the reviewer is telling us about his time here because he can’t tell anyone else in his life about how he spent his evening. (and hey, I can sympathise with that problem)

Just tell me that she’s real, pics are accurate, incall was clean and in a safe location, and if you found her to be a nice person to spend time with. Maybe add is some spice to give an impression of the service, but I don’t need an x-rated romance novel. We get it, ya got laid and enjoyed it. :)
when I read a review I look for what's said about the SP's appearance..i.e. if it's anywhere close to the ad (AF excepted..they're real)
and what's available,eg BBBJ,DATY,etc.I always think YMMV regardless of what is written, good or otherwise, about service levels.

As for the novellas, I enjoy the (unintentional) humour of the boaster,oops, I mean poster, thinking we're enthralled by his self-proclaimed
specialist sexual attributes.

when I write a review I try to keep it brief, like Joe Friday said, "just the facts.."
 

OF_manager

Banned
Jan 4, 2024
92
279
53
This is a big reason I like to use Twitter when considering a new SP (Yeah I’m still calling it Twitter, suck it Elon)

Candid shots of a girls vacation, dates, and times with other SP friends give a much more accurate impression of not only her personality but her current look.
Yeah I definitely prefer girls who do this, bonus if its videos. but I also see alot of girls on twitter just recycling old photos alot of the time, in those cases its no different. then you get into facetune, filters, angles, and even that ai video stuff , and you really dont have a fool proof method of knowing their current look anymore.
 

white Ninja

Banned
Dec 8, 2021
2,196
3,165
113
This right here. Im actually booked in to see a touring SP who looks very attractive, who is visiting here in a couple weeks time, her rates are quite high. I didnt do a deep dive until I was booked it, and upon viewing the gallery section of her website, I see all her photos that she uses on her ads and social media are labeled as being taken in 2020-2021 which is a significant amount of time ago.someone's body and face can undergo significant changes in that time frame. Therefore, I am contemplating cancelling the appointment.

I often come across comments and reviews from guys saying, "I saw her a few years ago and her body was amazing." However, it's crucial to acknowledge that a lot can change in just a year or two. In fact, I have personally witnessed people in my own life who have gained weight and become somewhat overweight in just a matter of months.

Id also add, If the provider you are reviewing is aware of your perb account username, we all know we arent getting an objective or unbiased review from you.
True dat , a lot can change over a few yrs .
 
  • Like
Reactions: rizzgod

Bunghole1

Well-known member
Mar 13, 2020
820
1,198
93
When someone is reviewing asian providers and says they are as young as the profile or close to it but it ends up being way off once you see for yourself in person. Time to get your eyes checked me thinks.
 

Sibar

Active member
Nov 1, 2015
108
27
28
Vancouver Richmond
I know one post stated in along the lines of, poster is reviewing the same AMP or SP too often. I frequent the Marpole area, but don't post all the time. So once I get to somewhere new, I try to do a review.
 
  • Like
Reactions: white Ninja

masterpoonhunter

"Marriage should be a renewable contract"
Sep 15, 2019
3,177
5,422
113
Banned , banned and banned if caught.

It might take longer than we would hope for them to get the axe but the moderators are pretty good at tracking those guys
Hmm
Fair bit of foresight with that post fellow perbite, given a recent permanent ban of a prolific poster on these forums.
 

plodoublesuited

Active member
Jul 28, 2023
119
161
43
When new accounts post reviews of SPs (usually after negative comments had been posted)

"I have seen xxx 3 (multiple) times so far and she's amazing.
10/10!!!"
 
  • Like
Reactions: white Ninja

white Ninja

Banned
Dec 8, 2021
2,196
3,165
113
There really isnt an excuse for pictures that are out dated.
One of those "boudoir" photoshoots costs like $100 and alot of photographers would be willing to do it for free.
Iphone cameras are better than a lot of professional cameras today, get one of your friends to snap some pics for you, or get a $15 tripod off amazon and take them yourself.
I thought we were supposed to champion sex work as "real work" maybe do some work then.

I dont want to come off as an asshole but I think its safe to assume that any provider who isn't using pictures that were taken in the past year in their ads is basically telling us that they are aging poorly, have put on weight, and look worse now than they did when their pictures were taken.
I think within 5 yrs is fair . And not showing their face in completely understandable.

But fake picture or stolen from another LL add is just a HUGE TURN OFF !
 

white Ninja

Banned
Dec 8, 2021
2,196
3,165
113
Moreso in regards to 411 posts rather than reviews, but

its pretty annoying when I post a 411 seeking recommendations for a provider that possesses particular qualities.(ex. age, body type etc) and someone comes in and recommends an SP who fits non of the criteria I was looking for. oftentimes you will look at their post history and they are promoting the same one or two SP's all over the site.

Even more annoying is when its an SP who doesn't fit the criteria who comes in and promotes herself in a 411 thread
It might actually be the sp themselves behind the handle .
I recall seeing in Perbatory they had discovered 5 handles came From the same Location.

All 5 handles started threads about the exact same provider , then each handle commented on the other handles threads.

They all promoted the exact same girl and literally No One else .

I figured thats either one hell of a fanboy - white knight or the actual provider herself working over time .
 
  • Like
Reactions: $Mansion
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts