I have had both and neither are up there in terms of customer service.
You apparently ignored this comment al.
Both in business and in personal life I have had both. I have left both and I am now back with Shaw for several reasons most of which were performance, support, cost etc.
The 3 year contract isn't a big thing - certainly not a major issue the way Shaw would like it to be. Everyone has contracts for their car, their cell phone, their home.
What rules is service, reliability and price
Since I switched to Telus for phone, tv and internet at the end of August - I've had no problems at all.
No more 4 hours on hold with Shaw
No more having to wait at home for a Shaw technician that doesn't come. (the Telus technician phoned to confirm that I was home and say that they would be there in 30 minutes)
$80 a month savings over the almost exactly the same package of services.
So - no contract = 4 hour hold times and $80 a month more in cost
I'll accept the 3 year contract.
I haven't bothered to read your savvy investor thread. Must be something about Telus you like other than their apparent excellent service.
BTW, I sell to both corporations for their system related work. I have nothing but respect for their engineering, program management and purchasing operations. My beef with both, mainly Telus has been their lack of support, we will get to it when it's convenient to us attitude.
If I have had a problem with support from Shaw, I have always opted for their call back service. Not once have I waited more than 45 minutes for a return call.
You know you are in the midst of a honeymoon with them and they want you to be happy. Trust me, 18 to 24 months down the road you will look back upon this thread and shake your head.