Massage Adagio

No Review List???

Status
Not open for further replies.

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
A few days ago a thread popped up about a certain SP (not Large Lips). The SP being asked about posted a response indicating that she was on a "no review list" and that if the thread was not terminated immediately, she would remove it herself.

I, in turn, added my 2cents. My feeling was that this is a review board and and that as such, guys come here to either post reviews (positive or negative) or to research SPs so as to make an informed decision.

Strangely enough, the thread, very shortly thereafter, disappeared.

Is it true that there is a "no review list" on this board? Can any SP simply because she doesn't like any negative comments have the option of becoming "invisable" or "off limits" to the members of this board?
 

curmudgeon

Member
Aug 16, 2003
317
0
16
57
Vancouver
There is a "no review" list. There are certain SPs that specifically request no-reviews (positive or negative). Any posted review of those SPs are removed when a moderator sees it.

For a brief time (a few weeks), this list was public, but not since.
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
wtf!!??

I don't get it. What's the point of having this board then? Personally, I don't believe this list exists. I don't see the logic behind it. It, simply put, seems contrary to the nature of this board. Perhaps a mod can clarify or, at least, confirm the existance of this list.
 

kehoe

I shoulda been a farmer
Apr 16, 2003
784
0
0
I was part of that thread too. It's a joke and if you are part of a "no review list" then you should not be allowed on this board either. Fair is fair.
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
No! I strongly disagree. The very integrity of this review board is now in question. The question should not be whether or not the list should be published - it should be about whether or not it should even exist.
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
Sorry Mod. I posted my last comment before seeing that you had posted a policy statement. I will read what you have to say before commenting further.
 

kalel

Member
Sep 16, 2006
667
10
18
.

i don't mind the no review list. while i think there are probably some sp's out there who will take advantage of this and offer bad or rushed service, it does ultimately hurt their business as well. think of how much more business some of the women have gotten because of the good reviews they've received. the women on the no review list don't have that luxury because of their personal choice. there are many perberts who only see an sp after a positive review.

i do think that if we can't review certain sp's we should atleast be able to comment on the service with a minimum of words (eg good or bad, or L/A/S).
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
After reading Sheik's comments, I'm still not convinced that this is a decision that is in the best interest of the board. Whereas I respect that the mods have to make tough calls sometimes in the interest of safety or liability, I think that it open the doors to a flood of poor SPs opting to be excluded because they "said so". Again, I feel that this policy seriously undermines the integrity of this board.
 

Olmac

New member
Apr 25, 2003
123
0
0
Here's a thought, post the DNR list for all to see so that mistakes don't happen. We then can put them on our personal DNS (do not see) list.:rolleyes:
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
Here's a thought, post the DNR list for all to see so that mistakes don't happen. We then can put them on our personal DNS (do not see) list.:rolleyes:
In effect, the choice to not be reviewed would be, a negative review.
 

kehoe

I shoulda been a farmer
Apr 16, 2003
784
0
0
After reading Sheik's comments, I'm still not convinced that this is a decision that is in the best interest of the board. Whereas I respect that the mods have to make tough calls sometimes in the interest of safety or liability, I think that it open the doors to a flood of poor SPs opting to be excluded because they "said so". Again, I feel that this policy seriously undermines the integrity of this board.
exactly the way I feel. Also, any sp's on this no review list should also not be allowed to post and take partin any part of the board.
 

visiting

Active member
Oct 23, 2005
997
1
38
right behind you!
I understand and apreciate that some girls want in on the NRP, but just find it funny that often when a review is pulled, the poster starts this new thread about NRP... I would think to make things simple the names on this list should be listed, not thier reasons.

Then I would be comfortable that the mods, as in Sheik's post, would not honor that if the lady in question ...

from sheik's Post
We will not respect an NRP if the girl consistantly has bad reviews or its a bait and switch operation
 

kehoe

I shoulda been a farmer
Apr 16, 2003
784
0
0

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
I have been a member of this board for almost 4 years now. I understand that the Mod has the final decision. That's an understanding we have to ensure the smooth and civil operation of this board. However, I, and I am sure, many others, would urge the mod to re-consider this policy.

Respectfully,
Scubadude
 

Fred Zed

Administrator
May 11, 2002
784
267
63
UP ABOVE SMILING
No! I strongly disagree. The very integrity of this review board is now in question. The question should not be whether or not the list should be published - it should be about whether or not it should even exist.


Integrity of the review board ? ...Unless the lady is a rip - off or scam artist then ofcourse she can opt for no review. Boards provide the user with different ways of interacting with other members and ladies all for free, we never guarantee we will carry reviews of all the ladies out there. Learn to make the best use of what you have instead of asking what you cannot get.
 

visiting

Active member
Oct 23, 2005
997
1
38
right behind you!
yep, shooting themselves in the foot so to speak.
Maybe not.... First Perb is not the only source of info, lets face it, most of us didn't find PERB on the first day we started pooning....


So now you have all these placed to advertise, including CL, so how do you know if she is new or not if you can't find a review on Perb?


Yes some of us only like to see well reviewed ladies, but those with a more adventurous side would see them... Thinking about Anita, She doesn't have great reviews but people still see her...
 

jjinvan

New member
Apr 4, 2005
684
0
0
I can think of at least one SP who regularly pulled the 'bait and switch' trick, and at least 3 times that people posted either a review or a neighbourhood watch or a post in the lounge about her bait and switch tactics, but *poof* the thread disappeared.

Add that to the policy that says that an SP can post fake 'self reviews' under an assumed name, without them being deleted...

Guys guess what, this board exists as an advertising medium for the SPs, and to collect advertising fees from the SPs.

If you want an actual review board, you'll have to look elsewhere, that isn't what you'll find here.

With that in mind, there are some great SPs on here, and you can generally find out about services and prices etc... but keep in mind that it is buyer beware, and that this an escort advertising board and not a review board.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
Scubadude

Keep in mind we are talking about a human beings using their bodies as vehicles to provide pleasure and not an inanimate object like a toaster oven or car. This business is their livelihood.

1)This board can be a wealth of information for those requesting it however this board mainly targets a particuler demographic: the one that willingly chooses to pay for services and time of a SP in the low to mid price bracket.

I've seen this myself: a mid-price SP raising her rates and the flood of negative remarks come in bordering on reviewing. Even though the SP has historically provided formidable service once she has raised her rates it gives the reviewers a chance to knock the SP off her pedestal. If I raise my rates I'd put money on it that a few false negative reviews will crop up.

There is also a fine line between what information is publically requested from a prospective pooner and what is information is exchanged by Private Message.

Sure, it's a possibility that having a DNR List would have service-poor SPs to ply their trade without exposure but I have observed that those type of providers do not last long in the industry. They're not usually smart enough to request the policy.

What's your solution?

2)How about those false negative reviews? Only the SP and reviewer would know for sure what had happened in the session. Do we allow reviews where there is a case of mistaken identity (happened to me twice)? Do we allow reviews from people with an agenda that can and are determined to immobilize the business of a SP or can the SP on a DNR List separate fact from fiction by stopping the process from starting in the first place?
What's your solution?

The list should exist as requested from the SP out of respect not to be abused but should be posted publically.
 

jjinvan

New member
Apr 4, 2005
684
0
0
Sure, it's a possibility that having a DNR List would have service-poor SPs to ply their trade without exposure but I have observed that those type of providers do not last long in the industry. They're not usually smart enough to request the policy.
I can think of at least a half dozen off the top of my head, and all of them have been (or were) around for a looooong time and all their reviews were deleted by the mods..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts