Hockey Pool Advice

Which of these guys would you pick?

  • Evgeni Malkin

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Steve Stamkos

    Votes: 5 50.0%
  • Alex Ovechkin

    Votes: 1 10.0%
  • Sidney Crosby

    Votes: 4 40.0%

  • Total voters
    10
  • Poll closed .

AA_Train

Registered AWESOME
Jul 19, 2007
768
2
18
This year I plan to enter a hockey pool organized by one of the guys at work and a few of his other buddies. It's a pick one per group style of pool and the prize money is pretty decent, as 60 or 70 people enter at $20 a pop. There's 5 players per group except for the first group which has only 4 which contains the elite of the elite. If you were to pick one of them as your anchor, which one would it be?
 

bcneil

I am from BC
Aug 24, 2007
2,095
0
36
Sidney................
 

AA_Train

Registered AWESOME
Jul 19, 2007
768
2
18
Doesn't Stamkos have the lowest injury risk out of all of them?
That's my logic and why I am kind of leaning towards him. Crosby's durability is my only concern with him because you know the points are there. Guys like Kunitz and Neal are in the pool too and I feel if I pick Crosby I need to pick them as it is very possible that's who Sid's linemates will be and I could get a shit ton of points with them in tow.
 

BORKO

Everything is AWESOME!!!
Jun 3, 2013
1,165
0
36
Sexy Fun Land
That's my logic and why I am kind of leaning towards him. Crosby's durability is my only concern with him because you know the points are there. Guys like Kunitz and Neal are in the pool too and I feel if I pick Crosby I need to pick them as it is very possible that's who Sid's linemates will be and I could get a shit ton of points with them in tow.
Probably better to diversify in case Crosby goes down. Isn't Neal on Malkin's line?
 

AA_Train

Registered AWESOME
Jul 19, 2007
768
2
18
Probably better to diversify in case Crosby goes down. Isn't Neal on Malkin's line?
Neal has played with both in the past, though more recently with Malkin because of Iginla's arrival in Pittsburgh. I've done the all your eggs in one basket approach in pools before, with mixed results. If everyone stays healthy, SCORE!!! If not, it can all fall apart.
 

BORKO

Everything is AWESOME!!!
Jun 3, 2013
1,165
0
36
Sexy Fun Land
Neal has played with both in the past, though more recently with Malkin because of Iginla's arrival in Pittsburgh. I've done the all your eggs in one basket approach in pools before, with mixed results. If everyone stays healthy, SCORE!!! If not, it can all fall apart.
Probably better to use that approach when their is a history of health. I think the best approach in fantasy is to just take the BPA.
 

bcneil

I am from BC
Aug 24, 2007
2,095
0
36
With this type of pool with a player per group, Sidney becomes the key.
If he stays healthy, he probably wins his group by 30 points.
Out of 70 people 50-60 will pick him. If you don't have him, it will be impossible to make up that many points against that many people.
The rest of the groupings will have less variance.

If he does have injury problems. If its 10 games or whatever then its a wash.
But if he does miss a significant amount of time, you are screwed if you have him.
The people who didn't pick him will have the best chance to win, and there will be 10-20 people.

Can you buy 2 entries? That's what I would do, a Crosby and non-Crosby team
 

BORKO

Everything is AWESOME!!!
Jun 3, 2013
1,165
0
36
Sexy Fun Land
With this type of pool with a player per group, Sidney becomes the key.
If he stays healthy, he probably wins his group by 30 points.
Out of 70 people 50-60 will pick him. If you don't have him, it will be impossible to make up that many points against that many people.
The rest of the groupings will have less variance.

If he does have injury problems. If its 10 games or whatever then its a wash.
But if he does miss a significant amount of time, you are screwed if you have him.
The people who didn't pick him will have the best chance to win, and there will be 10-20 people.

Can you buy 2 entries? That's what I would do, a Crosby and non-Crosby team
You don't think Ovie is back in form?
 

passenger57

Member
Sep 22, 2007
52
4
8
Is it just points based or do goals count more than assists? PIMs are a wash but if shots on goal is a stat used then Stamkos and Ovechkin are the guys to go with.

If Crosby is the most desired player and trades are allowed, I'd take him and trade...

He's too prone to injuries...
 

AA_Train

Registered AWESOME
Jul 19, 2007
768
2
18
Is it just points based or do goals count more than assists? PIMs are a wash but if shots on goal is a stat used then Stamkos and Ovechkin are the guys to go with.

If Crosby is the most desired player and trades are allowed, I'd take him and trade...

He's too prone to injuries...
All points count as equal and there are no trades. The only thing counted are points.
 

AA_Train

Registered AWESOME
Jul 19, 2007
768
2
18
With this type of pool with a player per group, Sidney becomes the key.
If he stays healthy, he probably wins his group by 30 points.
Out of 70 people 50-60 will pick him. If you don't have him, it will be impossible to make up that many points against that many people.
The rest of the groupings will have less variance.

If he does have injury problems. If its 10 games or whatever then its a wash.
But if he does miss a significant amount of time, you are screwed if you have him.
The people who didn't pick him will have the best chance to win, and there will be 10-20 people.

Can you buy 2 entries? That's what I would do, a Crosby and non-Crosby team
There is the option to buy as many teams as one may like but this year I am only buying one.
 

passenger57

Member
Sep 22, 2007
52
4
8
Stamkos>Crosby>Ovi>Malkin

Crosby's not gonna completely blow Stamkos out of water even if healthy and is a major injury risk
 

Daytime Owl

New member
May 24, 2005
146
0
0
Sid Crosby, for two reasons, best player in the NHL and based on the strongest team, I would go with the Penguins.
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts