Your Thoughts on Legalization

CJ Tylers

Retired Sr. Member
Jan 3, 2003
1,643
1
0
47
North Vancouver
Given the recent waste of money by the federal government, one can only wonder what wild (and untimately, most likely conservative) conclusion they will come to.

But let's not consider that which we can't change... but ponder upon the question ourselves.

What are the pro's and cons of legalization? Should it be done? Should it be privatized or placed under the protection of the govermnet?

The only cons I can see are outside influences from so called "moralists", in the US or other parts of Canada. (other countries maybe, but Europe is fairly easy on things of this nature)

My suggestion would be this:

"Escorting" is classified into several categories and anyone involved in the industry is classified as one of the categories. The classifications are not advertised, but are listed on the escorts file with the government.

Private Escort Services (in call, out call) must be liscenced and undergo frequent inspections (STD's, free of drugs and alcohol)... to ensure the safety of the workers and clients is foremost. Testing is required, of course, on an equally frequent basis.

Testing comes free of charge to the employee, the company pays for it as a condition of it's business liscence. Accordingly, benefits and vacation pay are accorded to the employee.

Employees are subjected to normal taxation.

Also, all reports of bad clients and

Next, private escorts (singular) must aquire an operating liscence (nominal fee) and undergo testing as per normal. They have a slightly more free way of conducting business, but but display an up to date certificate showing their last test date for STD's. Again, they have access to a center to report bad clients... they can peruse and add new entries. Also, under a privacy law, they do not have to inform a landlord of their practive as long as it is discreet. (debatable, but worth a discussion)

Finally, the "escorts" previously found on the streets. These girls would be relocated to government run facilities. Aside from mandatory testing for drugs, alcohol and STD's, they would also have rehabilitation programs as either available or mandatory. Family support programs and counseling facilities should also be included. If re education funding is required, it should be something accessible.

Basically, the last category is for those who find themselves in the "profession" by something other than direct choice. Drug addiction, a family to feed, poor self image... all these things can drive someone to the streets... most would like to return to a more "normal life" so do what you can to provide that. Get them standing on their own two feet.

The business operating fees & liscences obtained from the Escorting Agencies and independants could have the majority of their earnings earmarked for supporting the infrastructure of the last agency. Also, the money currently being wasted patrolling and arresting johns could be redirected to actually HELPING the people who need help... a radical concept for a government.

Now, I aslo have a theory that single mothers should have free access to education and housing if they are on welfare. Child care should be provided while they are at school.... not luxurious surroundings, some might even be shared... but the goal would be to get them off welfare ASAP and into the tax paying work force... the courses taken must be relevant to a job and good grades must be maintained.

What I'm driving at over all is the improvement of working conditions, the aiding of those who aren't in the profession by choice and the return of revenue from this endeavor...and the saving of expenditure on policing and other social costs.

Some might ask what about other people who are down on their luck, such as many of the d/t east side residents. Well, I don't have all the answers... if someone doesn't want to improve themselves or is incapable of it, there's only so much that can be done.

But that's a discussion for another time...

So what are your thoughts, Perbians?
 

Massagegirl

Banned
Mar 25, 2003
891
1
0
I'm for decriminalizing in all forms, except pimping, but am against legalization. But that's just cuz I don't like the gov't in my biznass... and I doubt clients want the gov't in theirs either.

Just imagine when an outbreak does happen, the gov't agency will want the personal info of anyone who came in contact with said person, just like a Hepititis outbreak, so they can trace the source. My friend got Hep A and they wanted a list of everyone he was intimate with, and of everywhere he ate. They did trace it to a hot dog vendor on Gov't St who wasn't yet showing symptoms so in that case it was great, but I don't think the SO will be so pleased at the dining choices pooners make. :D
 

luckydog71

Active member
Oct 26, 2003
1,117
0
36
76
Washington State
I associate the word legalize with decriminalize. In other words remove prostitution as a something prohibited by the criminal code. What you go on to describe is major regulations and even government operated brothels.

Most of the sexual activity is now removed from the criminal code; extra-marital affairs, gay and lesbian relationships, I assume I could have sex with my mother and not be put in jail. Hell I could get frisky with my goat and still be OK. But let money change hands as a result of the sexual act and you have committed an illegal act.

Seems dumb to me.

I would guess 99.99% of the people on this site would feel the same way. I am also opposed to government regulations.
 

rickoshadows

Just another member!
May 11, 2002
902
1
18
66
Vancouver Island
First of all, prostitution is not illegal in Canada, most activities associated with it are. The Bawdy house and solicitation rules are what is causing most of the problems. If prostitution were to be treated like any other business, all the regulations to control the more harmfull aspects are already in existence. No one sell hotdogs on a street corner anymore without a permit. Many places are regularly inspected by municipal health departments already. I could go on. but what I'm saying here is all that is required is change of mindset by our elected leaders and a couple of mayors/premiers with enough balls to slap the Police lobby on the side of the head and remind them that we determine which laws they enforce, not them telling us which laws to make.

rickoshadows
 

luckydog71

Active member
Oct 26, 2003
1,117
0
36
76
Washington State
Rick, we have to stop agreeing like this. Is one of us changing our political position? Impossible.

I am mad as hell and I am not going to take it any more. It is not partisan politics, my government and from your comments your government, wants too much say in how I live my life.

I do not need their f***ing protection. I do not need their f***ing wisdom.
What I do need is for them to stay the hell out of my way.

Prostitution is a business and should be subject only to the same laws as any other service oriented business.
 

rickoshadows

Just another member!
May 11, 2002
902
1
18
66
Vancouver Island
luckydog71 said:
Rick, we have to stop agreeing like this. Is one of us changing our political position? Impossible.
I've already scheduled my self to attend a NDP community forum and am planning to join the next anti-American rally, just to make sure my heart is still bleeding Liberal red.

rickoshadows
 

greenvalley

New member
Sep 19, 2004
110
0
0
Make no mistake the only reason the government wants to "legalize" what is already legal is so they can make money from everyone. Not only income tax, but registration fees, license fees, fess for collecting the fees, fees for filling the paper showing reciept of the fees, etc. Of course they will give you lots of talk how they have improved everything, but really its just to give more jobs to paper pushers like themselves. What we have now works for the most part.

This just another part of the cash economy the government wants to stomp out.
 

HaywoodJabloemy

Dissident
Mar 6, 2004
254
0
0
Never the safest place
rickoshadows said:
...If prostitution were to be treated like any other business, all the regulations to control the more harmfull aspects are already in existence...
Yes, I completely agree. Any additional licensing would be more pointless and useless bureaucracy, and other countries have proved this.

Sydney AUS has no licensing for brothels, other than the usual licence any business needs. Local authorities are allowed to close brothels that violate particular regulations about disrupting neighbourhoods, such as not having enough parking, or being in view of a church or school.

The places that have it almost invariably make the licensing requirements pointlessly difficult to meet. For no apparent reason, their numbers are indirectly or directly limited so there's not enough of them to meet the demand, resulting in more illegal than legal brothels. This is already the case in Canada with massage parlours. Certainly in Toronto there are far more MPs either without licences or the wrong kind of licence, than there are with the correct body rub licence, which costs between $6000 and $7000. There are many more willing and able to pay for a licence, but none are available.

Licensing and mandatory health checks for individual sex workers is just plain idiotic. Is there a big problem with insane escorts trying to make themselves and everyone else ill? If there was one like that, do you think she would be bothering to get a licence?

SPs know enough to get their own tests. And if they are forced to display some kind of stupid "tested STD free" certificate like a restaurant approved by the Health Department, the only result would be A-hole customers demanding unprotected sex "since I know you're clean".
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts