...For myself I use the lighter weights and do 3 reps of 15.
As you progress through your workout say after about a half hour
your muscles are toning and getting used to the idea of "labouring".
I then move up to slightly heavier weights by only 5 pounds but have
found this has toned me quite nicely without the desire to "bodybuild".
This for me is all done with free weights concentrating on specific
muscle groups. It is boring as hell but only if you want it to be.
Also which I find very beneficial is between each set of 3 take a damn
good breather for at least 10 - 15 minutes concentrating on breathing
exercises. It replenishes the oxygen needed for the muscles to
wake up again for the next set...