Why should rape not be punishable by death?

Moderator

New member
Mar 23, 2006
227
0
0
I asked all that posted on that thread that they think before they posted and not go back and delete. It was ignored so the thread is gone.:(
 

LonelyGhost

Telefunkin
Apr 26, 2004
3,933
1
0
too bad ... it had some interesting stuff on it ...
 

sdw

New member
Jul 14, 2005
2,185
0
0
Moderator said:
I asked all that posted on that thread that they think before they posted and not go back and delete. It was ignored so the thread is gone.:(
I think that the current defination of Rape is too all encompassing.

Sexual Assault should be graduated:

1. The Hunter. A person who stalks and assaults a known or unknown (to them) victim should be put to death. They have chosen to operate in a premediated manner to satisfy their needs both physical and emotional. The fact is, there are a small number of people who enjoy taking what they want and subjecting others to abuse. There is no recognized treatment for these people and when our current system releases them into the world they do the same thing all over again. Putting them to death reduces the number of victims.

2. The Peter Pan. Otherwise powerless persons who don't have the bravery to assault an adult and therefore assaults children should be put to death. These people put just as much planning into their assault as the Hunters, do it for the same reasons as the Hunters and reoffend just like the Hunters.

3. The loving family member. These "funny uncles", grandfathers and fathers are just as powerless as the Peter Pans, but usually allow the child to seduce them. They are usually not a risk to unknown people. They need to be jailed for life to stop them from increasing the number of generations of a family that do the same crime over and over.

4. The Horny Teen. These are Hunters in training. Their assault usually happens on a date if the victim changes their mind about having sex. Since the Horny Teen thinks that they have put the effort in, they think they deserve to have sex as their reward. The Horny Teen needs to be jailed for long enough that society can be confident that they won't graduate to being a Hunter.

5. The Young Lover. These are kids who have the enthusiatic cooperation of their "victim", however the parents aren't as enthusiatic. There was no crime committed.

Age has nothing to do with this. There are Horny Teens in their 80s just as there are Young Lovers in their 80s. There is as much or more Rape in institutions and old folks homes as there is in the general population.
 

williewheeler

Bionic Member
May 30, 2002
497
1
0
YVR
I say DEATH to the phantom posters!!!!
 
Jun 20, 2005
781
0
0
The Wet Coast
williewheeler said:
I say DEATH to the phantom posters!!!!
I am curious why they have not been named. I'm not necessarily saying they should be banned, but why can't we at least put them in virtual stocks.

I'm also curious about the decision to delete all instead of closing it. And then the moderator posts his comment in this thread and leaves the thread open. Am I reading too much into this?
 

johnston1976

Banned
Aug 12, 2006
49
0
0
Vancouver
The loving family member. These "funny uncles", grandfathers and fathers are just as powerless as the Peter Pans, but usually allow the child to seduce them.
huh? what do you mean allowed the child to seduce them?
 

tedsweettangv

Active member
May 5, 2006
731
80
28
Vancouver
Because a civilized society does not put its members to death. If even one innocent person (wrongly convicted) is put to death, we are all murderers. That is the principle.

On the practical side, there is a drunken night, two people have sex, later one claims it was rape. Is it? Maybe, maybe not, a jury could swing either. Way you don't kill people for that.

On the personal side, if you commit a felony, as far as I am concerned for the duration fo your sentence you have given up all rights as a member of that society. I don't think prisoners should get TV etc. I think the state should be able to use them in anyway that the state sees fit short of ending their life. That includes consmetic and medical tests which are currently performed on animals. Death is too good for them.
 
Jun 20, 2005
781
0
0
The Wet Coast
tedsweettangv said:
Because a civilized society does not put its members to death. If even one innocent person (wrongly convicted) is put to death, we are all murderers. That is the principle.

On the practical side, there is a drunken night, two people have sex, later one claims it was rape. Is it? Maybe, maybe not, a jury could swing either. Way you don't kill people for that.

On the personal side, if you commit a felony, as far as I am concerned for the duration fo your sentence you have given up all rights as a member of that society. I don't think prisoners should get TV etc. I think the state should be able to use them in anyway that the state sees fit short of ending their life. That includes consmetic and medical tests which are currently performed on animals. Death is too good for them.
I'd write a long response, but given your 3rd paragraph, this thread will be gone within 5 minutes.
 

sdw

New member
Jul 14, 2005
2,185
0
0
johnston1976 said:
huh? what do you mean allowed the child to seduce them?
It means they back off pretty quickly if the child says NO loudly and publicly. They think the child is seducing them if the child doesn't say no.

The difference is the funny uncles don't persist if the child says NO, the Hunters and the Peter Pans aren't stopped by the word NO, the victim has to be physically strong enough to fight them off.
 

Moderator

New member
Mar 23, 2006
227
0
0
luv-em-n-lv-em said:
I am curious why they have not been named. I'm not necessarily saying they should be banned, but why can't we at least put them in virtual stocks.

I'm also curious about the decision to delete all instead of closing it. And then the moderator posts his comment in this thread and leaves the thread open. Am I reading too much into this?
Yes you are reading way to much into this! All I was trying to do was get members to think before they posted, The topic at hand was volitile and easily could get out of control.

Even when warned not to, "some" members where posting and then deleting thier comments.

This to me causes a few problems,

1:That it show's in some cases that no thought has been given to the post.

2: Knowing that my warning was on the first page, It was indicating to me that "some" were jumping in with out reading the entire thread.

3: Because deleting posts has started to become a habit with "some" other members are now starting to jump and quote as soon as a post goes up, giving us in some cases an almost endless stream of quotes.

4: Because not all members can see when a post has been deleted and who deleted it, We mods tend to get blamed for editing which in most cases is not true.

I know I can't please all no matter what I do, but the subject matter was not the issue. I ask again that all members take a few moments to think about any post Before hitting the reply button.
 

jakey_edwards

New member
Apr 15, 2005
66
0
0
That was too bad...

I just wanted to say a quick thank you to all who responded. I wish I'd had more time to contemplate the responses. Too bad we had to shut the thread down. I am not finding fault with the Mod. I did not have a chance to go online to see some of the later responses.

On a related item, it looks like Pakistan decided to postpone implementing those reforms. One can only hope better late than never huh?

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/5337752.stm

Jakey
 
Vancouver Escorts