Why are we so quick to call shill?

[American Male]

Fellow PERBites,
I have been noticing, as having many others, the recent trend in pulling out the word SHILL at the drop of a hat. It is rare that a positive review of ANY SP in the past couple of months doesn't get at least one shill response brought against it.

What in the name of hell are all of you people afraid of?

Are you afraid that someone out there is having fun with someone that you don't know about? Are you afraid that someone is just plain having more fun than you?

For the umpteenth time, pooning and sex are fun and emotional experiences. Why are some of you so opposed to someone else sharing in that fun and excitment with the rest of us in a glowing review of an SP that rocked their world?

Maybe that's the issue. Maybe you negative posters out there (and you know who you are) no longer remember what its like to have someone rock your world. Maybe you no longer find joy or fun in sex and pooning and meeting new escorts anymore and you resent those who do.

Just calling it like I see it.

 

[Klaxxon1]

I concur with you, AM. It's one of the reasons why a new member
like me is afraid to post some positive reviews. Trying to avoid arguments
from fellow members who doesn't agree.

 

[Jonesy]

I don't think calling shill is right either.

However, if I have seen someone and then a new poster comes along and says she is a 9/9/9 when at best she is a 5/7/5 and more at home on a fish farm, sorry but something needs to be said to protect others from wasting there money.

That is not calling shill. That is being honest.

If you haven't seen someone, then that is calling shill.

 

[rollerboy]

Why are you afraid to be called a shill? It's not like having acid thrown on your face.

If you post a couple more reviews (of different girls), it'll eventually become obvious that you're not a shill. Questionable tastes, perhaps for some, but to each his own.

Getting burned for a couple hundred on a bad tip irks me. I'd rather be called a shill. Never called anyone out as a shill though. I usually just chalk it up to low standards/temporary insanity.

 

[D.W.B]

yeah thats it

Fellow PERBites,
I have been noticing, as having many others, the recent trend in pulling out the word SHILL at the drop of a hat. It is rare that a positive review of ANY SP in the past couple of months doesn't get at least one shill response brought against it.

What in the name of hell are all of you people afraid of?

Are you afraid that someone out there is having fun with someone that you don't know about? Are you afraid that someone is just plain having more fun than you?

For the umpteenth time, pooning and sex are fun and emotional experiences. Why are some of you so opposed to someone else sharing in that fun and excitment with the rest of us in a glowing review of an SP that rocked their world?

Maybe that's the issue. Maybe you negative posters out there (and you know who you are) no longer remember what its like to have someone rock your world. Maybe you no longer find joy or fun in sex and pooning and meeting new escorts anymore and you resent those who do.

Just calling it like I see it.[/QUOTE


negative posters only do so because of their own defects of character?

i would think that it has more to do with getting ripped off or recieving shitty second rate service than being envious of you and your always perfect sexual encounters but hey wtf do i know?

 

[wolverine]

A newbie would be better off by posting several reviews of different SPs at once. That would erase any doubt re: his credibility right away.

 

[aznboi9]

negative posters only do so because of their own defects of character?
i would think that it has more to do with getting ripped off or recieving shitty second rate service than being envious of you and your always perfect sexual encounters but hey wtf do i know?

I can understand that. Nobody likes going to see an SP based on a positive review only to find the service provided is much lower than that described.

What I have been noticing though is that almost any first time reviewer, regardless of the quality of review, will get a shill accusation. And it actually kind of is insulting when you think about it. You're basically calling the reviewer a liar.

 

[LonelyGhost]

Here's some advice from an ancient pooner ...

1. don't write a review that sounds like the only thing you have ever read is Penthouse Forum ... jeez, i hate that!

If you don't have any writing skills, then stick to the facts: eg: "she had two tits and a wet spot" then describe which one you went for ...

2. don't add a rating if this is your first time having sex: well, with a woman ... who isn't inflatable ...

you may get flamed, but if you simply state that this is your first review and don't feel comfy with counting past your six toes, then we'll cut you some slack.

3. do provide a reasonable description ... particularly if the girl is new ... the most important thing is did she match the picture/description you saw/got and were you happy with what you finally met?

if she opened the door and you puked on her shoes, then we NEED to know that you were either really drunk or she is really ugly ... but be nice! "not my cup of tea" or "didn't live up to the description" is good enough ...

4. don't provide a play by play of your weinie ... there are some visuals that make US puke ...

let us know if she seemed to know what she was doing and if she enjoyed doing it ... if she broke out the salad tongs to handle your goods, and then chased you into a corner to 'finish the icky stuff' then she's probably not going to be around that long or will be strolling the high track by Friday.

5. finally, if she gave you a long list of restrictions or a short menu then try and let us know that too ...

nothing worse than reading that an sp is 'open-minded' and all that it means is she will open the door and your wallet for you ...

As you get some more experience (no the inflatable doll doesn't count) you can get a little more detailed with your reviews ...

but most stuff that is called 'shill' is simply 'shill' and you're not doing yourself or us any favours by writing it ...

 

[therealrex]

I don't see why we need to coddle liars and idiots how will they learn otherwise. The purpose of this board is to provide accurate reviews so guys can get an idea of who is good and who is not service wise. The more we worry about hurting some doofus' feelings the more advantage we give to the scam artists and in the end you end up throwing $200 away. Also if you don't like giving details in your reviews why are you posting here?

 

[Creole Lady Marmalade]

says she is a 9/9/9 when at best she is a 5/7/5 and more at home on a fish farm, sorry but something needs to be said to protect others from wasting there money.

What you have just described is ones' opinion. You might not share it with them. YMMV. I thought we've established that.

 

[crazydancer]

to each of their own... to each of their own....

i mean i may find a sp attractive n i may have good fun time with her. it doesn't mean that u will find her attractive, or having good time. YMMV indeed.

but if there r enough good review for certain sp, other guys who read these review can have some idea what he's gonna get.

 

[westwoody]

What you have just described is ones' opinion. You might not share it with them. YMMV. I thought we've established that.

Just stating a number doesn't really mean much.

As long as the reviewer states his rationale for the rating we can use our own judgement. Let's say he has a fabulous time but at 55 minutes into the session she suggests getting ready to leave, and he gives her a 5 for service because he thinks he's been rushed out the door. Now imagine he calls an agency and the girl sits in the bathroom for ten minutes, comes out and screws him for ten minutes, goes back to the can for ten minutes, and then fucks off after he's paid for an hour...well, okay, I can see why that is a 5 at best.

As long as you can back up your opinion, no problem.

 

[Verb]

I always take review as a READ ONLY thing and I have a mind set only half is true. Sometimes the longtime posters review...I would trust it a little more. I can also understand why people cry SHiLL too....Perb has become a huge money maker for SPs and some will do anything to get the fish hook out there.

 

[Verb]

Oh yeah...here is a tip for the newbies posting reviews....Either write one with the full details or don't. It doesn't help stating how good she looks and say "I am a true gentlemen and I cannot share the intimate details".....That right there is like a useless review.

 

[Penhold]

I don't think calling shill is right either.

However, if I have seen someone and then a new poster comes along and says she is a 9/9/9 when at best she is a 5/7/5 and more at home on a fish farm, sorry but something needs to be said to protect others from wasting there money.

That is not calling shill. That is being honest.

If you haven't seen someone, then that is calling shill.

I generally agree with you - posting your own views of an SP after you've seen her is entirely legitimate and honest. When it's in the same thread, it gives other readers a different perspective - and those who know you and your past reviews can put your comments in perspective in relation to your past reviews.

I find the problem with new posters is that you don't know whether they're legit, experienced, naiive or whatever. For example, how do I know whether the newbie has just seen his first SP (or had his first ever sexual experience ... with other than his own hand)? In that case, he'll likely be so damn grateful that he's had sex he'll think she's the most wonderful and beautiful lady in the world - solid 10's across the board. But if he's a first time poster on this board but I recognize his handle (or he gives it in his post) from another board such as TERB, then it could be he's an experienced hobbiest - you just never know and so you can't much stock in first time posters until they have posted a few more reviews and established their credibility.

Let's not be too quick to call someone a shill - but if it's really dam obvious that it's a shill then yes, it should definitely be called out. Not for us more experienced guys but to save other newbies and all the lurkers who are too afraid to post from falling into the trap and going to see the SP that's been shilled.

Penhold
______________________________
Save a newbie, report a shill.

 

[Creole Lady Marmalade]

My Bad

Sorry folks,

should've been clearer. I was actually referring to the looks scale/category and the grouping and gauging of all the SPs in a general manner, based on looks, instead of separating them where they should be.

ie. blondes, brunettes, busty blonde, busty brunette, busty blonde spinner, busty blonde BBW, etc.


Of course, service-wise it's easy to compare. Compare away!!!

 

[American Male]

What I have been noticing though is that almost any first time reviewer, regardless of the quality of review, will get a shill accusation. And it actually kind of is insulting when you think about it. You're basically calling the reviewer a liar.

Thanks for stating this very plainly, aznboi9. This has been my impression of the shill accusations of newbies. Why do so many of you want to accuse a newbie of being a liar? You really don't know that the info in the review is accurate or not. You don't know that its a new SP hiding behind a fake name. If you disagree with their ranking, fine, say that. If you want to ask a question, fine, do that. If you want to put in your two cents, fine, add your opinion. But stop calling the guy a liar. Stop calling him a shill. Let the mods worry about SPs promoting themselves by posting false reviews. That is part of their role on PERB.

Give the new guys a break, would da? We were all new guys once.

 

[cute~kimmy]

just casting my hook!

....Perb has become a huge money maker for SPs and some will do anything to get the fish hook out there.[/QUOTE]

sometimes they even write replies all over the place just so their names out there! Thats like shilling for themselves! hahaha where did the word shilling come from anyways?

 

[Jonesy]

....Perb has become a huge money maker for SPs and some will do anything to get the fish hook out there.

....sometimes they even write replies all over the place just so their names out there! Thats like shilling for themselves! hahaha where did the word shilling come from anyways?

Bingo. It took a SP to put this into the proper perspective.

Well said.

 

[Creole Lady Marmalade]

....Perb has become a huge money maker for SPs and some will do anything to get the fish hook out there.

sometimes they even write replies all over the place just so their names out there! Thats like shilling for themselves! hahaha where did the word shilling come from anyways?[/QUOTE]


Yes, but some of us pay for that privilege.

A lot of replies can actually hurt them. Take Carole for example, with what she has been posting the last 2+weeks, I'd never want to see her if I was a pooner. Or those SPs who are quick on the defensive or ones who lack confidence, whiners and the blatantly desperate.