The Porn Dude

What promps a post?

plauing

Member
Aug 10, 2004
61
0
6
A recent thread in the soap opera aka the Saskatchewan section made reference to the types of reviews that people post (+ve VS -ve). So Judging from the number of visits that I think take place and the number of reviews I see on the board I think there is a significant number that go "unreported" so I'm curious What prompts a post?

I tend to post only the exceptional negatives for one reason: to help fellow pooners avoid disappointment

I am less likely to initiate a positive review because I think that the all mighty YMMV, chemistry, or what ever you want to call it does make a difference with any human interaction. When I see a gal I try real hard to find out what she enjoys because as corny as it sounds what I get real pleasure form is form my partner having a good time. I have had more then one good time with out even making it to the finish line but my SP, at the very minimum giving me a couple of good fakes. I tend to add my positive comments to an existing post.

That and people would get tired of reading about Sydney

Now that i read this, if everyone thought like this there wouldn't be many positve reviews now would there but I'm still going to post it.
 

wpgguy

Banned
May 13, 2005
674
3
0
Interesting view point.

Absolutely right about posting the negative reviews to help others avoid disappointment. I have not had a bad pooning experience since I started browsing on the forums aside from one right at the start. That's the last time the little head overruled the big head.

I also think your right that most don't post good or bad reviews and most good ones go unreported by those who do post. IMHO I think there are a few reasons that the good reviews do not get posted as often as they could.

1) Sydney is the perfect example, what more can you say, her reputation speaks for itself.

2) As a general rule I think people speak up much more quickly when they are mad, upset etc. They need to vent when they feel they have been cheated but not so much if they leave happy.

3) I think the main reason you don't see to many positive reviews. We don't want to share our favorites. If a girl gets great review after great review, we all know it's going to be harder to get an appointment and her rates could go up or service could go down or both.

I try to post on most of the girls I've seen, good or bad, as if no one posts what good is the board. The posts and PM's of others have saved me considerably in the last two years and it's the least I can do to give something back and not just lurk.

YMMV plays a huge part in the overall experience, I've had great times with girls that others did not and times when after I left I didn't know what all the fuss was about. Can't agree more about trying to find out what the girl likes as well, chances are if she's uncomfortable it's not going to be a session to remember.

Wpgguy
 
Last edited:

Avery

Gentleman Horndog
Jul 7, 2003
4,770
22
38
Winnipeg
I always review a lady the first time I see her. The only exception has been two occasions when the ladies have asked me BEFOREHAND not to post reviews, as long as I'm satisfied. In both cases, I was very satisfied, and I respected their wishes.

I've never been afraid to post negative or so-so reviews. I've pooned long enough to tell the difference between a lack of chemistry/YMMV and plain, old, crappy attitude and service.

I don't agree with the comments about positive reviews using Sydney as an example. I base decisions to see ladies on their reviews and who posted them. The greater the preponderance of good reviews on a lady, the better. Ten positive reviews will probably make me ignore one negative review. However, if there's only one positive and one negative review on a lady, I generally err on the side of caution, and wait for more reviews.
 

LonelyGhost

Telefunkin
Apr 26, 2004
3,933
1
0
under another name i posted many reviews, good and bad: if i was
asked not to post any I respected that wish (which leads to the
whole 'DNR' list business ...)

the question of whether to post pos versus neg reviews is not
as important as the issue of utility: many provide too much of
the Penthouse Forum Letters detail that is immature and rather
tasteless as well.

nothing wrong with saying you had a great time, we don't need
the slobbering details!

same with getting into personal details and nitpicking ... if there's
a glaring flaw or misrepresentation: eg; she's advertised as a 19 year old virgin
and you're greeted by a hirsuite 40 year old with a clit bigger than
your dick, then by all means share.

but if she had a pimple on her ass give us a bleeping break!

Finally, attitude is EVERYTHING in this business ... an sp with a
great attitude and marginal looks is worth more than the hot chick
with the cold attitude every time!

If some sp made you feel like a King we don't need to know how,
just where to get in contact with her.
 

wpgguy

Banned
May 13, 2005
674
3
0
I don't agree with the comments about positive reviews using Sydney as an example.
I don't really follow you here Avery. Do you mean a) if a lady as tons of good reviews people will still post as they normally would, b) it doesn't matter if a lady has many reviews we should still post another or am I missing your point completely?
 

Avery

Gentleman Horndog
Jul 7, 2003
4,770
22
38
Winnipeg
I don't really follow you here Avery. Do you mean a) if a lady as tons of good reviews people will still post as they normally would, b) it doesn't matter if a lady has many reviews we should still post another or am I missing your point completely?
I meant (b). I like to see as many reviews as possible on a given lady. If they're all positive, so much the better. IMO, just because a lady has many positive reviews doesn't mean a happy pooner shouldn't post another one. They're all worthwhile.
 

wpgguy

Banned
May 13, 2005
674
3
0
OK, thanks for the clarification. I agree the more the merrier, it's just that when I saw Sydney in Feb. I almost didn't post a review as there was already so much written about her in the past.
 

alyb

New member
Apr 9, 2007
180
0
0
lol, the soap opera...

yeah, i guess you could say so. hence why i refuse to do much more posting there. from now on, everyone knows where i stand... shouldn't need to say much more.

-----
pertaining more specifically to this thread... most people (myself entirely included), put wayyyy too much faith into perb. yes, you may run across 2 positive reviews of someone followed my 3 negatives and think "no way", however, thats generally the top of the ice burg. there could be 20 other positive reviews out there that haven't been posted, and if one of the negatives was...well...slightly inaccurate, now in reality...you have a girl with about a 22 pos/3neg "rating". Looks a whole lot different, doesnt it?

Also could swing either way. Maybe a girl has an immaculate perb reputation but really let down some people that dont post, etc...

Anyway, I get too worked up about what people have to say on perb sometimes (never in terms of my reviews, but just their personal comments about my business, etc...) and at the end of the day, it really doesnt matter. If you put too much of your faith into these boards I have a feeling, like I believe WPG GUY said, sometimes youre going to wonder "what all the fuss was about" anyway....

Aly
 

gchuck

Member
Nov 13, 2004
279
0
16
I have to differ a little bit with you on this, Aly. I do have a lot of faith in the information on these boards, if not always the maturity with which some issues are dealt with:rolleyes: . I'm with Wpg guy in that since I started doing research on the Boards I have not had a single bad experience with anyone who was positively reviewed on the board, and I definitely agree with Avery that a BUNCH of positive reviews makes a person that much more confident in booking with a given SP, and puts the odd negative review in clearer perspective as the exception to the rule. My first experience using a review board was TERB; the girl I ended up seeing had a bunch of glowing reviews and a couple of less than stellar ones, and my experience with her was fantastic. In Saskatchewan PERB led me to Sydney, to Jazmine, to Megan, and to you; all have been really great experiences. In most instances, I have at least written a quick "me too" post just to confirm what others have said; you don't necessarily have to write a novel to add a little more credibility to what's already been said. I'm almost the opposite of Plauing, however; I tend to post positives without hesitation, but I really give a lot of thought before posting anything negative; I know I would want that info posted if I was researching that particular SP, but you have to be very, very careful to be fair and accurate in the process.

I guess my point is twofold:
1) The information on the boards, in my experience, has been extremely accurate and useful
2) I think it's always a good idea to write even a couple of lines to confirm or refute what's been posted previously. The more posts there have been relating to an individual SP, the more likely the majority opinion is to be accurate.

The thinking in point 2 is exactly why I intend to see Aleeria soon; rather than just rely on the 2 reviews posted on the Sask board, which basically represent a coin toss, I went back and searched the boards for reviews from Calgary; there are lots of them, and the majority by far are extremely positive.

Gee, this is nice...such a respectful little conversation we're all having here! Take care, everybody.
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
Gchuck brings up some good points......Perb isn't the only resource so we should all really do our homework prior to commiting to seeing anyone.
I never hesitate to review either good or bad. I think that the good gets on the boards a lot more than the bad because many pooners don't want to deal with backlash that usually accompanies neg reviews.
It most certainly is harder to do a neg one and I'm sure it is much harder to read one about one's self and stay unemotional about it. But the neg is almost more important, in my mind, than the positive.
 

Avery

Gentleman Horndog
Jul 7, 2003
4,770
22
38
Winnipeg
...yes, you may run across 2 positive reviews of someone followed my 3 negatives and think "no way", however, thats generally the top of the ice burg. there could be 20 other positive reviews out there that haven't been posted, and if one of the negatives was...well...slightly inaccurate, now in reality...you have a girl with about a 22 pos/3neg "rating". Looks a whole lot different, doesnt it?
That's precisely why I encourage pooners to write reviews. Just because a lady has a few positive reviews doesn't mean satisfied clients shouldn't bother to post more.

The other factor, as I said earlier, is that I look at who posted the reviews. Some reviewers have a long history and can be relied upon; others can't, and some newbies are unknown quantities. However, I've never had a bad experience with ladies who have had mostly positive reviews on the boards. My only bad times have been with unreviewed ladies where I TOFTT.
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts