What....is Evil?

CJ Tylers

Retired Sr. Member
Jan 3, 2003
1,643
1
0
47
North Vancouver
Just a thought that popped into my head the other day, when I read a book on the subject.

How do we define evil? What quality or substance denotes evil in our society, or, in our morality? When we ascribe the quality of "evile", or "vile", or any derivative of the word to someone... what do we mean, and what do we read into such an adjective?

Has the term become diluted with use? S. Harper has been called evil by some, as has Hitler. What about people formerly referred to as evil... but later on are shown to be mentally or emotionally deficient (that being the source of their behaviors). Do you believe that evil is at the root of their being, or does the abnormality in them absolve them of that taint?

Speaking of taint, how does the concept translate between religions, traditions and societies with different views? Is the evil that a christian man or woman faces on a daily life the same kind of evil that a Zorastrian, Buddist or Hindu follower wrestles with?

Just an interesting conversation piece, I think...
 

chilli

Member
Jul 25, 2005
993
12
18
Well someone who calls S. Harper "evil" has to be a liberal.

People who call otherwise "normal" people mean hateful words - are generally
using the words as a means of hurting someone.

It's their pain expressed outward.

As far as the difference between someone being unbalanced when they commit evil things, well - you would have to be "unbalanced" to commit an evil act in my mind - all the more reason to lock you up.

Society rights over individual rights when it comes to other peoples safety.

That's the answer to your question.

Are there exceptions to every rule? Yes of course and that's where we expect people to use common sense.
 

mick_eight

Banned
Feb 21, 2005
1,197
0
0
I just got 'People of The Lie' by M.Scott Peck. yesterday. Without haven read it I 'll give you my feelings now that some people are just born evil. I may feel diffrent after I get too it, which did you read
 

CJ Tylers

Retired Sr. Member
Jan 3, 2003
1,643
1
0
47
North Vancouver
Just a moment there... I intentionally didn't politicize any aspect of that post because in doing so, it degenerates the conversation into a political rally. I used Harper and Hitler to simply delineate the extremes of association that people have for the world "evil". (although if you dug deep enough, I'm sure you could find something about any political figure that would throw them into the "evil" lot).

To commit wonton acts of violence, or wontonly inflict pain/punishment/death/destruction... these are often used as the textbook defenition of evil (or a close paraprhasing of it).

Pursuing your own agenda, regardless of the costs to other people is also something society tends to look upon as evil if it hurts them.... but as leadership if it benefits them. Interesting, no?

Hurtful words...hurtful words... they are born of ignorance, and are a taught through generations. They denote a complete lack of respect, or perhaps a lack of understanding regarding the levity of the words used. But are they evil? What people have done who have used those words, perhaps, but to simply repeat them like blind sheep? Hateful, disrespectful...yes. I'm not convinced it's evil per se.

We lock up the criminally insane for the saftey and benefit of society, but are they evil? Unstable and unable to control their own actions for sure, butevil would seem to require a premeditation of the act.

Someone who goes out, gets drunk, and kills someone... but who doesn't actually plan on it in the first place... even when they repeat the behavior... may not be evil, but are lacking in any behavioral control mechanisms. There was one young man in England who killed 15 men over the course of several years. He described himself as the least likely person he knew to commit murder, yet he would find himself in a situation that triggered the murderous behavior over and over again.

The man was remoreseful, but clearly a threat... although a mild mannered one at that. Severe emotional issues drove him to his actions.

Compare that with the case of the Moorsgrave killers... a man and a woman who kidnapped children, sexually assaulted them for their own gratification...and then ritualistically murdererd them... and they carefully selected places to bury the bodies. During their trial, it was noted there was absolutely no remorse present in either of the two, more a commen feeling of resentment at being caught and a complete lack of empathy or understanding for the reason behind their arrest. Even during graphic testimonies (including an audio tape of a child begging for her life), the pair was witnessed to be passing candies with noisy little wrappers back and forth.

To me, that bespeaks evil... careful, planned, joint, enjoyed, calous and unrepentant.

It is, however, interesting to see how societies views on evil have changed. In general, evil seems to be anything that goes against the generally accepted views of society... something that causes shock, revulsion and anger.

In times past, this was enough to villify someone... once they were labelled as evil, it was all over for them. Now, we tend to reserve that name for only the most sinister fiends...and relegate most others to mental or emotional imbalances or disabilities.

But what is evil? What really defines it, as a concept?

Mick_Eight: It was a book from the local library, entitled "Evil". It was based on a 3 part BBC series that delved into the matter of Evil, not only from a religious standpoint... but also that of a natural and societal standpoint. A VERY interesting and thought provoking read. (even more interesting, as I read it, I was reminded MANY times of Sylar from Heroes).

The book also remarks upon the Will being a trademark of many "evil" icons in history. In fact, apparently, there was a nazi propaganda film that is even shown to this very day as a prime example of excellent propaganda film making. It capatalized on Hitlers "Will", or charisma, and amplified this throught out the film. Although, from the descriptions, it does sound corny (Hitler descends through clouds, as a divine being would, and begins his speech etc). I can't remember the actual name of the film, sorry.
 

CJ Tylers

Retired Sr. Member
Jan 3, 2003
1,643
1
0
47
North Vancouver
Oh, and as far as being born evil... that's an interesting concept. Of course, if you're selected as an evil being from the start, well, life kind of sucks for you.

I think I ascribe more the to theory that we are born will equal capacity for good and evil. What we choose, how we live, is just that... a matter of choice and not a predestined fate.

It also makes those who are evil more heinous, as they've freely chosen their path. Of course, outside influences can push you in either direction, but it's a persons own Will in the matter that defines what they become.

Of course, then you can ask the question...is evil a teachable skill? If you are born evil, then you can't really pass that evil on to anyone else... they'd have to be born evil as well.
 

CJ Tylers

Retired Sr. Member
Jan 3, 2003
1,643
1
0
47
North Vancouver
"What evil lies in the heart of man..."

Another good quote.

The book also talked about Apocolypse Now, and the book that inspired it (wouldn't you know it, I've forgotten the name). It talked about how the main villain, or the supposed villain, found a perfect clarity of thought and action in the wilds... and it changed him profoundly. To him, what he was doing wasn't wrong or evil... but it was natural and had a "perfect crystal clarity" to it.

The concept of evil, iconic in religion, is really only as old as the religion it resides in. Before that, before our religions came into being, was there a concept of evil as well?

Were darkness and fire viewed as evil? (darkness shrouds the land, and everything becomes more dangerous. Fire is a ravenous beast that consumes the flesh and ravages the landscape). How often are the words natural evil, necessary evil and unecessary evil repeated even in our modern world?
 

HankQuinlan

I dont re Member
Sep 7, 2002
1,743
6
0
victoria
Evil is a point of view.
Of course it is. We all know evil when we see it, but it is difficult to pinpoint the source of evil or to define it. I think "evil" involves those doing selfish acts without regard to their consequences. Serial killers fulfill their desires by torturing and killing others. Bastards like Saddam Hussein, Pinochet, and thousands of others throughout history enriched themselves on the suffering of others. Corporations can be evil -- does that make every cog in their machine evil too?

I doubt that Harper is "evil" -- I suspect that he has good intentions, even if I disagree with his policies. I doubt that George Bush is "evil" either -- he doesn't have the intellect to understand his actions -- but the buck stops with him, so I would throw him in the category. I would term Dick Cheney "evil" in every category because I think he understands what he is doing -- causing grief and torment for the profit of his pals, and to hell with everything else.

But even intentions can't mitigate evil -- Hitler probably thought his policies were for the benefit of the human race, yet wrought immense suffering. He was nice to his dogs, and had a woman that loved him. But he was still an evil prick because of the consequence of his actions.

I kinda wish I was a Christian -- the idea of evil bastards getting the trap door treatment just when they think they're getting into the pearly gates has a great deal of appeal. Imagine Dick Cheney's surprise! Alas, he is just going to die like the rest of us, and any punishment will have to be in this world.

But, then again, I think WalMart is evil too, so it is all in your point of view.
 

CJ Tylers

Retired Sr. Member
Jan 3, 2003
1,643
1
0
47
North Vancouver
AH now...if you belonged to the christian sect, then you'd also have to believe in forgiving Cheney for his sins.

As for Harper, he may have good intentions in mind (but like Cambell and Sullivan)....however, his actions hurt (and continually, conciously) people. Choosing to push Canada into an offensive role, despite the people of Canada not wishing this to happen...all decided because he had an agenda that he had to adhere to.

Still, he probably continues to think it was the right thing to do.

But semantics aside, Evil really is something we don't like to think about, or discuss. It seems, however, that it manifests all around us without our knowing... until too late.

Still discussing homicidal folks... if they are completely in control of their faculties, then yes...I'd agree that they are evil. But what's the verdict when there's a simple impulse control missing, or an obsessive control in effect?

Does an ill or sick mind equal an evil mind?

Human advancement can actually be summed up as evil, I guess... think about it. In order to survive, we killed not only our food (prey) but our competitors. This was done pretty much in cold blood, although species survival was at stake.

Consider the "selfish gene", which pretty much sums up that pathological need to survive and thrive at the expense of others on a very basic level. (not that the selfish gene can be used as an excuse for poor behavior... but a babies need to demand attention from a parental unit is a demonstration of the selfish gene... it's them ahead of everyone else).

Let's talk biblical references... what was the first recorded mentioning of evil? What did our forefathers mean of it? How was it represented?

We know that the popular imagery of satan was borrowed directly from the Master of the Hunt in England... a part of the celtic/pagan faith that the christian fath wished to exterminate at the time. So does that maybe suggest that the judeo/christian defenition of evil stems from a corruption of other religions icons and tenets?
 
Vancouver Escorts