Just a moment there... I intentionally didn't politicize any aspect of that post because in doing so, it degenerates the conversation into a political rally. I used Harper and Hitler to simply delineate the extremes of association that people have for the world "evil". (although if you dug deep enough, I'm sure you could find something about any political figure that would throw them into the "evil" lot).
To commit wonton acts of violence, or wontonly inflict pain/punishment/death/destruction... these are often used as the textbook defenition of evil (or a close paraprhasing of it).
Pursuing your own agenda, regardless of the costs to other people is also something society tends to look upon as evil if it hurts them.... but as leadership if it benefits them. Interesting, no?
Hurtful words...hurtful words... they are born of ignorance, and are a taught through generations. They denote a complete lack of respect, or perhaps a lack of understanding regarding the levity of the words used. But are they evil? What people have done who have used those words, perhaps, but to simply repeat them like blind sheep? Hateful, disrespectful...yes. I'm not convinced it's evil per se.
We lock up the criminally insane for the saftey and benefit of society, but are they evil? Unstable and unable to control their own actions for sure, butevil would seem to require a premeditation of the act.
Someone who goes out, gets drunk, and kills someone... but who doesn't actually plan on it in the first place... even when they repeat the behavior... may not be evil, but are lacking in any behavioral control mechanisms. There was one young man in England who killed 15 men over the course of several years. He described himself as the least likely person he knew to commit murder, yet he would find himself in a situation that triggered the murderous behavior over and over again.
The man was remoreseful, but clearly a threat... although a mild mannered one at that. Severe emotional issues drove him to his actions.
Compare that with the case of the Moorsgrave killers... a man and a woman who kidnapped children, sexually assaulted them for their own gratification...and then ritualistically murdererd them... and they carefully selected places to bury the bodies. During their trial, it was noted there was absolutely no remorse present in either of the two, more a commen feeling of resentment at being caught and a complete lack of empathy or understanding for the reason behind their arrest. Even during graphic testimonies (including an audio tape of a child begging for her life), the pair was witnessed to be passing candies with noisy little wrappers back and forth.
To me, that bespeaks evil... careful, planned, joint, enjoyed, calous and unrepentant.
It is, however, interesting to see how societies views on evil have changed. In general, evil seems to be anything that goes against the generally accepted views of society... something that causes shock, revulsion and anger.
In times past, this was enough to villify someone... once they were labelled as evil, it was all over for them. Now, we tend to reserve that name for only the most sinister fiends...and relegate most others to mental or emotional imbalances or disabilities.
But what is evil? What really defines it, as a concept?
Mick_Eight: It was a book from the local library, entitled "Evil". It was based on a 3 part BBC series that delved into the matter of Evil, not only from a religious standpoint... but also that of a natural and societal standpoint. A VERY interesting and thought provoking read. (even more interesting, as I read it, I was reminded MANY times of Sylar from Heroes).
The book also remarks upon the Will being a trademark of many "evil" icons in history. In fact, apparently, there was a nazi propaganda film that is even shown to this very day as a prime example of excellent propaganda film making. It capatalized on Hitlers "Will", or charisma, and amplified this throught out the film. Although, from the descriptions, it does sound corny (Hitler descends through clouds, as a divine being would, and begins his speech etc). I can't remember the actual name of the film, sorry.