Hmmm not very good at first round picks hmmm. Let's see all those top 5 picks the canucks. Most top 5 picks are considered by most scouting staffs as being no brainers. Picks #6. to #30 are considered as great to good prospects since scouting is not an exact science and we don't have the benefit of a crystal ball or20/20 hindsight or a time machine.
1970 1st draft Dale Tallon at #2 lost the expansion coin flip with buffalo. Buffalo took Gilbert Perrault
1971 Joceyln Guevermont #3 after Montreal #1 took Guy Laflleur and Detroit took Marcel Dionne at #2. Buffalo took Rick Martin at #5
1972 Don Lever #3 Islanders took Billy Harris at #1 Atlanta took Jacques Richard at #2 Montreal took Steve Shutt at #4. Buffalo took Jim Schoenfeld at #5.
1973 Dennis Ververgaerte at #3. After Islanders took Dennis Potvin at #1 and Atlanta took Tom Lysiak at #2. Toronto took Lanny MacDonald at #4
1974 No first round pick - lost in trade
1975 No pick in the top 5. Picked Rick Blight at #10
1976 No first round pick - lost in trade.
1977 we picked Jere Gillis at #4
1978 we picked Bill Derlago at #4. Mike Gillis (yes our ex-GM was selected by Colorado at #5)
1979 we picked Rick Vaive at #5
1980 we didn't have a top 5 pick but we got Rick Lanz at #7
1981 we didn't have a top 5 pick but we got Garth Butcher at #10
1982 no top 5 pick at #11 we got Michel Petit
1983 no top 5 pick at #9 we took Cam Neely
In this group Vaive, Butcher, Ververgaerte and Derlago were middle of the road performers. I liked Butcher as a dependable defenceman. Neely! Let's not go there. That was our shining star and we got a wounded one armed Barry Pedersen in return.
1984 Pittsburgh took Mario Lemieux at #1. We didn't have a top 5 pick but took JJ Daigneault at #10
1985 we took Jim Sandlak at #4
1986 we didn't have a top 5 pick. At #7 we took Dan Woodley
1987 our #3 pick was dealt to Boston who selected Glen Wesley no other first round pick that year
1988 we selected Trevor Linden at #2 overall
1989 we didn't have a top 5 pick at #7 we took Jason Herter.
In this group obviously Sandlak and Linden were the only decent ones. More so with Linden.
1990 we selected Petr Nedved at #2 overall
1991 we didn't have a top 5 pick but selected Alex Stojanov at #6. Peter Forsberg was selected at #6 by Quebec. Markus Naslund was selected at #19 by pittsburgh. (We traded for |Naslund)
1992 no top 5 pick #21
1993 no top 5 pick #20
1994 no top 5 pick #13 Mattius Ohlund
1995 no first round pick. - Alex mogilny trade
1996 no top 5 pick #12
1997 no top 5 pick #10
1998 we selected #4 overall Bryan Allen
1999 we selected #2 Daniel Sedin and #3 Henrik Sedin
2000 no top 5 pick selected #23
2001 no top 5 pick selected #16
2002 no first round pick
2003 no top 5 pick #23 we selected Ryan Kesler
2004 no top 5 pick #26 we selected Cory Schneider
2005 no top 5 pick #10 we selected Luc Bourdon
2006 no top 5 pick #14 Grabner
2007 no top 5 pick #25 White
2008 no top 5 pick #10 Hodgson
2009 no top 5 pick #20 Schroeder
2010 no 1st,2nd, or 3rd round picks Dealt in deals
2011 no top 5 pick #29 Nicklas Jensen
2012 no top 5 pick #26 Brendan Guance
2013 no top 5 pick #9 Bo Horvat (trade) #22 Hunter Shinkaruk
Ok we are talking about the Quinn, Burke, Nonis and then Gillis eras here. Obviously, Nedved and Alex Stojanov were the top because the Penguins turned Alex Stojanov into Naslund for us. Their screw up was not our glorious picking. I recall Alex Stojanov was out of the league within a few years working for a small town Fire Department. What's important here and I know you will come back with another wall of words is the last ten years where we have given up valuable assets for basically nothing. Great picks were Ohlund, Kesler and Schneider. I would say there is more upside on Hodgson than Kassian. Schneider is a no brainer and with our current goalie situation it will haunt us for the next few years until we have a bonafide Number One goalie. Yes, Burke pulled of a beauty getting both twins on draft day but by and large the Canucks picks that have either stayed with the team or turned into other valuable assets is not a pretty story.