Upcoming Gov action on Prostitution

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
For your reading pleasure,

@ Canada.com (http://www.canada.com/topics/news/story.html?id=51e7974c-4811-4683-be80-f46ea93efaf5&k=46048):

<div style="background-color:#CCFF33">
The Conservative government has turned aside calls from Liberals and New Democrats, as well as its own MPs, to rewrite federal criminal laws in order to shift the burden of punishment away from prostitutes and onto their customers and pimps.

Opposition MPs said the government's refusal to act on the key recommendation of a report by the Commons committee on the status of women is disappointing and unacceptable.

"My hopes are dashed because the strongest recommendation of the report is not going to be followed," said Liberal Maria Minna. The Toronto MP said she had dared to hope that the government would move to modernize the prostitution laws because the Tories on the committee were on side with the Liberal and NDP members.

"We'll have to start lobbying the government again," she said.

Ontario New Democrat Irene Mathyssen also accused the government of not taking the problem of human trafficking seriously enough. In particular, she said, recently proposed legislation to limit the number of women who can come into the country to work in strip clubs was more about optics than substance, given that the practice had already all but disappeared under the former Liberal government.

But Tory MP Joy Smith said opposition MPs should not rush to judgment. She insisted she is not giving up on getting the government to agree to target johns and pimps instead of prostitutes. "Things are still under discussion. There is no way that this is going to be left unaddressed," the Winnipeg MP vowed.

Smith, a leading anti-trafficking campaigner, said the government has already shown its good faith on tackling the "horrendous" crime of trafficking by implementing one of the committee's major recommendations.

The government announced in June it will allow victims of trafficking brought into Canada from abroad to remain here for 180 days on temporary resident permits, up from 120 days under the old rules. It also said they will be allowed to apply for work permits.

The measures were advocated by the committee as a way to tackle the consequences of human trafficking, a form of human slavery that revolves largely around the exploitation of women.

The committee had also wanted the criminal law amended so as to make purchasing a sexual service a criminal offence, and to repeal provisions that outlaw the act of soliciting by prostitutes and that make it illegal for them to be found in a bawdy house.

Justice Minister Rob Nicholson quietly tabled the government's response to the committee's recommendations just before MPs broke for the summer recess.

Although Nicholson did not respond directly to the call for revamped federal prostitution laws, he did defend the existing law.

"The Criminal Code of Canada provides a comprehensive set of tools to ensure that traffickers are held accountable," the government's response statement said.

Minna said it's time to enact legislation that will dry up demand for the sex trade.

"I know some women want to be prostitutes and that is how they want to earn their living," she said. "But the bulk of women in the business are exploited."

The committee's two Bloc Quebecois MPs were the only members opposed to changing the prostitution laws. They argued that "criminalizing the purchase of sex" would not solve the problem of sexual exploitation.

Nicholson said human trafficking must be condemned, and that the government is playing a leadership role at home and abroad to combat the problem. Among other things, it has financed public awareness campaigns and established, under the RCMP, a Human Trafficking National Co-ordination Centre.
</div>

Looks to me they have near-concensus among all political parties, including the one in government. I guess massage parlors and other bawdy houses will flourish, perhaps even be declared as such under law in the future. It surely means women will no longer be criminalized for anything to do with prostitution, unlike now. But upcoming legislation looks aimed at the guys who drive around picking up girls, and seems like LE will have more tools to charge with. Lastly, the whole human trafficking thing is just grand standing to appease the United States. Not one case of trafficking has been successfully prosecuted (so claims by the gov that they are doing all they can are ironic), although Pinky's is still up on the docket.

As for the "bulk of the women who are exploited", I guess if the government really believes that, they would step in to the massage parlors and try to educate them on that respect because the bulk of the women there certainly feel they are there to exploit an economic opportunity (not the other way around). But we never see words mentioning this, so I guess the sentiment is merely a bluff.
 

Quarter Mile'r

Injected and Blown
May 17, 2005
3,596
134
63
Out of Town
It always makes my head swim whenever the "govt" talks about prostitution
of late. Everything they say weighs in on the exploitation of women and
sex slave trafficking now. Not that these women have made a choice to do this kind of work. :rolleyes:

Oh no.......the gov't would never see it that way of course. :rolleyes:
In their eyes all women are sex slaves and have been trafficked one
way or the other.

Just like our MP raids last year. Oh YEAH !! :rolleyes:
They were all busted for being trafficked weren't they? Geeeeeeeeez !

Fucking sickening crap..............:(
The only one's who have their heads up their asses is this right wing
religious nutbar party.


............QM'r
 

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
It always makes my head swim whenever the "govt" talks about prostitution
of late. Everything they say weighs in on the exploitation of women and
sex slave trafficking now. Not that these women have made a choice to do this kind of work. :rolleyes: ...

The only one's who have their heads up their asses is this right wing
religious nutbar party.
In the article, it looks like all the parties feel the same way about the women involved being exploited, not just the right wing one.

Secondly, I'm interested in laws that may impact MP owners. It could be seen that they are living off the avails of prostitution, especially if they repeal the law prohibiting bawdy houses (which the government seems to be OK with). That is, an MP could no longer be licensed as a "body rub" establishment but a "bawdy house" outright, and thus the owner could be seen as profiting from sexual services offered. That seems to be a tight one to dance around. It would be interesting to see how repeal of bawdy house laws plays out.
 

littlejimbigher

New member
Jun 21, 2006
1,438
4
0
surrey
I wonder how many of you ladies who advertize here realize how exploited you are? At least according to the government.
LOL
 

HaywoodJabloemy

Dissident
Mar 6, 2004
254
0
0
Never the safest place
I agree with QM. It is really disappointing that all the parties except the BQ are so ridiculously gullible and naive on this subject.

...if they repeal the law prohibiting bawdy houses (which the government seems to be OK with)...

That is not what (the majority of) this particular committee proposed. Read that part of the article again. What they proposed was an idiotic and largely symbolic rewording of the laws, as was done several years ago in Sweden, so that the legal penalties are (supposedly) applied to everyone involved in the business except the prostitutes. Presumably, in relation to the Criminal Code sections regarding common bawdy-houses, it would mean eliminating only the one small line referring to "inmates" of common bawdy-houses, while leaving the rest of Sections 210 and 211 as they are.

Like many countries, Sweden has equivalents to our "living on the avails" and "common bawdy-house" laws, modified slightly as mentioned above. But in addition, they have made paying for sex, but not getting paid, criminal. Of course prostitution necessarily must involve one person paying another, so unlike Canada, the entire business is completely criminal under all circumstances since it is impossible for it to operate without a crime occurring.

In reality these moves have only made life more difficult and dangerous for the Swedish women in the business.

In order to stay in business, the women must protect their clients from the police. If they are assaulted, they are very reluctant to call the police because doing so would cause them to lose all of their other clients once word got out that the police would be monitoring her.

They must avoid working in pairs or groups, as they would prefer to do for safety reasons, since doing so means they could be charged for assisting prostitution to occur. They have difficulty finding places to live, and can easily be evicted, because landlords can be charged if their buildings are used for prostitution. They can be more easily exploited by landlord "rent pimps".

The laws actually end up protecting the criminals and hurting the women, precisely the opposite effect that its proponents claim.

Sweden now requires a high percentage of female representation in government, and unfortunately this seems to have resulted in a misguided radical element of 1980s-style anti-male feminists getting their way.
 

Chrisinda

Member
Apr 17, 2006
134
0
16
Regina
Speaking as a person who personally chose this industry:

I chose this. I was not coerced. None of the many people I know have been coerced.

Escort companies and massage parlors are not usually the main problem. Yes, there is human trafficking. But most companies have nothing to do with this! If Canada really wants to work on the problem, why don't they investigate the real human traffickers and the iv parents sticking their kids on the street.

C'mon Canada. Leave the consenting adults alone, and go after people who are really victimizing!
 

Quarter Mile'r

Injected and Blown
May 17, 2005
3,596
134
63
Out of Town
Well said Chrisinda

Could this be the solution in a nutshell?
All you ladies lobby the gov't to see it from your point of view
so they can quit generalizing about prostitution, that it's mostly
about gals who are being trafficked, or rather, exploited.

If that is even possible. :rolleyes:

To me it would seem that this "generalization" term of trafficked girls
is the key spin on putting it in the media to make people think
what the gov't wants them to see. What else is new? :rolleyes:


...........QM'r
 

HaywoodJabloemy

Dissident
Mar 6, 2004
254
0
0
Never the safest place
...All you ladies lobby the gov't to see it from your point of view...
That's what some are doing, despite the incredible negative stigma about publicly acknowledging how they earn their living. And there's been more stories about them in the media recently, particularly because of the Sex Professionals of Canada constitutional challenge. Even one of the MPs quoted in the article had to acknowledge they exist. And BTW, you don't exactly see large numbers of us guys standing up beside them and publicly supporting them.

The Conservatives and their police allies talk a good game about wanting to crack down on everything, but their lack of action speaks louder than their words. It seems The Conservatives are no different from The Liberals in wanting to ignore this situation, following the usual political path of avoiding controversial issues whenever possible.
 

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
That is not what (the majority of) this particular committee proposed. Read that part of the article again. What they proposed was an idiotic and largely symbolic rewording of the laws, as was done several years ago in Sweden, so that the legal penalties are (supposedly) applied to everyone involved in the business except the prostitutes. Presumably, in relation to the Criminal Code sections regarding common bawdy-houses, it would mean eliminating only the one small line referring to "inmates" of common bawdy-houses, while leaving the rest of Sections 210 and 211 as they are.
Yes, I agree that the article never said that bawdy house laws would be repealed. I asked the question because the trajectory of intent would seem to suggest it might be a later move. I can see why you thought I meant it was in the article, however. I should have been as clear about it as now.

However, the rest of your post is especially interesting. You point out that Sweden is the model being used, and it seems to make sense by the way you describe it. There is no evidence of it though. How did you make the connection? ie: Was it stated in some other article?
 

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
Speaking as a person who personally chose this industry:

I chose this. I was not coerced. None of the many people I know have been coerced.
While you understand your own point of view, the feminists (and sympathizers) in government seem to think that you don't fully understand your own situation. You see, they think that no matter how high you set your rate, the transaction to sell the use of your body for sex to a man is inherently unfair to you. Do you find any grain of truth at all to this?
 

HaywoodJabloemy

Dissident
Mar 6, 2004
254
0
0
Never the safest place
...You point out that Sweden is the model being used...
Was it stated in some other article?
The article you posted does not specifically mention it, but the proposals are clearly modelled on Sweden. It was certainly discussed during this committee`s hearings, which included many witnesses pulling enormous fictional numbers out of the air regarding the anti-trafficking hysteria, in order to dishonestly advance their real agenda of a prohibition on all sex work.

The Bayswan.org website has the translated text of the actual Swedish laws and a page of links to many critiques from sex workers in Sweden, or writers who have interviewed them.

Sweden is frequently used as a mythical example by prohibitionists, usually the radical dogmatic feminist element, but also the moralist religious nutjobs, their strange bedfellow political allies on this subject. It goes without saying that neither of these groups cares to hear about the reality of the situation or what sex workers think. Fortunately it was heard in New Zealand, where they rejected the Swedish-style prohibition in favour of decriminalization. See the two paragraphs led off by "Nor should we turn to the Swedish model..."

Just a few days ago Art Hanger mentioned Sweden, along with other non-facts about Europe and Australia, on the second page of this opinion item in The Calgary Herald. In this post on https://merb.cc, I ranted about Hanger`s habit of using supposed facts he knows to be fabricated.
 
Last edited:
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts