Or option E (D is "pale"): Variety is the spice of life! (not the same as no preference).
Contrast is sexy, so that can mean tan lines on some, but if every woman had tan lines, then the woman who contrasted with no tan lines or pale would stand out even more.
I had a gal friend several years back who was a cute and sweet brunette, but would not be desribed as a knockout. She went on holiday to Greece to the islands of Naxos / Parros, which were extremely popular at that time with Swedish tourists. Suddenly she was pulling in the studliest Swedish guys left and right because she was one of the few women available with dark hair.
I think there is a sociology experiment in there somewhere...