Speeding Ticket Question

massageseeker

Member
Sep 3, 2003
959
0
16
My buddy got a ticket and told the cop he was not speeding. The cop told him he was, he asked to see the radar gun and the cop said he reset it ..so he could not show him the speed ..

is there a legality to follow here ? or is he screwd in a dispute?
 

praxis

Member
Sep 30, 2004
1,938
5
0
www.edmontonpolice.ca
He's screwed. . .

it's his word against the cops - so who wins the argument. . .(I'll give you one guess. . .) ;)

He can take it all the way to the courts (just so it incoveniences the cops as well), then on the trial day plead guilty and negotiate a lower fine with the prosecutor. Tha's all you can hope to get...save about $20-$40 off the fine. He'll have to pay something anyway. I haven't heard of anyone winning on a ticket unless the cops are totally incompetent.
 
E

Euro_SZabina

However going to court will loose of his work, just to get a lower fine...now does that really worth it ?
 

Mr Blonde

Member
Nov 3, 2003
349
9
18
50
he's better of paying it. the money he loses ditching work to sit in some stuffy court room, with some prick cop is more then paying the fine.

a lot of people think the cops can't be bothered to show up, but they usually do. it either means over-time, or a day indoors without the indignity of being seen as nothing more than a public nuisance.
 

Pantherdash

Panther
Apr 2, 2007
2,575
254
83
Downtown Vancouver
My buddy got a ticket and told the cop he was not speeding. The cop told him he was, he asked to see the radar gun and the cop said he reset it ..so he could not show him the speed ..

is there a legality to follow here ? or is he screwd in a dispute?
Man, this cop is an asshole. But Praxis is right...your word against his. Tell him to fess up and pay the fine. Speed is killing us!:(
 

Pantsnake

New member
Mar 20, 2006
181
0
0
A friend of mine who was a cop in Winnipeg (He's now a Chartered Accountant) told me this once. If you are ever pulled over for a traffic violation that you think is bogus and you want to fight it. Don't argue with the cop at the time. Be polite, take your medicine and smile. Then when you get home take the time to write up exactly what you think happened. WHY? If you argue, they will definitely go back to the car and make some notes regarding the stop because they will expect to end up in court. If you are cooperative, the cop will write the ticket, go back to their car and finish their shift without giving it a second thought. Then when you do go to court, aside from the ticket they will likely not have made any other notes. Yes it will be their word against yours but if you have detailed notes the judge will usually rule in your favor.
 

Sir_frixalot

Big Pink Steel
Nov 15, 2006
227
1
0
Calgs
OK there's a few options: I am in Calgary BTW

1) First appearance option - go to the traffic court place and wait to see a prosecutor, negotiate with him/her and usually it's pretty good, although lately it's been worse. They Used to say - fine or points? I'd pay the fine and it would never come onto your record.

2) plead NG and the BS at the trial. I've had about 50% SUCCESS RATE with that. SOmetimes cop is no show, but not often. If you can think of ANYTHING that the radar might have picked up (plane/train/truck) it might work, but for laser you're F'd.

3) Plead NG and then at the trial plead G, you might get less but not much since you wasted their time (use #1 instead)

4) Plead NG and don't show up. You will lose and warrant will be issued (not good cuz you forget and wham!! next time you get stopped - not fun)

I use #1 and #2 a lot but I still have 9 points on my lic. I would have more though (about 20) if I didn't fight, and a 3 mo suspension is 15.

Drive safe Kids thats the best way to save money for pooning...
 

loudze

New member
Sep 3, 2007
10
0
0
use a lawyer

I used to get speeding tickets when i was younger and had a brand new car. My insurance was expensive, and so were the tickets. I met a guy who told me about a lawyer he used and when I got my next one I gave him a call. The lawyer went to court for me and only charged $150. I didn't have to show up but I went anyways. He argued that the case should be dismissed because the radar gun had not been calibrated recently enough according to the radar gun's manual. It was dismissed. My lawyer said cops make so many mistakes it is easy to get speeding tickets dismissed. I used him and two other lawyers over the years and got out of five more tickets. My record is clean. I have learned where can speed and where to slow down now and haven't got one for a couple years, but I know who to call when I do. You can try to fight the ticket yourself, but using a lawyer is almost a sure thing. Just don't tell the police officer you know how fast you were going. If you say just 1 kph more than the limit the judge will give you the ticket for 1 kph over and your insurance goes up. BTW I am from the US and it might be different than in Canada. There are way more speed traps in the US so there is enough work to keep the lawyers busy.
 

Valpacino

Member
Oct 1, 2005
84
9
8
Alberta ticket for BC resident?

hi fellow perbs...i had the misfortune of getting a ticket today going from bc to alberta..got caught near the border of AB on AB side for doing 120 at 100 zone...well, it was getting late and i just wanted to get to my hotel fast, etc, etc...anyway, there were no cars behind me no cars oncoming, as the road was wideopen, i just gunned it...i know it was wrong of me doing more than what was posted but that's not the point.

does anyone know how AB and BC system work? if i don't pay the ticket, would it prevent me from getting insurance renewed by ICBC? i know if i have any unpaid o/s ticket issued by BC gov't, i have to clear that up to renew insurance w/ ICBC. what happens w/ o/s ticket out of province? how about demerit point? would getting served AB ticket affect my demerit point in bc?
it's really frustrating as i have been clean for almost 5 yrs and now this...argggh. any insights would be appreciated. thanks
 

rescue911

New member
Jan 1, 2006
494
1
0
stupid fuck

instead of suddenly becoming a legal eagle why doesn't the stupid fuck just slow down..dumb numbnuts.
 

Godfearsme

New member
Jul 2, 2007
17
0
0
Upon reading this I recalled a best of CL post that related very nicely to this topic and so I thought I would post it http://www.craigslist.org/about/best/dal/316206178.html

Open Letter From a Cop
Date: 2007-04-21, 3:51PM CDT


Ladies and Gentlemen,
Allow me to introduced myself. I am a police officer. More importantly to this post, I am a police officer who is sick and damned tired of dealing with certain things on a day to day basis:

1) Contrary to what you might think, I am not an idiot. That ring on my finger is a BA from Texas Tech. My GPA was a 3.71 and I was in fact the president of my frat (which means I got a lot of stories that start out "So, this one time, we were fucked up, and...). So, when I make the mistake of mispronouncing your name (the last name with 17 fucking letters, only two of which are vowels), dont give me that look like I just kicked your puppy.

While I may not be an idiot, I am human and I do fuck things up from time to time. When I apologize for pulling you over because I thought your tags were out, just take the sorry and be on about your way. DO NOT get a high and mighty attitude. Our state has over 5000 traffic laws, I can find one to help you get over your tude.

2) No, I do not have "real criminals" I should be out looking for. Did you happen to notice the fucking Harley parked behind you with LED's blinking? Lemme give you a hint - if you see a motorcycle officer, our entire job relates to asshole drivers. Asshole drivers are the ones who make your daily commute dangerous (Or, a complete standstill, once they wreck out). With that in mind, shut up about the other "important" things I "should be doing." Believe it or not, I tried to get this job. Dont act like you wouldnt like to get paid to ride a Harley for 8 hours a day. But, the main benefit of this job, is I dont have "Real criminals" to fuck with. No shagging calls, dealing with domestics, and so on. My worst days are telling someone they lost a loved one in a wreck I just worked. Which, brings me to my next point:

3) If I was a dick from the beginning of the stop, I apologize. I mean that with all sincerity. I am human. If I've dealt with 10 assholes before I stopped you or maybe delivered a death notification, I may have done the wrong thing and assumed you were gonna be one too. Believe it or not, after my shift on the way home, I'll probably reflect on my day and feel a bit shitty if our interaction stands out because I was a jerk. Yours wouldnt be the first citation I've "lost" because I thought I was being an overbearing prick at the time I wrote it. We all have our bad days.

4) No good deed goes unpunished. I know that. But, if I give you a warning - DO NOT assume I pulled you over for a bullshit reason and then lost my nerve. Just because I didnt write you for 7 over the limit, doesnt mean I was profiling and you should set up a meeting with my Chief and your NAACP rep. You complaining that "He stopped me for nothin, oterwise he'd have given me a ticket," is bullshit and, frankly, is the reason most of us have stopped giving warnings.

Profiling is BULLSHIT, by the way. You're hauling ass past me at 70+ mph. I have to see your speed, if you have a front license plate, registration sticker, inspection sticker and if you're wearing a seatbelt in the split second you pass me. I couldnt give two shits if your black white or green.

5) No, you may not see my RADAR gun. For a few reasons. First, I dont have to show it to you. You bestfriend's roommate's boyfriend who talked to a cop once is fucking wrong. I dont have to show it to you, I dont care what you heard. Second, I dont want to show it to you, because I dont want you out of your car. Why? You may not know that you're not gonna attack me, but I dont know that. If you're seated, you're less of a threat and I like feeling as comfy as I can. Also, I dont have a RADAR anymore. I have LIDAR. If you're gonna act like a lawyer on the side of the road, get your shit squared away first and know what you're talking about. Finally, you cant see the LIDAR for your own safety. You feel that way your car rocks every time an 18 wheeler flys by? I'd rather not get sued becuase your stupid ass fell into traffic and got killed on my stop.

While I'm on my good pal LIDAR, it has some neat features. It's a laser beamed device, so - no, I couldnt have gotten the guy next to you. It's got a scope on it, and the scope's dot was aimed directly at your car's grill. Also, it tells me the distance in feet that i clocked you at. So, dont tell me, I couldnt have gotten you from that far, because I can. Its accurate to 2500 feet (half a mile or so), and I can clock you, get two swigs of coffee and eat three donut holes by the time you get close enough to see my motorcycle on the shoulder.

6) Arguements take place in court, not on the side of the road. No exceptions. And, yes, I will show up to court. Even on my day off. I get paid (by you, thanks for reminding me) OT to show up to court, and I'm trying to con my wife into letting me buy a new boat, so I need that money. Now, once we get to court, follow a few easy rules:

Dont lie. My bike has a video camera on it, and that box on my belt is a mic. The camera is hooked into my fixed 4 way RADAR, so it shows your speed (if I didnt clock you with a LIDAR unit, that is). Oh, and judges dont like all those cuss words you used out at the scene...

Dont yell at me outside the court room. This is not a personal matter to me, even if it is for you. After this, Im going home and watching my Texas Rangers fuck up another promising season. You will be the furthest thing from my mind.


Guys and gals, we are the same as you. We've got a home life that might suck, bills to pay, college loans, the damned team that never wins (Tech losing in the first fuckin round! Damn you Bobby Knight), and so on. We have feelings, personalities, and dreams just like you. When Im at your window, look at my face. You met a hundred guys like me in college, and loved em. I was that guy a few years ago, and not much has changed. Im still a nice guy, treat me like one and you might just get a warning.




Pretty funny for a cop...
 

Pantsnake

New member
Mar 20, 2006
181
0
0
I met a guy who told me about a lawyer he used and when I got my next one I gave him a call. The lawyer went to court for me and only charged $150.
$150.00?:eek: Maybe back in the days of gas at 59 cents a gallon or 10 cent chocolate bars. :D
 

CalgaryJenn

I Love To Chat
Apr 15, 2006
1,209
0
0
54
Calgary, Alberta
Although I don't know alot about what will or will not happen with a speeding violation as of yet, I DO KNOW that we were travelling on Shephard Road the other day coming onto Barlow and it is 70 and we were doing 90, the radar detector went off as did the scrambler/jammer unit we own. The scrambler/jammer unit sends the FM signal (if it is any kind of laser) back to their gun and it jammed her gun,giving her an inaccurate reading she looked at it funny as if the gun just spoke to her in Greek, banged her palm against it and then aimed it facing the other direction...LOL. This little unit is guarenteed as we have had it for about a month now and this has happened twice, and the company who makes it guarentee's they will pay any tickets in the first year if their unit fails. If you want to know where to get it it can be purchased at most Auto Temps or I got mine up at the Road King truck stop at Com-Tech inside.

.
 

Walk Softly

Member
Sep 13, 2005
711
2
18
Victoria area
Hate to tell you but... In BC cops don't legally have to show up personally for traffic court. They are allowed to appoint a representative who looks after every traffic ticket for that court session. They changed this a while back because it was costing a fortune for cops to show up for court sessions where the challenger didn't show up. Don't forget this is administrative law: you are considered guilty unless you can prove yourself innocent.

If your friend really wasn't speeding, I wish them luck. Otherwise, quit whining and buck it up!

WS.
 

chiapet

New member
Apr 30, 2005
15
0
0
he's better of paying it. the money he loses ditching work to sit in some stuffy court room, with some prick cop is more then paying the fine.

a lot of people think the cops can't be bothered to show up, but they usually do. it either means over-time, or a day indoors without the indignity of being seen as nothing more than a public nuisance.

If you have ever noticed, your court date is already on the ticket when you get it, that is the court day or days for that cop, so he will be there unless he is testifying at a more serious case, like an assault case running longer than planned, etc. I got 2 cops in the family. Your best bet for almoust any case is go to the traffic court, talk to a prosecutor and offer some non whiny explanation and ask if you can have the points removed and just pay the fine, then your insurance will not go up, a much more expensive longer term problem, especially if you have other tickets on your record.
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts