So much for German superiority

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
my god. you really are clueless at times. Who would the ruling party be if the Germans won the war? ummmmm........ The Nazi Party. The fact of the matter is that even when the average German found out what happened to the millions of Jews, Gypsy's and disabled, few cared, after all they were just Jews, Gypsy's and cripples. Sure there were some german people who felt bad, but could that not be because they were a conquered people trying to appease the allies and make themselves look good? How many would have spoken out againest the atrocities if the Germans had won?
Even if Hitler himself was dead, he was hardly the most cruel and radical of the Nazi Party. Alot of his orders were made by Himmler, Hess and Goreing with Hitler rubber stamping them. Historians agree on that as well.
You just proved me right. It's the Nazis, not the Germans who are blamed by historians for the Holocaust.
 

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle

MissingOne

Don't just do something, sit there.
Jan 2, 2006
2,226
435
83
... In fact, the German language is so recognized for its beauty that government institutions exist for keeping it true to its form. Does that happen in Canada, the US or England?
It's often said, not without some truth, that when a government decides that it is necessary to protect the national language, it's a sure sign of a language whose importance is declining.
 

MissingOne

Don't just do something, sit there.
Jan 2, 2006
2,226
435
83
... and (German) is yet highly flexible in that new words can be created without necessarily having to borrow from other languages. That's not the case with English.
That's just plain silly. English is rife with compound words created from other English words.
 

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
"Why The Allies Won" by Richard Overy. Enjoyed it immensely.

As for GBM, obviously quantity far exceeds quality regarding his posts.

Richard Overy stands in complete contradiction to almost all other historians as to why the Germans did not defeat SU. Most historians agree that had Hitler not ordered the invasion of the Ukraine before Moscow, had he actually followed through with the advice by his generals, SU would have fallen. Instead, Overy focuses on how Russians were able to focus military production into one giant machine that overcame German resource superiority, and also Russian fanaticism derived from hatred for Germans after having fought them for so many years. But these two main factors he trots out as the reasons why the Soviet Union was eventually able to overcome Germany is completely dependent upon an protracted war due to the mistake of Hitler's diversion away from Moscow into the Ukraine. Simply put, SU would not have been able to gather all that might until at least 2 full years after Barbarossa began, and Overy recognizes this. Almost all historians agree that had Hitler gone straight to Moscow, it would have been over in months, and the German generalisimos' calculation of that is correct.

Richard Overy published "Why The Allies Won" with the intention of throwing out all the answers provided by other historians, I might suggest, to provide an alternate view and sell more books. You ought not to read only one historian's viewpoint in your understanding of history.
 
Last edited:

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
That's just plain silly. English is rife with compound words created from other English words.
It is true, English does have a lot of compound words created from English words, but in contract to German, it is minute. English prefers to borrow from other languages (which has tremendous advantages), but at the price of diverting from its original form and heavy change.
 

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
It's often said, not without some truth, that when a government decides that it is necessary to protect the national language, it's a sure sign of a language whose importance is declining.
You're right about that. It is happening in France and Quebec. Unfortunately for the Germans, English has become lingua franca, which is why Germans protect their language now with such fervor.
 

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
While it is true English has large influence from Germanic root, it is obvious that you did not study both German and Latin for several years as I did. If you had, you would recognize English finds most of its root in Latin.

The English language contains influences also from other areas of the globe as from SE Asia, whence Pali has presence.
English was merely influenced by Latin. It did not derive from it.

I quote: "The history of the language can be traced back to the arrival of three Germanic tribes to the British Isles during the 5th Century AD" from - http://www.krysstal.com/english.html

Now look at this from the same site:
 

MissingOne

Don't just do something, sit there.
Jan 2, 2006
2,226
435
83
Since this thread turned into a bit of a discussion about language:

If any of you like Mark Twain, and haven't yet read "The Awful German Language", give it a read. It's very funny.
 
Last edited:

LaCreme

RETIRE SP
Mar 19, 2007
484
0
0
IN YOUR WALLET
Fuck you're so stupid. You're so dead wrong you might as well just be dead.
History_of_the_English_language

I quote the above link in the first 6 words of the first sentence: English is a West Germanic language.
if you look in historical book you will find french to be germanic as well before latin took over.
 

LaCreme

RETIRE SP
Mar 19, 2007
484
0
0
IN YOUR WALLET
It's often said, not without some truth, that when a government decides that it is necessary to protect the national language, it's a sure sign of a language whose importance is declining.
i dont see it as declining as long we all get to get to understand eachother..
that is the importance i think because is wrong to not understanding eachother that why language did evaluate since to complete our thoughts.
 

LaCreme

RETIRE SP
Mar 19, 2007
484
0
0
IN YOUR WALLET
You're right about that. It is happening in France and Quebec. Unfortunately for the Germans, English has become lingua franca, which is why Germans protect their language now with such fervor.
Frist of all french from france and french from quebec is two thing diffrent but simillar.french from quebec is inspire from the old french from france i mean when they frist came here. we still used some old 3-400 yrs ago french word and but new frenchy used something else to understand read my example below:D .. ..

ah la lingua language langue i would say in here german is more a nother state of mind because " sparche look pretty much like speech and "rede" mean talk talk and talk like language :eek: . so here german and english use diffrent synonym to descrive the same thing.. also all the globe do! so it self english is much more moderne in that way. is what i think here.
 

Fletch

Member
Jan 1, 2007
85
0
6
Edmonton
Why The Allies Won

I see you have read the book. I don't really agree with you conclusions but I don't really care to debate them either.

I have read a number of books regarding history as it is a favourite of mine when it comes to reading material. Out of curiousity have your read "Blood, Tears, and Folly: An Objective Look at World War II" by Len Deighton?

My point is that the Germans lost for a number of reasons and it is doubtful that they could have won and held the territory.

I really do not understand what kind of point you were trying to make in the first place with the first post, you go from history to cars to penises.

As for German engineering concerning vehicles, I like what the Lemon Aid Car Guide has to say on the subject.
 

LaCreme

RETIRE SP
Mar 19, 2007
484
0
0
IN YOUR WALLET
the teacher was in full er>ction when he told me this story i am he came very hard and a huge load of microcopic solder he had in this ball. then i remove the robber then he got up then did put a brick of cash on the table then i had to go without knowing what happen next with that amazing story . if you are so smart go head tell what happen..

hey i miss u if you read me now. cant waite to hear your personal version!
 

aznboi9

Don't mind me...
May 3, 2005
1,382
4
38
Here Be Monsters
I had read that English is more based on Dutch and that the deviation occurred due to the introduction and influences of French. Any truth to this?
 

Pantsnake

New member
Mar 20, 2006
181
0
0
I see you like to blame all Germans for the Holocaust. That is not the view of learned historians and the academics, who blame the Nazis for these atrocities. I side with the educated people, I guess you side with the ignoramuses.
First off let me say that I have travelled extensively through Europe and have made lifelong friendships with many people from Germany. In my travels I have found the people of Germany to be very warm ang gracious hosts. I have nothing against German people and know that the people of Germany today had nothing to do with the Holocaust just as I had nothing to do with putting aboriginals in residential schools.
Your statement in the first post of this thread is that you speculate on the direction that Europe may have taken had Germany won WWII. Germany at that time was ruled by the Nazis and we all know what the Nazis did. Yes I'm sure that there were Germans who disagreed with the Nazis at that time but the facts remain the same. If the Germans (the Nazis) had won the war I know Europe and the world would be a far different place right now. The fact we are even having this little debate is proof of that.
 

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
I see you have read the book. I don't really agree with you conclusions but I don't really care to debate them either.

I have read a number of books regarding history as it is a favourite of mine when it comes to reading material. Out of curiousity have your read "Blood, Tears, and Folly: An Objective Look at World War II" by Len Deighton?

My point is that the Germans lost for a number of reasons and it is doubtful that they could have won and held the territory.

I really do not understand what kind of point you were trying to make in the first place with the first post, you go from history to cars to penises.

As for German engineering concerning vehicles, I like what the Lemon Aid Car Guide has to say on the subject.
History is also a favorite of mine. However, I have not read the particular book by Deighton you mentioned. If your point is that the Germans lost for a number of reasons and that it is doubtful they could have continued to hold the territory, then your point is well taken by me. The Germans did in fact lose for a number of reasons, not withstanding that they could have won for one reason (the one I mentioned: executing the plans as put forth by the generals). And yes, it is doubtful they could have continued to hold the territory - that is even a greater certainty than their victory according to plan. The reason is that German culture was not so pervasive that whole other cultures could have integrated it, something we know too well today about the conquest of peoples.

The point I was trying to make in skipping from one thing to another and then ending at the study about the undersized German penis is no point at all, but to poke fun at German notions of superiority. Unfortunately, I could not seem to get the point across to all but Vegasdaddy. It seems that at the mere mention of the love of anything German alongside the word "superiority" gets everyone up in arms. I guess it'll be a really long time before Germans can increase military power without immediately raising suspicions if even Canadians get upset so easily.
 

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
First off let me say that I have travelled extensively through Europe and have made lifelong friendships with many people from Germany. In my travels I have found the people of Germany to be very warm ang gracious hosts. I have nothing against German people and know that the people of Germany today had nothing to do with the Holocaust just as I had nothing to do with putting aboriginals in residential schools.
Your statement in the first post of this thread is that you speculate on the direction that Europe may have taken had Germany won WWII. Germany at that time was ruled by the Nazis and we all know what the Nazis did. Yes I'm sure that there were Germans who disagreed with the Nazis at that time but the facts remain the same. If the Germans (the Nazis) had won the war I know Europe and the world would be a far different place right now. The fact we are even having this little debate is proof of that.
I agree with you that Germans are for the most part warm and gracious, even benevolent and generous. There is, however, an element of arrogance to their national character but I would say it is not without merit. However, that Nazi was the ruling party and Nazism their ideology was well received by the German people. Likewise, other brutal regimes were also well received in other nations at the time. In the late 1930's, Darwin's theories of evolution had been by now well accepted and revolutionized how humans saw their own origins and development. We were immature in our understanding of evolution, and many sought to politicize the science - hence the outgrowth of racist ideologies predicated upon genetic superiority. So while you say many Germans agreed with Nazism, I would have to speculate that something like Nazism could have also easily taken root in many other countries at that time. Take for example Japan, whose inhabitants believed that they were the superior Asians and deserved to rule all peoples of the Far East. My point is thus that it is fruitless to blame the Germans as a people for the rise of Nazism, as such attitudes towards race were rampant everywhere.
 

aznboi9

Don't mind me...
May 3, 2005
1,382
4
38
Here Be Monsters
The video below answers your question. They say that there's more to it than a
Dutch foundation overlaid with French. The interesting part is how the structure of our language was such that English would absorb other languages without being replaced by them during times of conquest, etc. A fascinating video.
Dank je

The point I was trying to make in skipping from one thing to another and then ending at the study about the undersized German penis is no point at all, but to poke fun at German notions of superiority. Unfortunately, I could not seem to get the point across to all but Vegasdaddy.
I just figured you were trying to spur up a discussion. It worked! :)
 

sonoman

Leg man.
May 14, 2005
1,830
4
0
Vancouver
My point is thus that it is fruitless to blame the Germans as a people for the rise of Nazism, as such attitudes towards race were rampant everywhere.
If you're interested, read Timothy W. Ryback's The Last Survivor which looks into the attitudes of present-day residents of Dachau. He paints a much starker picture of pervasive attitudes in Germany today. Just a thought.
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts