Wow thank you! I am very interested! Excellent! I will look forward to reading it! Thanks again!!!If you're interested, read Timothy W. Ryback's The Last Survivor which looks into the attitudes of present-day residents of Dachau. He paints a much starker picture of pervasive attitudes in Germany today. Just a thought.
Gawd, I hope you don't rely on Wikipedia for too much!Fuck you're so stupid. You're so dead wrong you might as well just be dead.
History_of_the_English_language
I quote the above link in the first 6 words of the first sentence: English is a West Germanic language.
I used wikipedia as an example. Sometimes it is good, other times it is bad. But all you need to do is search the internet and you will find many many more sites that say exactly that English is from the German family of languages. Many are from universities and other educational institutes. Here are some:Gawd, I hope you don't rely on Wikpedia for too much! Thin and skimpy.
The various invaders who came from geographically located old Europe (and please do not think that Germany existed then or any language that could be referred to as German) brought the various dialects with them to what much later became England.
And virtually all of old Europe was occupied for long stretches by the Romans, who... think carefully now, spoke what? Latin!
And, of course, Ceasar's famous "Veni, vidi, vici" (I came, I saw, I conquered) was uttered in reference to old Britain (which did not exist then, but was only a number of small fiefdoms). For those who do not know, Ceasar was the emperor of Rome and its territories, the language of which is ... Latin. You can visit Roman ruins in England from the times of their occupation many centuries ago.
You know, education really did expire at the end of the '60s.
I sure hope you don't think I'm making the claim Germans created English. I never even implied that. Just making sure you know.I agree that English is from the Germanic family of languages that was developed at used in many parts of Europe not just Germany. I don't think the Germans can claim that they created this language any more then the Dutch, Swedish, etc. It was simply a language in a regional area that spread as populations moved.
I must admit, it's an acquired taste.As far as German being a beautiful language, you've got to be kidding me. Ugh!!
What you say about German citizens knowing to some extent is a sad truth. In the late 30's and 40's however, prevailing attitudes in all the world permitted such abominations to occur. They occurred in all of Asia by the Japanese and others. They occurred in Canda and the US with the confiscation of all property and internment of the Japanese. It happened to the Basques in Spain. It happened in Stalinist Soviet Union. Humankind at that time, which was not too long ago, had a distinctively different view of race and genetics. When you think about how it was only a few decades ago, it is rather incredible.German citizens knew to a certain extent what was going on with the Jews. It would be impossible to round up millions of Jews and to kill them without most of the populace having an idea what was going on. My mother in law was a nurse in Germany and she knew what was going on and my father in law who was in the Luffwaffa also knew what was happening. They were not Nazi's, just ordinary Germans. My father in law actually flew his plane to Scotland and surrendered to the British because he wanted nothing to do with what Hitler was doing.
I'd love to go through the English dictionary with you, word by word, and trace linguistic origin or influence.Where you get your idea that the origin of English is from Latin is just totally out of the blue.
I found the study very interesting, frankly, because I found it hard to believe. Germans tend to be large in overall body, and as such it would make sense they are large in the penis too. Anyhow, it was entertaining reading (unless you're German I suppose).HEY! Not always...my ex is German and he's hung VERY nicely...He split me on more than one occasion.![]()
And similarly you should go through not just words but grammatical constructs of Modern English and Old English to see the derivation from German. There certainly are countless etymological examples from which English words can trace their origin to Latin, but nevertheless, the English language itself has its roots in German and has arguably as numerous if not more connates (sp?). But taking a step back and seeing the forest for the trees, to say that English is derived from Latin would be saying that English is closer to French, Spanish and Italian than German. That statement is not proof of my point, but the statement is obscenely ridiculous. Modern English is closer to German, Danish, and other Germanic tongues. Looking further, the 3 main classifications of language, Genetic, Typological and Areal all fit to make the ancestry of English in the German family. It is not the case with Latin, for the genetic blueprint of the peoples of Britain (including Celts) is far from the Romans, nor is it typologically correct as grammatically English is not similar to Spanish, French or Italian as it is to German, nor is it arealy associated as German tribes were documented to have engendered their language into the British isles even as Roman influences never quite made it ashore.I'd love to go through the English dictionary with you, word by word, and trace linguistic origin or influence.
There has been no argument made that Latin is the only origin of English, as it has already been recognized it has many sources (the Indo part was included in my reference to Pali, a dialect of Sanskrit used in such countries as what was Burma).
But to not acknowledge the vast influence of Latin (directly or indirectly through French for example) in the English language is an error. My school study of Latin has given me great insight into the construction and fine meaning of countless English words.
Hey GBM if you think "German is a beautiful language," you are dimmer than I thought. Achtung, baby.
I studied German for four years, and spoke it reasonably well for a few years, particularly while travelling, before largely losing it to non-use. One of my close relatives is French near Alsace and speaks German fluently.Sorry, should've clarified; The only sentace I agree with GBM on is that German is beautiful.
I would like to suggest that someone actually study German, you will realize how many compound words there are (more than English, for sure).
Your father-in-law was Rudolf Hess??My father in law actually flew his plane to Scotland and surrendered to the British because he wanted nothing to do with what Hitler was doing.
It is a good read, maybe a bit biased on the part of the author (although he is German himself). If you were being sarcastic, you forgot to put in one of these:Wow thank you! I am very interested! Excellent! I will look forward to reading it! Thanks again!!!
I don't like to use those face icons, and if at all possible I prefer to not. Unfortunately, some readers expect them (I'm not talking about you), or they take great offense. I wasn't being sarcastic, in fact, I just happened to be out today and in my travels I stopped by a bookstore to find it, but had unfortunately forgotten the name.It is a good read, maybe a bit biased on the part of the author (although he is German himself). If you were being sarcastic, you forgot to put in one of these:lol





