Should negative reviews be removed?

Sunset

Guest
Aug 10, 2004
348
1
0
Brisbane
Stephanie,

I agree with you. But, his expectations were not fulfilled. Absent of name calling and private data the review should have stayed.

The review in question did not affect my opinion of the lady. I think she Rocks and would like to meet her someday.

Stephanie said:
Ya know,

the SP, in question had it marked clearly what her measurements were (I know, guys and numbers...), and a pic was a reference. This just seems bogus, dude you knew coming to see her what you would expect. It wasn't misleading. But there was more to the story, right?
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
Okay, now I'm really leaving...I have to pee (hmm what a waste, ANYBODY OUT THERE INTO GS?)


Goodnight, I have left the building.
 

maverick73

Banned
Feb 2, 2005
2,288
0
0
Spinnerville, BC
everest said:
i am not sure but wasn't your review kind of gross? was your post about the guy taking a sh.. after the sex and messing up her bathroom? if this was your post then it went beyond even poor taste. it may have been truthful but it was very mean spirited.
I didn't even notice it got yanked. Hmmm, maybe it should have been edited instead of completely removed. Seems kinda unfair since she had some supporters who I'm sure has reviewed her positively elsewhere. Or, has the lady requested that ALL reviews of her be removed?

This one kinda bothers me. Even though it was kinda gross about taking a crap afterwards, the rest of it seemed genuine and we need those truthful negative reviews on here.
 

Maury Beniowski

Blastocyst
Mar 31, 2004
1,869
1
0
In a nice wet pussy!
Pooners have the luxury of anonymity; however SPs do not.

If pooners' phone numbers and other personal details were available for public display on Perb, I think they would quickly understand the need for privacy, albeit limited, that some SPs are seeking when they request that reviews be withheld or removed from this board, whether these be positive or negative.
 

maverick73

Banned
Feb 2, 2005
2,288
0
0
Spinnerville, BC
Notification

I personally wouldn't mind being notified by PM if a post of mine has been removed and the reason why, or if that is too much trouble, just bare notification with no reason.

Perhaps if a whole thread has been removed, there should be a sticky or a separate forum stating which threads have been removed and the reason why, or at least which threads have been removed with no reason. This would be similar to the "if you've been banned sticky thread"

Correct me if I'm wrong, I don't remember a negative review in the last month that sticked. Jonesy and Bigbasket both got their reviews yanked. Kinda bothers me because why the heck would anybody be bothered to take the time to write a negative review if it's gonna get pulled. At the very least, I hope that the 2 SP's that requested it be removed at least had ALL their other positive reviews pulled as well.
 

maverick73

Banned
Feb 2, 2005
2,288
0
0
Spinnerville, BC
everest said:
i have to disagree on this point. it was beyond an edit job. if the review was the one about crapping, i think it is the mod's duty to remove it. the other posts on that thread were also pretty disgusting. there was no respect shown.
Well the original poster mentioned the part about taking a crap, which could have been avoided. That then led to the thread taking a life on it's own, with several people claiming to put him to shame by taking an even bigger crap, etc. next time that happened. I for one fueled the fire by "egging" the posters on, although I would never personally take a crap at an SP's house as revenge.

Now, out of curiosity, if the original poster didn't mention anything about the crap, would the review have been allowed to stay? If so, then I think he should post it again as a warning to others.
 

maverick73

Banned
Feb 2, 2005
2,288
0
0
Spinnerville, BC
everest said:
without the crapping part it might have been ok. can't remember the whole post. she is the kind of sp we should be warned about.

did not realize you were part of egging them on. it was like a bunch of high school boys being quite out of control. do have to admit that i could only smile at some of the outrageous statements made. maverick, you should be ashamed of yourself! ... just teasing.
I know, I am hanging my head in shame right now :eek:
 

maverick73

Banned
Feb 2, 2005
2,288
0
0
Spinnerville, BC
Looks like the post got reinstated, in full detail :).
 

Fred Zed

Administrator
May 11, 2002
784
267
63
UP ABOVE SMILING
blowhard said:
My advice would be that if you are going to do a negative review...no matter how pissed you are...make sure it isnt in the guise of a personal attack. Tone down the rhetoric and even mention some possible positive aspects of the session (if possible). The less it looks like a personal attack the more likely it is to remain. Be negative, but respectful.
Good point. My sentiments excactly. In one negative review recently
deleted the escort claimed in an email to the Mods that the client was rough and forceful. Unfortunately, the tone and rhetoric in the review seemed to support this view. By all means post your honest opinion but reviews that are in bad taste and/or use excessive language will be removed.
 

Jonesy

Guest
Apr 4, 2005
250
0
0
maverick73 said:
Looks like the post got reinstated, in full detail :).
It came back with a note from Moderator saying he investigated it and found the SP to be far from reputable. However, review is once again missing in action.

All I know is if anyone is planning on seeing her, consider giving the money to charity or something instead as you will feel better about yourself, stop a lying SP from ripping you off and will allow you to avoid getting home and showering for about 2 hours just to get yourself feeling clean again.
 
Vancouver Escorts