Am I the only one who DIDN'T have a good steak there? Oh right, my "date" didn't either.
We both ordered ours rare and got it medium. Yeck! I was quite surprised to say the least. Once can be a fluke. Two is just ridiculous!
The service and decor were superb though.
I'm sorry to hear that.

Usually Gotham's steaks are superb! Must have been an off night for the chef.
Gothams will never capture the excellence that Hy's steakhouse has been dolling out for over 47 years!
http://maps.google.ca/maps/place?ci...t=0&ved=0CGsQuAU&sa=X&ei=xJoiTI_ODILwM6-u2OII
http://www.hyssteakhouse.com/hys-vancouver.html
I have never had even a slightly unpleasant experience there.
Even when entertaining some folks from Kansas City, MO. I chose Hy's & they did not disappoint.
In fact, when we finished my guests admitted that Hy's was as good as any steakhouse they have been to in North America.
That list includes:
Lawry's the Prime Rib - Los Angeles, CA
Morton's The Steakhouse - Beverly Hills, CA
Cattlemen's Steakhouse - Oklahoma City, OK
Gibsons Bar & Steakhouse - Chicago, IL
Benton's Steak & Chop House - Kansas City, Mo.
Ruth's Chris Steak House - Kansas City, Mo.
Plaza III - Kansas City, Mo.
Acme Chophouse - San Francisco, CA
I say go there & make sure you have a table within view of the chef at the grill so you can see the flames dance.
