Depends on which Tawnie you are talking about......Tawnie Fox ? or "The Tawny" from Victoria. Been with both and Tawnie Fox is not even in the same league as "Tawny" from Victoria. As for Sugar she is a nice women...a bit flaky but nice. Both Tawnie and Sugar are poster girls for breast enhancement. Sugar obviously paid more for hers and it shows. While Tawny is a poster girl for a great hot steamy romp in the bed and she charges less