Right to Refuse Unsafe Work (in Alberta).

cruiser

New member
Mar 17, 2007
429
0
0
I wanted to ask the general PERB public about the above mentioned statute in Alberta (see the following link: http://employment.alberta.ca/documents/WHS/WHS-PUB_li009.pdf )

I am looking for feedback from anybody that may have used it in the past or anybody who may have legal knowledge about using it. I communicated to my employer that I will not do job "X" because of unsafe work conditions due to poorly maintained equipment that could put my life at risk.

I would like to know if my employer can perhaps try and find a way around it to give me disciplinary actions in refusing to do my job. Can they say "Sorry, we don't have any money to do the necessary repairs, but we still need you to do the job". Should I be getting a lawyer in case they start putting lots of pressure on me?

If anybody has experience with this statute, I wouldn't mind getting a private IM to know what I'm up against and the best way to handle it.

Thanks,
 

freebird

Member
Aug 16, 2003
126
0
16
65
I refused to run a piece of equipment at my work due to safety concerns, and about a month later I was let go due to "downsizing". They still kept the "night shift guy" that I had trained and he is now running that equipment. Bottom line is no company will fire you for refusing to run unsafe equipment, but there are many other ways they can get rid of you. Unless you have a union or a piss-pot full of money and a lawyer, there isn't a lot you can do about it.
 

cruiser

New member
Mar 17, 2007
429
0
0
I refused to run a piece of equipment at my work due to safety concerns, and about a month later I was let go due to "downsizing". They still kept the "night shift guy" that I had trained and he is now running that equipment. Bottom line is no company will fire you for refusing to run unsafe equipment, but there are many other ways they can get rid of you. Unless you have a union or a piss-pot full of money and a lawyer, there isn't a lot you can do about it.
Good point....I would like to think that I'm an "asset" to the corporation and that they value my contribution. I will be curious to see what the outcome is.
 

island-guy

New member
Sep 27, 2007
707
6
0
Does alberta have some sort of agency similar to WorkSafe BC or the WCB ?

If so, you can always file a complaint with them for unsafe working conditions and then they'll send an inspector and the company will have no choice but to deal with the problem.

Of course you might end up downsized or something down the road but if there was a record of the complaint etc then you'd have a much easier time suing them for wrongful dismissal.
 

Jethro Bodine

Well-known member
Feb 17, 2009
4,450
1,895
113
Beverly Hills. In the Kitchen eatin' vittles.
I've been on both sides of this fence as an employee and now as an employer. Often these situations can be resolved if approached properly. If you just go to your boss and say "I'm not doing this or that because it's dangerous", that is likely to get negative reaction. Go to your boss with a well thought out rational explanation of the situation and your reasons for feeling the way you do. If yiou work in a union shop, definitely speak with your shop streward first.
The key to this or any other workplace dispute is to have as much documentation as possible. Sit down and write out exactly what the situation is with clear references as to the times and dates. Photographs or video would be helpful as well.
The other thing to consider is that certain jobs entail risk and refusal to perform "dangerous work" is not always possible. A cop can't say, I'm not going into that alley because its potentially dangerous. That's what they're paid to do.
One other thing. Your employer must have a personel file on you. In this file any workplace incidents, reprimands, performance appraisals, etc would be found. You have the right to view this at any time. If you fear retribution, ask to see your file. Copy the contents and ask your boss to date and initial each page (which is your right). That way in the future if they try to fire you and you've been a good employee, they'll have trouble establishing grounds and there won't be things suddenly appear in your file, to justify their actions.

Labor laws do vary with province so what may fly here in Manitoba with out pinko labor friendly government may not go in conservative redneck Alberta.
 

gpchillin

New member
Apr 20, 2008
129
0
0
Grande Prairie
I wanted to ask the general PERB public about the above mentioned statute in Alberta (see the following link: http://employment.alberta.ca/documents/WHS/WHS-PUB_li009.pdf )

I am looking for feedback from anybody that may have used it in the past or anybody who may have legal knowledge about using it. I communicated to my employer that I will not do job "X" because of unsafe work conditions due to poorly maintained equipment that could put my life at risk.

I would like to know if my employer can perhaps try and find a way around it to give me disciplinary actions in refusing to do my job. Can they say "Sorry, we don't have any money to do the necessary repairs, but we still need you to do the job". Should I be getting a lawyer in case they start putting lots of pressure on me?

If anybody has experience with this statute, I wouldn't mind getting a private IM to know what I'm up against and the best way to handle it.

Thanks,
I work in the oilpatch and seen people refuse work more then a few times and they might not do it but somebody has to. And well maybe once or twice was it truly unsafe some parts of the job are shitty but they have to be done and for +$300 a day you have to accept it as part of the job or goto McDonalds for $60 a day.

In the oilpatch they very very rarely fire people in over 20 years i've only heard of a handfull of people actually getting fired but those were some very major incidents, No in the oilpatch they will just stop sending you out on jobs or put you at the very bottom of the list until you just quit then there is no paperwork to do.

Now if they want you to drive a dump truck full of gravel around town with no brakes well that's a different story and maybe it's best to move elsewhere but not knowing the exact situation it's hard to say.

In the end it comes down to how much do you want your job because doing anything that upsets the job will only hurt you in the end so you have to decide if its really worth it or not because from my experience if somebody refuses to do something it's usually the boss that ends up having to do it just because it has to be done.
 

cruiser

New member
Mar 17, 2007
429
0
0
I work in the oilpatch and seen people refuse work more then a few times and they might not do it but somebody has to. And well maybe once or twice was it truly unsafe some parts of the job are shitty but they have to be done and for +$300 a day you have to accept it as part of the job or goto McDonalds for $60 a day.

In the oilpatch they very very rarely fire people in over 20 years i've only heard of a handfull of people actually getting fired but those were some very major incidents, No in the oilpatch they will just stop sending you out on jobs or put you at the very bottom of the list until you just quit then there is no paperwork to do.

Now if they want you to drive a dump truck full of gravel around town with no brakes well that's a different story and maybe it's best to move elsewhere but not knowing the exact situation it's hard to say.

In the end it comes down to how much do you want your job because doing anything that upsets the job will only hurt you in the end so you have to decide if its really worth it or not because from my experience if somebody refuses to do something it's usually the boss that ends up having to do it just because it has to be done.
I work in a similar type of industry where it involves driving driving large trucks. My Right to Refuse was based on the truck in questin having defective tires (completely worn out with less the 2/32 tread). When I raised the issue with my manager, she replied that "You drove the truck for 3 days and then raise this flag". I replied that "yes", I did notice that the tires were worn, but it wasn't until I had a tire technician look at them did I realize how bad that they really were.

The tires in question have been replaced, but she still pointed the finger at me. She doesn't want to take any responsibility and is reversing the onus back on me.

My two bits,
Cruiser
 

cruiser

New member
Mar 17, 2007
429
0
0
Alberta has labour laws ???? :confused:
Moreso based on the fact that there have been many accidents/deaths attributed to unsafe work practices that they want to try and eliminate them somehow.

Would this "statute" not be considered a labour law?
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts