puddlegul or not to puddlegurl a non review

[Dr Macoy]

I do not poon that often I find a girl I like and I see her 4 to 6 times a year.That is enough excitement for me, In the past I have been happy to see Diamond or softhandsanne.Once I find a girl and we click I am happy to see her predictable service for a couple of years till the energy fades or she retires.

I decided to see puddlegurl I liked her website and thought her extra services would be an exciting alternative.Plus the fact that she is off the beaten path was appealing to me. She is a bbw I am certainly not perfect.

I should have known pick two Price Quality Service.

The bottom line is I made an appointment waited a couple of days and she informed today she would not honor the booked appointment but If I wanted I could book one for 2 to 4 days after the original booking.

NO thanks PG I waited 4 days for an appointment and will not do it again

DO NOT PREBOOK WITH PUDDLEGURL69 she will not honor your appointment

Macoy OUT

No Drama or BS PG just the facts

 

[Rubber Man Hood]

What am I missing here?

- You had to wait to make an appointment
- You made an appointment
- She subsequently tried to change the appointment for a few days later

So what?

 

[MasterRPC]

I can understand...

when a man has needs he wants them satified. now it seems like it is a rebook. knowing her schedual hitngs happen that need her direct attention. sorry to hear about it Macoy might be worth waiting for if you haven't met her yet

 

[HankQuinlan]

Not always the case...

I had no trouble with a pre-booked apointment. I found her charming and eager to please, she certainly provided the services she advertises, and I am quite sure she would provide other items and fetishes with equal grace if asked. I found everything suggested by her website and CL ads accurate to a fault. She has a pretty face, which combined with her confidence in her abilities gives her a beauty of her own.

I was very impressed with the "puddle gurl" show she provided as a bonus shile I was slowing my heart down; not something I had ever seen quite so impressively presented.

She is absolutely a great value for money for anyone not put off by her dimensions.

BTW, if anyone is tempted by the other regular CL ads for an unnamed BBW advertising as 25 with a downtown incall, I would caution that the experience pales in comparison. She is friendly and willing, not quite as large as puddlegurl but with an impressively large post-pregnancy middle, and certainly not a "rob," but is far from a professional provider in demeanor and her space is not set up to cater to clients....and her rates are slightly higher..

 

[Dr Macoy]

I had no trouble with a pre-booked apointment. I found her charming and eager to please, she certainly provided the services she advertises, and I am quite sure she would provide other items and fetishes with equal grace if asked. I found everything suggested by her website and CL ads accurate to a fault. She has a pretty face, which combined with her confidence in her abilities gives her a beauty of her own.

I was very impressed with the "puddle gurl" show she provided as a bonus shile I was slowing my heart down; not something I had ever seen quite so impressively presented.

She is absolutely a great value for money for anyone not put off by her dimensions.

BTW, if anyone is tempted by the other regular CL ads for an unnamed BBW advertising as 25 with a downtown incall, I would caution that the experience pales in comparison. She is friendly and willing, not quite as large as puddlegurl but with an impressively large pos-pregnancy middle, and certainly not a "rob," but is far from a professional provider in demeanor and her space is not set up to cater to clients....and her rates are slightly higher..

good service was what I was looking forward to,and why I waited four days for the first appointment only to be told oops I am sorry wait four more days.

all I am saying is perhaps puddlegurl is over selling herself.

If her interest was to resolve the issue quickly I would have been OK I always
carry a gratuity for exceptional service

at the same time she was posting in CL daily trying to prebook even more appointments.

"fool me once shame on you fool me twice shame on me" cliche of the day
macoy out

 

[athaire]

Dude you should ease up a bit.....everyone gets canceled appointments from time to time. At least she tried to reschedule with you right. Certainly you are upset and disappointed but I haven't heard of any other times that this has occurred so I would tend to think you are overreacting a bit. To bad she is banned at the moment or she could speak to this directly........

Take the reschedule and then see another girl in the meantime to satisfy your needs of the moment.........

 

[tweak]

"fool me once shame on you fool me twice shame on me" cliche of the day
macoy out

that was scotty's line........

i'd be pissed big time too and take my business elsewhere.
go find yourself an orian slave girl.......

 

[planetsmurf]

who is puddlegurl?

 

[Dr Macoy]

Thanks Tweak that is what I have done, in the future when a girl says I have no time today how about in a few days my response will be OK ONLY if we have done business before. If we have not done business I will keep dialing

Wow Athaire thanks for the advice I see why you have so many post I hope there all as productive as your advice to me. I was just trying to post my experience and respond to comments.


Macoy Out

 

[not2old]

DO NOT PREBOOK WITH PUDDLEGURL69 she will not honor your appointment

This is a bit harsh. I understand that you were disappointed. Maybe the make-up appointment would have been way better than the first. Maybe she would have gone the extra mile to make up for it.

I have to cancel an appointment once and I am glad the SP did not take such a hard line with me. She fit me in a few days later. It was one of my best sessions.

You may want to consider another try. It might work out great.

 

[RobBC]

who is puddlegurl?

http://puddlegurl69.rare-playmate.com/

will answer all your questions.

More back on topic, sorry to hear that your apointment got postponed, but to be honest, SP's do have lives and sometimes shit happens. Maybe that was the case here, I don't know, but I'd be inclined to give her the benefit of the doubt unless you have a reason not to.

Of course, we can't hear her side of the story as it would appear she's currently banned from the site.

At any rate, how did she express the cancellation to you? Did she say something along the lines of "unfortunately I cannot honor our appointment today, and I apologize", or was it "screw off buddy, I got better stuff to do than see you today"?

And for the record, that's not sarcasm, I'm genuinely interested.

 

[athaire]

Wow Athaire thanks for the advice I see why you have so many post I hope there all as productive as your advice to me. I was just trying to post my experience and respond to comments.


Macoy Out

I have sooooo many posts because I spend entirely to much time on these boards.....as for the advice, well take it or leave it up to you. I appreciate your wanting to get your experiance out there, hell I do it all the time. But you are also damaging a girls rep with some of your comments and that is indeed harsh considering she offered to rebook....... I think your plan about rebooking with girls you have seen is a good one. I am sure you will have all kinds of luck......

 

[Dr Macoy]

I have sooooo many posts because I spend entirely to much time on these boards.....as for the advice, well take it or leave it up to you. I appreciate your wanting to get your experiance out there, hell I do it all the time. But you are also damaging a girls rep with some of your comments and that is indeed harsh considering she offered to rebook....... I think your plan about rebooking with girls you have seen is a good one. I am sure you will have all kinds of luck......

I dont see anything damaging in any of my post just facts and how I felt about my experience with puddlegurl.

As for your advice Athaire I think it is more about your need to feel superior and give advice than actually helping people on this board certainly your "advice" post had a condescending tone that I did not appreciate .The good news is it has brought attention to puddlegurl who seems to be good at marketing herself I am sure she will thrive. In the meantime I will continue my quest for a sp who is a good fit,excuse the pun

Macoy not only out but done this is childish garbage.

 

[bigmoe69er]

Macoy has a right to express his opinion and share his experience! He did so in an appropriate manner. I am glad that he had the balls post. Hank's post was also very well done.


---Dr. Moe

 

[not2old]

I dont see anything damaging in any of my post just facts

I just don't think that your statement that "DO NOT PREBOOK WITH PUDDLEGURL69 she will not honor your appointment" is a factual statement. This means that all appointments that are prebooked will not be honored.

This is clearly an over statement and paints an situation that is far from reality.

 

[cljw31]

I don't know, i wouldn't just not book with someone based on one review. It's cool if you don't feel like seeing this person again but don't tell everyone not to do it as well.

 

[athaire]

As for your advice Athaire I think it is more about your need to feel superior and give advice than actually helping people on this board certainly your "advice" post had a condescending tone that I did not appreciate .

Sniff.....you think I am condecending with a need to feel superior?????? LOL....far from it. If you don't like the comments given in your threads don't post them. You don't have to agree with everything everyone has to say, just as I don't. I think you are the one that has the problem not myself.......a girl cancelled and tried to rebook....hmmmm....yup she is the devil.....lol.

I am glad you posted this thread though to give a little weight to any future reviews you might do.....ohhhh wait you don't review. You just come here and take from the board and don't give back unless you have hurt feelings.........

 

[tweak]

Sniff.....you think I am condecending with a need to feel superior?????? LOL....far from it. If you don't like the comments given in your threads don't post them. You don't have to agree with everything everyone has to say, just as I don't. I think you are the one that has the problem not myself.......a girl cancelled and tried to rebook....hmmmm....yup she is the devil.....lol.

I am glad you posted this thread though to give a little weight to any future reviews you might do.....ohhhh wait you don't review. You just come here and take from the board and don't give back unless you have hurt feelings.........

he's pissed, posted what happen.
pg is still on cl "daily" taking appointments.
his story does have some merit.
pg should have offer some sort of compensation to make things good.
like ordering a pizza and finding out they lost your order, and it'll be another hour before they can send you out another one. i'd be pissed big time.
just my take on things.....

 

[Dr Macoy]

Sniff.....you think I am condecending with a need to feel superior?????? LOL....far from it. If you don't like the comments given in your threads don't post them. You don't have to agree with everything everyone has to say, just as I don't. I think you are the one that has the problem not myself.......a girl cancelled and tried to rebook....hmmmm....yup she is the devil.....lol.

I am glad you posted this thread though to give a little weight to any future reviews you might do.....ohhhh wait you don't review. You just come here and take from the board and don't give back unless you have hurt feelings.........

Perhaps my words were strong I was angry and it shows in my post any idiot can see that, it does not make them less relevant for me. 100% of the time I tried to book PG I was let down I am over it I am sure PG is long over it, you guys keep going though.

As far as my contributing to the board this is why, its silly I do not comment on other peoples post normally. and try not to give unsolicited advice to pooners.I have nothing to prove on this board if my lifestyle was such that I had value to ad I would, because I have taken away, but I am not doing anything that is not already well documented so I keep quiet.

Why don't you ask the advertisers if the guys like me are a welcome addition to this board or the moderators instead of attacking me? because I just don't care

whats good for some is clearly not good for others all I can say is in my years of pooning I have had quiet friendships with a few people who are associated with this hobby while avoiding drama.That is what matters to me

Whatever I am sure this post will bring another string of useless advice and self centered post most of which has already been pointed out I used to blame certain SP for the drama on this board I am now realizing it takes more than one as...... to create a useless thread

 

[athaire]

Perhaps my words were strong I was angry and it shows in my post any idiot can see that, it does not make them less relevant for me. 100% of the time I tried to book PG I was let down I am over it I am sure PG is long over it, you guys keep going though.

As far as my contributing to the board this is why, its silly I do not comment on other peoples post normally. and try not to give unsolicited advice to pooners.I have nothing to prove on this board if my lifestyle was such that I had value to ad I would, because I have taken away, but I am not doing anything that is not already well documented so I keep quiet.

Why don't you ask the advertisers if the guys like me are a welcome addition to this board or the moderators instead of attacking me? because I just don't care

whats good for some is clearly not good for others all I can say is in my years of pooning I have had quiet friendships with a few people who are associated with this hobby while avoiding drama.That is what matters to me

Whatever I am sure this post will bring another string of useless advice and self centered post most of which has already been pointed out I used to blame certain SP for the drama on this board I am now realizing it takes more than one as...... to create a useless thread