Performance Reviews - a few questions...

cruiser

New member
Mar 17, 2007
429
0
0
It's time for my annual performance review at my job and I would like to ask the PERB audience a few questions about a PR. I've gathered by reading past comments that there are a lot of people in management or senior positions and thus could give me some advice.

1) Are you obligated to sign your performance review....even if you don't agree with what has been written? Can my manager force me to sign it?

2) How should I react if my boss has received "feedback" from others about me that isn't true or has been "stretched"?

3) It sounds (from past discussions at my company), that the employees generally receive an annual salary increase. Do I have any flexibility in negotiating the amount I receive?

4) Do I have any other legal rights that I may not be aware of ?

Would appreciate feedback from any and all. I know that we may not want to talk about work while we are exploring other "recreational" activities, but I have been quite impressed with the level of responses that I have seen in other posts that I've seen posted.

Thanks,
 

Miss*Bijou

Sexy Troublemaker
Nov 9, 2006
3,131
44
48
Montréal
I'm no expert but still giving my 2 cents based on my personal experience :)

I may be corrected by others on some points but here's my opinion :) I skipped the last one as I have no clue about legal issues :eek:

Btw.. I'm assuming you aren't part of any union..? (you probably wouldn't need to ask here.)


1) Are you obligated to sign your performance review....even if you don't agree with what has been written? Can my manager force me to sign it?
I don't think you are obligated to sign it if you disagree with one or more points however if you are contesting some comments, you need to be able to argue your point. I've seen others do just that and if you can come up with something that they cannot argue against, I've seen others get those comments removed or changed before they agreed to sign it.

They cannot force you to sign it if you do not agree.. but depending on your reasons for refusing to sign, it may be all politics from then on so I wouldn't resort to this unless you have a strong case or there is something major to contest.




2) How should I react if my boss has received "feedback" from others about me that isn't true or has been "stretched"?
I think managers "usually" go to more than one person for feedback on an employee so if one person is stretching the truth and their comments differ from the general opinion of all the others, your boss will probably question this person's credibility, objectivity or motives and rely on the others comments for your review.

If they all "stretch" the truth, then you might want to start kissing ass a little more before your next performance review. Just a thought. :p




3) It sounds (from past discussions at my company), that the employees generally receive an annual salary increase. Do I have any flexibility in negotiating the amount I receive?

I assume all companies have different policies.. but some companies determine the specific % of salary increase based on how you "score" on your perfomance review while other companies don't have a specific pre-determined % but rather leave it at the manager/director's discretion to determine an amount they feel is deserved after reviewing your performance.

I don't think there is any negociating possible unless your company's policy for salary increase is the first one I described and you are contesting some points in your review (which would affect your overall "score" and as a result may also affect you pay increase.) but otherwise, I think you just smile and say thank you.. and once you're out the door, you start calculating how much more taxes you now have to pay and if your paycheque will actually be any different. :eek: :p
 

Guardian Angel

Active member
Feb 26, 2006
1,379
4
38
72
It's time for my annual performance review at my job and I would like to ask the PERB audience a few questions about a PR. I've gathered by reading past comments that there are a lot of people in management or senior positions and thus could give me some advice.

1) Are you obligated to sign your performance review....even if you don't agree with what has been written? Can my manager force me to sign it?

In our company I would ask employees to sign. If they are in disagreement with any part of the review, it should be written for the record with something suggesting the items(s) be dealt with and a time frame set, so they can be cleared up in a positive manner. Do not sign if you disagree with any major points that could affect your job down the road. Just a safety precaution and it puts responsibility back on your supervisor to work on the item(s) they may have pointed out. Reviews are a two way street.

2) How should I react if my boss has received "feedback" from others about me that isn't true or has been "stretched"?

Make it clear you disagree and for the record, once again write it down on your review (as stated in the above).

3) It sounds (from past discussions at my company), that the employees generally receive an annual salary increase. Do I have any flexibility in negotiating the amount I receive?

This is determined by whether your company has a set salary review program with increase levels based on your review performance. Most good salary programs have a set of standards that determine your salary and clear description of what you can expect to make for your position including how you can achieve increases. Be sure to bring many examples of what value you have brought to your company, through sales, community work, new procedures, or other things that are beneficial to your company's growth and well being.

4) Do I have any other legal rights that I may not be aware of ?

Yes , all you need to do is check with Labor Standards in your area to see what rights you may have, like notification periods required for pay decreases, number of hours worked or significant job description changes. If any changes are severe, call a lawyer for further consultation as the Labour Laws and Standard Law practices are different depending on your years of service and position you hold in the company.

I am not a lawyer, but my role with our company was to handle salary programs and as needed offer severance packages and assist in our salary review and performance review program completions. Hope this helps some. I can give more details if you like to PM me.

G.A.
 
If your performance review is based on Looks, Attitude and Service, your boss is probably on Perb. In a non-union environment, in my experience, it can be directly related to how big a tip you get (i.e. raise), and whether they want to repeat with you (do you get to keep you job, opportunities for advancement). In a union environment, it's more to do with performance management.
Any performance review process of any merit will get feedback from more than one source, often from other supervisors or from peers. It's always more risky to go with just one review, whether it's a shill or someone with an axe to grind. A consistent pattern will usually tell a more accurate story.
Fortunately for most, it's very unlikely to be posted on the internet.

George
 

Very Veronica

Banned
Aug 2, 2004
1,765
7
0
Vancouver
Just tell him you are on the NRP list.
 

steven69

Member
May 16, 2004
177
3
18
The Wet Coast
Any good performance review document will have a place for the employee to respond with their own comments.

If you feel that the review does not correctly reflect you, your performance or that their are other impacting factors that have adversely effected your review should respond in a clear and non emotional manner. If you need more space write it up separately and request that it be attached to your final review (Have your manager acknowledge receipt of your portion with a signed copy that you keep, If you are concerned that it will not be included in the final document you may want to send it along to HR directly).

With that portion completed I would sign the document. It confirms that the review process took place and that you participated in the process.

In most firms performance reviews become a part of that employees HR file.

In my experience performance reviews provide three functions in a corporation:

1. It helps to evaluate an employees strengths and weaknesses in terms of their work and provide a starting point for discussion as far as to areas needing improvement, areas where additional training or assistance from the company can be provided, and opportunities for the employees growth and career advancement within the company.

2. It provides an evaluation for compensation (merit pay, bonuses, raises) and possible job advancement.

3. It can also be used to provide documentation to allow a company to build a case to release an employee. If you are going to git rid of an employee and not pay out a huge compensation package you need to show that their work or actions did not fit the company's needs, that the employee was informed and that coaching and corrective action was attempted and not met (this process takes some time).

If you plan to stay and wish to build a career at your company take the document seriously. Make sure that it shows you in the best light possible and that you are an active and constructive participant in the process.
 

visiting

Active member
Oct 23, 2005
997
1
38
right behind you!
Crusier,

First off, don't get stressed, it's only a review.

When your signing your review, it's not that you agree 100% with what was said, it that you were made aware of it. If your working for a company, they want you to be part of the solution, not a problem, so the review normally is done to let you know what the company (your manager) thinks of your performance. Remember it is in the companies best interest for you to always be improving, that is why they pay you. They certainly don't like to have unhappy staff.

If your working for a unionized job, chances are that your union rep is with you for the review, and again that is to confirm you were told the review. Talk to the rep before and ask them what to expect, as they most likely have does this a few times before...

As for feedback, nobody likes a cry baby, so be carefully how you react, certainly do more listening that talking. Ask for explanations if your not sure, if specific facts are mentioned in your review that are wrong, you can mention it, absolutely, but don't get aggressive about it, that will not help you down the road, remember you have to work with all the people there.... If the review is done in groups, then you may want to talk to the manager after 1 on 1, and discuss the problems if they were specific to you only.

As for Pay, that is always negotiable, just harder to do in larger companies, but still possible. Don't just ask for more money, think about other things that can be negotiated, expenses ei gas, work clothing, cars, vacation time, work hours... ect, ... Here I think you need to be open to different options, and really you want to try to get your manager to make you an offer, then you can negotiate from there. Let them talk see if they mention anything that you can use to your advantage, then after they made their offer, and if you want to get a little more, talk about your expenses, tell them your considering a second job etc etc, just don't lie, then that may get you a little more, as the first offer is almost never the best.....

legal, I am not a lawyer, but you can certainly talk to you union rep if you are unionized, or if not talk to co workers, or look-up the laws, maybe try here....http://probononet.bc.ca/public.php



but the best advice....... listen to VV.....
 

Sweetiepie

New member
Sep 7, 2005
230
0
0
This advice is based on where I work, with the understanding there is always some variation: If you suspect anything wrong will happen during the performance recview, its best if you have a union rep or coworker with you as a witness. In any case, stay calm and listen during the review. Do not argue or try to refute anything. Just see it as gathering evidence for yourself as to what they are saying. Save your arguments for later, after you've had time to think about them and perhaps get help in forming a good response in writing. Read the actual form to see what your signature means. Often it simply means that you have read the review. Not that you agree with it. If they pressure you to agree or respond to it, refuse and say you need time to think about it. There should be some provision for you to provide a written response on the form or to be attached to the form. In that written response, you can refute the allegations. If you don't get too adversarial and they're not out to get you, they might just leave it like that in your file so anyone reading it the future gets to read both sides of it. And do get union or other help, as its hard to handle these things on your own. The emotions cloud your judgement even if you know what to do. One more thing. About allegations that are not true, what I would do is tell them you are going to forumulate a response and tell them you need to know the basis for the accusation/report that they received about you. If they say "so and so said..." you ask them "I need the specific details of what you were told actually happened and when." If they do give you the details, you can refute them by writing your version of what happened. If they don't give you details, you can tell them they need to remove it from your report as the information is not supported by any evidence, and they can't go by innuendo. If they refuse to remove it, then in your written response you point out that report's allegations are not supported by any evidence and the employers conclusions are unfounded. Basically, the important thing is to let them know you will hold them accountable for accuracy.
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts