Nuclear Power = Insanity

Fudd

Banned
Apr 30, 2004
1,037
0
0
http://www.canada.com/topics/news/national/story.html?id=d5f7f6ae-00ce-4119-a0fd-20388bb72e29&k=82870

Wholly fuck! Have the gone insane! How can anybody even think of going to nuclear power in this day and age.

Nuclear power is distructive to the environment, dangerous, unreliable and it doesn't even make economic sense.

Why the hell don't they put there money into clean renuable power like wind, solar, tidal wave or geothermal power sources. Or better yet just cut back and conserve.

If this gets approved and if the UN isn't able to put a stop to this, I'll going to break out my protest equiipment and head down to Edmonton and chain myself to the doors at Energy Alberta Corp.
 

Fudd

Banned
Apr 30, 2004
1,037
0
0
I should also start saving some $$$ cause I'd like to see Karma in Edmonton. Think she'll do an outcall to a downtown office and provide service while I'm chained up? :D
 

mikael

Banned
Aug 15, 2007
193
0
0
I should also start saving some $$$ cause I'd like to see Karma in Edmonton. Think she'll do an outcall to a downtown office and provide service while I'm chained up? :D
Well that's one way to get the media's attention ;)
 

therealrex

HUH?
May 19, 2004
927
1
0
If you really want to get away from CO2 producing power then Nuclear is the only real choice we currently have. The media love to talk about wind and solar and they can be used but they will never be our main source of power generation.
 

john23

Member
Apr 1, 2006
601
0
16
123
www.elsewhere.org
Nuclear power plants of the more modern variety (so called "fast neutron" reactors) use up 95%+ of their fuel and can use spent fuel from older style reactors. Given that there is now quite a lot of spent fuel hanging around it probably makes sense to use it up rather than just bury it.

In comparison old style reactors can get energy from only about 10% of their fuel before it becomes unusable.

Normally I'm not too keen on nuclear power but given that CO2 emissions now pose a far greater danger and given that we already have very inefficient reactors that waste fuel probably having a few of these around would be a good thing. I read about fast neutron reactors in Scientific American a while back if anyone cares to look it up.

IMO geothermal power is overall the best solution for large scale energy plants but there are still technical hurdles to make it practical.
 
Dec 31, 2006
572
5
0
I've seen and read a few things recently that suggest that nuclear power is by far the cleanest most efficient source of power. Coal mines & oil drilling produce more pollution on-site and much more when consumed. As well, they cause more deaths than nuclear incidents such as Chernobyl or 3 Mile Island.

While no one would argue that Chernobyl and 3MI were not terrible accidents, those 2 break down happened in very large part because they were poorly maintained and out of date. Scientists have learned from the mistakes of the past and have developed better technology because of it. Modern Nuclear plans are much safer and it is only fear mongering that prevents the development of safer, more modern plants.

Here is the scary thing that I heard recently (Documentary called Crude Awakening)

-We will be out of oil in 10 years time.
-We are 40+ years away from actual hydrogen fuel production and use, in large part because it's all theory right now and they have yet to develop safe means of production & delivery.
-Wind, solar, etc "clean" forms of energy produce insignificant amounts of energy for general use.
-Ethanol production consumes more oil energy than it outputs as ethanol.
-It would take 10,000 brand new massive Nuclear plants, operating at full capacity to meet our current energy needs. The need will only increase as countries like China & India continue to modernize. At that rate, we would consume all of the uranium within 30 years.

We are on the very cusp of a crippling global energy crisis and it is terrifying. :(
 

metoo113

Member
Aug 2, 2002
407
0
16
Somewhere Down The Crazy River
"We will be out of oil in 10 years time."

They've been saying that for fifty years. :D
 

Horse99

New member
Aug 17, 2006
555
1
0
Vancouver
When the oil runs out...nuclear is next!

or you can shiver to death in the dark....easy choice for me....Nuclear power doesn't bother me.....there have been countless oil spills in the past 20 years, compared to how many deaths from accidents at nuclear plants? I bet none in the past 20 years.

Some country in Europe named France, gets at least 70% of their electricity from nuclear. Would you rather us burn coal?
 
Dec 31, 2006
572
5
0
"We will be out of oil in 10 years time."

They've been saying that for fifty years. :D
Ah but they were talking about very specific oil sites, Venezuela & Texas etc. Those places are almost out, if not actually out and the predictions were accurate, it's only because they found new pans to plunder that we still have oil.

They now have the technology (satellite, etc) to detect oil pans beneath the surface before drilling. The scary things is that the middle east is on of the few places that have significant amounts oil remaining, but they have yet to detect any new oil pans, even with all of the technology.
 

kman32

New member
Jul 4, 2007
108
0
0
I agree Nuclear Power is not a good idea. But we've been so slow to act that alternative sources of energy aren't far enough along to replace fossil fuels. I really wish Canada would become a leader in this race to develop green technology. However, when you have eco-warriors like James Lovelock suggesting that a massive shift to nuclear power may be the logical course, you have no choice but to consider it. He is the creator of the Gaia world model after all.

Check out this article. It was relative in 2005, it's even more true today.

http://www.gwynnedyer.net/articles/Gwynne Dyer article_ Nuclear Power.txt
 

metoo113

Member
Aug 2, 2002
407
0
16
Somewhere Down The Crazy River
Ah but they were talking about very specific oil sites, Venezuela & Texas etc. Those places are almost out, if not actually out and the predictions were accurate, it's only because they found new pans to plunder that we still have oil.

They now have the technology (satellite, etc) to detect oil pans beneath the surface before drilling. The scary things is that the middle east is on of the few places that have significant amounts oil remaining, but they have yet to detect any new oil pans, even with all of the technology.
A number of these sites have been refilling with oil which is causing a number of people to re-think the origins of oil. http://www.nationalreview.com/nrof_bartlett/bartlett052902.asp
 

furball8

Honi soit qui mal y pense
Sep 24, 2006
76
2
8
The biggest concern is that if oil rich Alberta builds a nuclear reactor, the USA may easily get them confused with Iran. This could trigger an immediate invasion and search for WMD, or at the very least they would accuse them of being part of the axis of evil. Seriously though, no form of energy generation can be ignored if it can meet safety and enviromental standards. Improvements in reactors and waste storage keep coming, so the old "nuke=insanity" is short sighted ideological blather. I have no problem with wind, solar, geothermal, or whatever, but don't discard a technology that produces NO greenhouse gasses so quickly.
 

wolverine

Hard Throbbing Member
Nov 11, 2002
6,384
9
38
E-Town
A really good source of energy gives us daylight every day. Just have to improve the technology to make use of it somehow.
 
Mar 18, 2007
107
0
0
I've seen and read a few things recently that suggest that nuclear power is by far the cleanest most efficient source of power. Coal mines & oil drilling produce more pollution on-site and much more when consumed. As well, they cause more deaths than nuclear incidents such as Chernobyl or 3 Mile Island.

While no one would argue that Chernobyl and 3MI were not terrible accidents, those 2 break down happened in very large part because they were poorly maintained and out of date. Scientists have learned from the mistakes of the past and have developed better technology because of it. Modern Nuclear plans are much safer and it is only fear mongering that prevents the development of safer, more modern plants.

Here is the scary thing that I heard recently (Documentary called Crude Awakening)

-We will be out of oil in 10 years time.
-We are 40+ years away from actual hydrogen fuel production and use, in large part because it's all theory right now and they have yet to develop safe means of production & delivery.
-Wind, solar, etc "clean" forms of energy produce insignificant amounts of energy for general use.
-Ethanol production consumes more oil energy than it outputs as ethanol.
-It would take 10,000 brand new massive Nuclear plants, operating at full capacity to meet our current energy needs. The need will only increase as countries like China & India continue to modernize. At that rate, we would consume all of the uranium within 30 years.

We are on the very cusp of a crippling global energy crisis and it is terrifying. :(

Sorry, for totally going off topic here.

Is it just me? I find Izzy totally sexy when she talks science:D
 

Sir_frixalot

Big Pink Steel
Nov 15, 2006
227
1
0
Calgs
When the lights go out, just stay in and SHAG. Sounds good to me...

That guy from Alberta Energy does look like a young Monty Burns... It's all just a promo for the movie, RIGHT..? Like 7-11 becoming Quickie Mart...

I already told ED what I think of renaming Peace River - Springfield, I want to open the DOME DEPOT "for all your DOME needs"... If you haven't seen The Simpsons Movie, download it so you get that joke...
 

festealth

Resident Troll
Sep 8, 2005
276
0
0
Everyone touts wind power but few consider that wind generators are just reaching sizes of 5 MegaWatts, and most of the existing ones are much less than that. It costs about $1 million to install one wind generator when you take the research, plant costs, and then transmission costs and the substation. Not at all cheap. And they are a blight on the landscape, noisy, and can only supply power when the wind blows.
There's more than enough hot air coming from Al Gore to constantly turn those turbines, lol.
 

littlejimbigher

New member
Jun 21, 2006
1,438
4
0
surrey
Nuclear power doesn't bother me.....there have been countless oil spills in the past 20 years, compared to how many deaths from accidents at nuclear plants? I bet none in the past 20 years.
Ask people in Belarus and the Ukraine about how many people are still dying
from radiation caused cancers due to Chernoble.

I actually belive nuclear power might have to be the way to go but between fear of accidents and huge cost over runs it will not happen in Canada.
 

Fudd

Banned
Apr 30, 2004
1,037
0
0
I have several objections to nuclear energy. One of the biggist problems is with all the nuclear waste that is just piling up around the world from various sources. Yes it may be stored or contained for now, but nuclear waste can be redioactive for centries if not thousands or years. We have got to think about the future generations who will have to deal with the by product of our neglect.

Even thought the workers in the nuclear industry are monitored to exposure we've got to think about the long term damage not just to the workers directly by all their decendents because of all the damage the low level of radiation exposure have done to their DNA.

And any body remember the Simpson's intro when Homer inadvertenly gets nuclear material on him and goes out of the plant and it ends up in the public. With all the workers in these plants and the exposure to radioactive material some is bound to leek out into the public in one form or another.

Also nuclear material is a limited resource and when all the Uranium is looted from the Earth what will we do then. It will be the same situation as the dwindling supply of oil we have now.

No, nuclear is not the way to go. The only solution is to go to renuable resources such as solars, biofuels, wind, tidal power and so on. But the only real solution is to just use less. We need to shut down industries that consume vast amounts of energy. We need to take personal responsibility and conserve. Turn off that light when your not using it, take public transit or your bike. Chose only energy efficient appliances or do it manually. We just can't keep raping the planet of its riches forever.
 

Sir_frixalot

Big Pink Steel
Nov 15, 2006
227
1
0
Calgs
NEWS FLASH

The Nuke is to power the OIL SANDS
so more oil can be produced cheaper
and that will increase the CO2 overall
cuz oil just wants to be burned, donit?

We gotta drain those reserves before
somebody smart invents something so
we don't need as much oil any more.
Investors got mansion payments too.

Suzuki must be layin low
oiling up the uzi and the 303
Gonna get some oil execs
From the rooftops someday

The Chinese will re-build the railway
from Peace River to the coast
didn't get it right a century ago
for 2-way traffic: oil out, troops in

Study the map of the USA
You may need to run there someday
Where you stand will be scorched earth
They never fight at home///
 

sdw

New member
Jul 14, 2005
2,185
0
0
I've seen and read a few things recently that suggest that nuclear power is by far the cleanest most efficient source of power. Coal mines & oil drilling produce more pollution on-site and much more when consumed. As well, they cause more deaths than nuclear incidents such as Chernobyl or 3 Mile Island.

While no one would argue that Chernobyl and 3MI were not terrible accidents, those 2 break down happened in very large part because they were poorly maintained and out of date. Scientists have learned from the mistakes of the past and have developed better technology because of it. Modern Nuclear plans are much safer and it is only fear mongering that prevents the development of safer, more modern plants.

Here is the scary thing that I heard recently (Documentary called Crude Awakening)

-We will be out of oil in 10 years time.
-We are 40+ years away from actual hydrogen fuel production and use, in large part because it's all theory right now and they have yet to develop safe means of production & delivery.
-Wind, solar, etc "clean" forms of energy produce insignificant amounts of energy for general use.
-Ethanol production consumes more oil energy than it outputs as ethanol.
-It would take 10,000 brand new massive Nuclear plants, operating at full capacity to meet our current energy needs. The need will only increase as countries like China & India continue to modernize. At that rate, we would consume all of the uranium within 30 years.

We are on the very cusp of a crippling global energy crisis and it is terrifying. :(
The vast majority of nuclear fuel that has made a first pass through a reactor can be recycled. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_fuel_cycle

The reason that this is not currently being done is because money doesn't like risk. It's expensive to build the reprocessing plants for nuclear fuel and capital investors don't want to put the money in if nuclear power plants to use the fuel are not going to be built.
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts