Carman Fox

No Review List???

Status
Not open for further replies.

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
Well, that it then...

As soon as it gets out that as an SP all you have to do is put yourself on the DNR List, Shiek is going to be swamped with requests. Pretty soon, there won't be many left to be reviewed. Sheik, you may have started the beginning of the end for PERB. Too bad, I really thought it was a great resource.
 

visiting

Active member
Oct 23, 2005
997
1
38
right behind you!
Ok thinking outside, or around the box...


Ok if Sheik feels that strongly about protecting the names on the DNR list, for whatever reason, we need to find a way to make everyone happy.

I suggest an RL....


a list of ladies that don't mind reviews, and to make it simple for the girls, they would have to opt out.
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
Ok thinking outside, or around the box...


Ok if Sheik feels that strongly about protecting the names on the DNR list, for whatever reason, we need to find a way to make everyone happy.

I suggest an RL....


a list of ladies that don't mind reviews, and to make it simple for the girls, they would have to opt out.
Basically, same thing in reverse. I don't think Sheik would go for it. He has already stated the reason for his decision - because he said so.
 

kehoe

I shoulda been a farmer
Apr 16, 2003
784
0
0
you're soooooooo incredibly hot Ava...whoops...inside voice. Great attitude though girl. It goes to my earlier point wayyyyyyyyyy back in the first part of the thread; if you are providing a great service and aren't super antagonistic, it makes almost no sense to be on a no review list.
 

visiting

Active member
Oct 23, 2005
997
1
38
right behind you!
If a lady is on a public DNR list how are the moderators supposed to see reviews and make the judgement if she belongs on a DNR for legitimate or fraudulent reasons? The DNR is taken seriously and its not "easy" to get on it.

You do realize we keep track of these bad reviews and whether the reviewer has credibility or not?

People are going to have to learn to stop jumping to conclusions without having all the evidence in front of them.


Sheik,

All I am trying to say is by not publically disclosing the DNR list, your not helping people take an informed honest decision. The board is the biggest and best in the world, because people want to get information. By keeping this information hidden, you expect people to have faith in you blindfully? That is what is harder to accept for everyone.
 
Jun 20, 2005
781
0
0
The Wet Coast
For this topic, at this point, this smilie is appropriate.

<img src="http://i151.photobucket.com/albums/s126/luv-em-n-lv-em/beatdeadhorse.gif" alt="beating a dead horse">

Note to animal lovers: I mean it metaphorically, not literally
 

sdw

New member
Jul 14, 2005
2,185
0
0
<img src="http://i151.photobucket.com/albums/s126/luv-em-n-lv-em/beatdeadhorse.gif" alt="beating a dead horse">

Note to animal lovers: I mean it metaphorically, not literally
At least they are admitting that there is a No Review List. Remember, a few months ago a similar thread was dismissed by moderator who insisted that there was no such thing.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
At least they are admitting that there is a No Review List. Remember, a few months ago a similar thread was dismissed by moderator who insisted that there was no such thing.
And I was suspended for 7 days for pointing out that one does exist.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
you're soooooooo incredibly hot Ava...whoops...inside voice. Great attitude though girl. It goes to my earlier point wayyyyyyyyyy back in the first part of the thread; if you are providing a great service and aren't super antagonistic, it makes almost no sense to be on a no review list.
So when a SP decides to raise their rates above the average all the while giving stellar service and getting ragged on, that you will show your support so they wouldn't have to resort to requesting to be placed on a DNR List?
 

mick_eight

Banned
Feb 21, 2005
1,197
0
0
How dare you presume to think you know better than those who have been experienced in maintaining this for years? TERB is the largest local review board in the world, is bigger than ASPD (a national board) and catching up with TBD (another national board) in terms of sheer numbers of people perusing the board. The same policy is in place there that is in place here now.

I've explained myself time and time again and this will be the last time I explain it.

If a lady is on a public DNR list how are the moderators supposed to see reviews and make the judgement if she belongs on a DNR for legitimate or fraudulent reasons? The DNR is taken seriously and its not "easy" to get on it.

You do realize we keep track of these bad reviews and whether the reviewer has credibility or not?

People are going to have to learn to stop jumping to conclusions without having all the evidence in front of them.
Hmmmmmm. Terb 62,000 Perb 29,000. ISG 172,000 not counting the USA or Argentina section. No wonder the leafs never win. They can't count.
 

kehoe

I shoulda been a farmer
Apr 16, 2003
784
0
0
So when a SP decides to raise their rates above the average all the while giving stellar service and getting ragged on, that you will show your support so they wouldn't have to resort to requesting to be placed on a DNR List?
I never said anything about rates. I don't judge an sp based on rates. I may decide whether or not to see her based on her rate but I certainly wouldn't judge or slag her on that fact. I've always said that an sp can charge whatever she wants and if she can get it then hats off to her. My first basis for judgement has always been attitude and outlook. Any review I've ever written has always placed a higher importance on attitude and service. My allegiance is and always has been to those ladies that treat me honestly and with kindness.

As far as a lady raising her rates are concerned, I think that over time there is an accepted level that her rate may be raised without offending anyone. As long as the service is top notch then I can't see her drawing any negative attention.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
scubadude said:
However, they do provide a service and can be as professional as any doctor, lawyer, actor or tradesman. And as their services are regularily reviewed, I am not sure I see why Sps can't.
All of those occupations listed are considered socially acceptable. They aren't concealed as this industry in all perspectives and that is all depending on how the SP market themselves.
For the very reason why you use an inanimate handle to identify yourself with but it's also to shield oneself from scrutiny is one of the reasons why a SP would request to be placed on the list. This just isn't an issue of privacy but protecting from stigma and judgement until pooning becomes morally acceptable. Is a DNR List all that bad?
kehoe said:
I never said anything about rates. I don't judge an sp based on rates. I may decide whether or not to see her based on her rate but I certainly wouldn't judge or slag her on that fact. I've always said that an sp can charge whatever she wants and if she can get it then hats off to her. My first basis for judgement has always been attitude and outlook. Any review I've ever written has always placed a higher importance on attitude and service. My allegiance is and always has been to those ladies that treat me honestly and with kindness.

As far as a lady raising her rates are concerned, I think that over time there is an accepted level that her rate may be raised without offending anyone. As long as the service is top notch then I can't see her drawing any negative attention.
I'm merely pointing out that the raising rates and receiving backlash have been one of many reasons why SPs have asked to be on the DNR List. This isn't a question that you needed to answer personally.
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
he
How dare you presume to think you know better than those who have been experienced in maintaining this for years? TERB is the largest local review board in the world, is bigger than ASPD (a national board) and catching up with TBD (another national board) in terms of sheer numbers of people perusing the board. The same policy is in place there that is in place here now.

I've explained myself time and time again and this will be the last time I explain it.

If a lady is on a public DNR list how are the moderators supposed to see reviews and make the judgement if she belongs on a DNR for legitimate or fraudulent reasons? The DNR is taken seriously and its not "easy" to get on it.

You do realize we keep track of these bad reviews and whether the reviewer has credibility or not?

People are going to have to learn to stop jumping to conclusions without having all the evidence in front of them.
Sheik, with respect, (I can't believe I'm cowtowing this way) the issue is that you haven't explained the reasons adequately. In fact, you're now contradicting what you said earlier on. Early on you indicated that an SP had the option of either being or not being reviewable. Then you said that if an SP had enough bad reviews, she would be removed from the DNR list and her reviews re-instated. Now you are saying the it is "not easy to get on it." Sorry, but there does not seem to be a consistant policy regarding this issue. Even in the posting policy sticky, there is no reference to the DNR.

Perhaps you could take this up with Fred. We're not asking you to give up your first born just to give some sober consideration to this issue.
 
Last edited:

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
he

Sheik, with respect, (I can't believe I'm cowtowing this way) the issue is that you haven't explained the reasons adequately. In fact, you're now contradicting what you said earlier on. Early on you indicated that an SP had the option of either being or not being reviewable. Then you said that if an SP had enough bad reviews, she would be removed from the DNR list and her reviews re-instated. Now you are saying the it is "not easy to get on it." Sorry, but there does not seem to be a consistant policy regarding this issue. Even in the posting policy stick, there is no reference to the DNR.

Perhaps you could take this up with Fred. We're not asking you to give up your first born just to give some sober consideration to this issue.
I don't think you're going to get an answer any more than the "Stephanie" handle, despite hate mail, will be changed anytime soon. You made a valiant effort and you should be proud of it.
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
I don't think you're going to get an answer any more than the "Stephanie" handle, despite hate mail, will be changed anytime soon. You made a valiant effort and you should be proud of it.
Thanks Steph. You're an angel.
 

souljacker

Total Noo-B
Dec 14, 2005
406
0
0
It has been addressed and I wont be posting a DNR list on PERB for obvious reasons.

The only DNR list needed is that for the moderating team to peruse.
Umm, OK, so call me dense, but what are the obvious reasons? I think everyone understands that there are valid reasons for having a DNR list, but the consensus seems to be (even amongst the ladies) that the list itself should be public.
Seems rather arbitrary and just a bit draconian. I would have thought that the members thougts would be given a bit more consideration.
Arbitrary and draconian? On perb? :rolleyes:
 

souljacker

Total Noo-B
Dec 14, 2005
406
0
0
How dare you presume to think you know better than those who have been experienced in maintaining this for years?
.....
People are going to have to learn to stop jumping to conclusions without having all the evidence in front of them.
Nice. First you get all pissy because somebody dares to offer a suggestion (here's a hint: successful admins/mods pay attention to people's suggestions rather than getting mad at them for daring to have an opinion... Whether or not you choose to act on those suggestions is entirely up to you, but berating people for offering them is just dumb), and then you get mad that people are jumping to conclusions without having all of the evidence. Gee, then maybe you should actually give people the evidence so that they don't jump to conclusions? I know, I know, perb policy is to keep absolutely everything hidden in the shadows, and never explain anything.

I've really been trying to take you at your word as a guy who's just trying to clean up the board, but your actions sure make that difficult.
 

souljacker

Total Noo-B
Dec 14, 2005
406
0
0
My memory is a bit different.

I don't recall him saying that they denied its existence. My memory is that he said he never heard from them that it did exist. And he had apparently asked on numerous occasions.
Actually, you could be right. It might have been that his questions were just met with silence rather than denial. Maybe I'll ask him on the other board.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Vancouver Escorts