No Review List???

Status
Not open for further replies.

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
So if a woman keeps her pics and text pretty demure and does not list any services, you could at least understand her desire to be on such list?

To me, the reason I dislike reviews, even non-graphic ones, is that I feel the experiences vary greatly. I have a 3-hour minimum, which allows for a lot of flexibility. I communicate a lot before a meeting to get a feel of the person. So every time I meet someone, I strive to create experience that will be UNIQUE for that particular individual. Also, people attracted to me like to keep their lives private.

So a positive review that says anything beyond "I met her and had a great time" feels (a) intrusive and (b) useless, because the details are not likely to be repeated with someone else.

I do, however, completely concur with the value of negative reviews as a useful tool of warning others.
You're right. Experiences do vary. However, multiple reviews indicate a trend useful to pooners. When 1 out of 10 reviews buck the trend...the pooners are the first ones to call foul.

I don't think you can ban positive reviews and not ban negative reviews. Otherwise it would be called the Pacific Escort Bitch Board. PEBB.
 

Dakota Wood

Complex Goddess
Mar 2, 2005
578
0
0
54
Vancouver
Could someone give me some examples of reasons why SPs feel they should be exempt from review?
Sure, as I've said before:

TMI- Some of the ladies have very location specific incalls. To say that she is located in a hi-rise on Maple St. between Vine and Cypress Ave. seems harmless enough, but if that is the only hi-rise on that block, you have just disclosed exactly which building she is in. Both safety and privacy issues arise from that.

YMMV-Just because there was dfk with PoonPro, it doesn't mean I will do the same with PoonNB, who hasn't brushed his teeth since the weekend and it's Thursday. It's awkward to tell PoonNB why he isn't getting the dfk he read about.

Just because I gave VicNick a ride to the ferries afterward, it doesn't mean I will give up an hour of my time to do the same for IslandIan, yet if VicNick posts that I did it for him, IslandIan would expect the same, and be disappointed if he doesn't get it.

Just because I went an hour over shooting the shit with AsianAuto, because I was enjoying the conversation, it should not be a given that I will do the same with FordFan. Yet FordFan is left feeling 'ripped off' if he doesn't get off the clock time.

SADP- Short arms, deep pockets. Not my idea of an ideal guest. The very last thing I want is someone booking with me simply because my donation is 50 dollars less then the next lady, and thanks to a positive review, it has been confirmed that a good time will be had.
 

visiting

Active member
Oct 23, 2005
997
1
38
right behind you!
Miss Wood,

Obviously nobody should write any information as to your exact location, as it is useless information, unless your a stalker, some may just want to know the area. But I don't think that is a reason to be on the DNR list, you could always ask the reviewer to remove it, or have the mods do it, I think most on the board would find that to be very resonable. Only in rare cases excact loactions may be usefull, thinking other dangers, & B/S.

Regarding the activities, honestly when I read a review, I don't take it as a fact that the SP in question will do everything mentioned with me. I have talked to some SP's that have explained about guys smelling bad, bad teeth etc etc, so maybe they didn't permit Daty, digits, etc etc. I think most adults respect that every situation is YMMV.

Yes if I see it often I will think it is a normal activitiy, but if I hear SP Jane, took Dave to the ferry, or she cooked him dinner, I will not expect her to cook me dinner, unless she adverstised that, even less take me to the ferry. I look at the reviews for attitude, and personality, trying to figure if we would match. What you could also do is ask your reviwer to not mention that you cooked him dinner in the review, as that is not a normal activity, even if it is totally a GFE thing! LOL? New acronym CYD? Cooks You Dinner?


In my case, if a saw someone on a public DNR list, I may go see her. But if there is no list, and I try to find information on her, I would be worried there is something bad, this is the reason I tend to see older SP's, who I found to much more honest/upfront. The only thing is if she posts on boards often, then I could maybe see her style... Example I like yours.
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
So if a woman keeps her pics and text pretty demure and does not list any services, you could at least understand her desire to be on such list?

To me, the reason I dislike reviews, even non-graphic ones, is that I feel the experiences vary greatly. I have a 3-hour minimum, which allows for a lot of flexibility. I communicate a lot before a meeting to get a feel of the person. So every time I meet someone, I strive to create experience that will be UNIQUE for that particular individual. Also, people attracted to me like to keep their lives private.

So a positive review that says anything beyond "I met her and had a great time" feels (a) intrusive and (b) useless, because the details are not likely to be repeated with someone else.

I do, however, completely concur with the value of negative reviews as a useful tool of warning others.
Sure, as I've said before:

TMI- Some of the ladies have very location specific incalls. To say that she is located in a hi-rise on Maple St. between Vine and Cypress Ave. seems harmless enough, but if that is the only hi-rise on that block, you have just disclosed exactly which building she is in. Both safety and privacy issues arise from that.

YMMV-Just because there was dfk with PoonPro, it doesn't mean I will do the same with PoonNB, who hasn't brushed his teeth since the weekend and it's Thursday. It's awkward to tell PoonNB why he isn't getting the dfk he read about.

Just because I gave VicNick a ride to the ferries afterward, it doesn't mean I will give up an hour of my time to do the same for IslandIan, yet if VicNick posts that I did it for him, IslandIan would expect the same, and be disappointed if he doesn't get it.

Just because I went an hour over shooting the shit with AsianAuto, because I was enjoying the conversation, it should not be a given that I will do the same with FordFan. Yet FordFan is left feeling 'ripped off' if he doesn't get off the clock time.

SADP- Short arms, deep pockets. Not my idea of an ideal guest. The very last thing I want is someone booking with me simply because my donation is 50 dollars less then the next lady, and thanks to a positive review, it has been confirmed that a good time will be had.
I don't think the issue is should there be a list? But why it isn't posted for all to see? The girls both give fine examples of why they may want to be on one. But it should be visible to all......
 

Dakota Wood

Complex Goddess
Mar 2, 2005
578
0
0
54
Vancouver
New acronym CYD? Cooks You Dinner?


In my case, if a saw someone on a public DNR list, I may go see her. But if there is no list, and I try to find information on her, I would be worried there is something bad, this is the reason I tend to see older SP's, who I found to much more honest/upfront. The only thing is if she posts on boards often, then I could maybe see her style... Example I like yours.
CYD, that is funny.

As for your last paragraph, absolutely make the list public. While some people will stick to there guns that there just shouldn't be a DNR list for any reason, there are others like yourself and Althaire who don't mind a list, just post it already...and finally, thank you, that's kind of you to say.
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
I don't think the issue is should there be a list? But why it isn't posted for all to see? The girls both give fine examples of why they may want to be on one. But it should be visible to all......
I'm sorry, but I don't think theses are fine examples for not being reviewable. In no way is identifying a building going to threaten an Sp's security. She is releasing the info to strangers in any regard. I already offered a rebuttal to Thais objections.

So I'll repeat..could I have good reasons for a particular SP to feel she is exempt from review?
 
Jun 20, 2005
781
0
0
The Wet Coast
In no way is identifying a building going to threaten an Sp's security.
If a lady has posted her pics (including her face), then what you are saying is ridiculous. Some of these ladies have, or could attract, stalkers. And specific information about their location could certainly jeopardize their security.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
If someone making up review as you claim ask yourself why? You must be deserving. In past I have had false reviews and I figure out why and change way I am and all problems went away.
What are you smoking? This makes about as much sense as TTT being on time.

I deserve getting or giving a service I'm not accustomed to providing? That's what the false review said. So it is I that has to change?
 

Stephanie

Banned
Mar 6, 2007
17
0
0
I'm curious Stephanie, what were these false accusations and how did you change for the better?
particular men post things to make themselves feel big about themselves. change how you advertise and how people can talk about you on boards can help a lot. surprised you donnot know this.
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
particular men post things to make themselves feel big about themselves. change how you advertise and how people can talk about you on boards can help a lot. surprised you donnot know this.
You didn't answer the question.......come on. Your so good at telling us why we are losers and your soooooo righteous so please enlighten us with some of your experiances......
 

TotallyTouchin

TOTALLY TOUCHABLE
Oct 22, 2005
600
4
0
45
Vancouver
Ok

What are you smoking? This makes about as much sense as TTT being on time.

I deserve getting or giving a service I'm not accustomed to providing? That's what the false review said. So it is I that has to change?
WHOA WHOA WHOA!!!!!!

I know there has been alot of whacko stuff happening on perb here recently and a strange poppy thread turned into like "I smoke the things that some from these poppies thread" but you...my dear, have just CROSSED THE LINE!!!!!!:eek: :D

TTT (That is me).....is ALWAYS at LEAST within the hour that I call back and say I may be there.....if there is no traffic....and the dogs don't have some sort of problem....and my rib isn't hurting from a weird stage thing I did....and my frosted flakes were crispy that morning.

SOOOOO....PLEASE do NOT! talk about my timeliness. I have watch (not found but I may get it an hour or so from now).

So yes....messed up thread no doubt.

Ummmm can we post a no review list or not?

Is there a no review list or no? Can we just make the list public and UPKEEP IT?

Can we inform the mods who is on it too to make their job easier and so the girls don't have to race around reminding them about the request and that it exsists?

Does it really matter if you get to review the girls on it or not?

If it does...maybe just avoid them.

If it' is too big of a crap shoot (ok bad word there)...if it is a ROLL OF THE DICE...then please....take the names...post the list....guys can avoid ladies if they please....and the rocket science that is hurting my brain is over.

There. Sheik. I am sure you are a good looking fellow who likes to look good but I think the beauty sleep is over and it would be nice to have the issues here addressed as there are a few of them.

Take care. I need to rest now. I've got Izzie waiting:p
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
Hmmmm

It has been addressed and I wont be posting a DNR list on PERB for obvious reasons.

The only DNR list needed is that for the moderating team to peruse.
Seems rather arbitrary and just a bit draconian. I would have thought that the members thougts would be given a bit more consideration.
 

visiting

Active member
Oct 23, 2005
997
1
38
right behind you!
It has been addressed and I wont be posting a DNR list on PERB for obvious reasons.

The only DNR list needed is that for the moderating team to peruse.

I disagree with you, the obvious reasons, so far all the ladies have agreed with posting their names on a public list, with 1 exception. Let the ladies vote on it, maybe the ones on the DNR list have valid points, but if you don't list a few of these points, this topic will come up, again, and again, and again!

I think in the long run, your just giving the mods more work to do, as if the list is public, new girls/ and perb-erts will just live with it, but until then, how do you expect the guys who write reviews to react to their reviews are being removed, after the fact?
 
Jun 20, 2005
781
0
0
The Wet Coast
Frankly at this point it is game over on this issue, at least for a few months. This topic will come back sooner or later, we'll do this all again, get the same results ... Just like the GFE-means-BBBJ-not-CBJ debate etc.

The PERB community came together, tried to get changes made but it didn't work.

Continuing to harp on this ad nauseam isn't likely to accomplish anything.

It isn't our board - it is theirs. We don't have to like it. That's the way it is.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Vancouver Escorts