Asian Fever

No Review List???

Status
Not open for further replies.

LeBeau

New member
May 26, 2006
160
0
0
I wonder if there is a way to reach some kind of comprimise. CLM and Tiff have brought up valid points as to the SPs perspective of reviews. However, as a pooner, it really pisses me off when I give up my hard earned cash on session that is shit because I was either unable to find proper info (a review ) to make an informed decision or I didn't bother to check the board on a particular lady because I was in a horny stuper and couldn't wait to check my computer.

The thread I was referring to when I first launched this thread was started as an inquiry (411) about a certain SP. The initiator was not posting a review, but rather seeking info. The SP immediately responded by having the question deleted. Not a review. There wasn't even an opportunity for anyone to provide the member with a "non-detailed" response from someone who may have had knowledge.

If there was a policy that allowed for a DNR list to be published but still allowed the opportunity for enquiries to be made without details. Perhaps to alleive any feelings that their security maybe comprimised. Would this be acceptable to all involved?
You need to learn to make your request small for something you were not to have. Publishing the No Review List, in and of itself, is a big step for Fred.

So, if Fred acquiescence’s in publishing it, that should be enough and there should not be any more request for “inquiries” about those on the No Review List.
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
You need to learn to make your request small for something you were not to have. Publishing the No Review List, in and of it, is a big step for Fred.

So, if Fred acquiescence’s in publishing it, that should be enough and there should not be any more request for “inquiries” about those on the No Review List.
Yeah but being on the DNR list is not necessarily an indication of whether or not members would recommend her service.
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
You need to learn to make your request small for something you were not to have. Publishing the No Review List, in and of itself, is a big step for Fred.

So, if Fred acquiescence’s in publishing it, that should be enough and there should not be any more request for “inquiries” about those on the No Review List.
I agree.......if you have the list in the public eye you don't have to see someone that may or may not be a WOT.......so there is no need for further inquires.
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
I agree.......if you have the list in the public eye you don't have to see someone that may or may not be a WOT.......so there is no need for further inquires.
Sigh......well perhaps we could start with the publication of the list. That would be something, at least. I still feel, though, that the whole concept of the 'list' is contrary to the nature of this board.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
Not quite sure if I understood this comment.
Me thinks Stephanie is half of a duo that was reviewed here. Steph advertises on CL.

I also believe that Stephanie's handle, my former handle, is going to cause a bit of confusion for potential clients interested in seeing and judging by posts made.
 

visiting

Active member
Oct 23, 2005
997
1
38
right behind you!
While I have no problem with a girl not wanting to be reviewed......how is Fred going to know if a girl is a scammer or rip off? The DNR policy will effectively stop the flow of info? Are we to pm the mods with all our complaints about the girls on the list and let them sort out our differences like referees? I think they have enough on their plates just trying to keep the place running never mind being judge and jury for us. And if the members of the board have no input into who is judging for us what is a scam and what isn't why would any of us trust those decisions?
Your correct, but I would think that if someone is on the DNR list, and you get Scammed, you could mention it to Fred/Mod's, and when the scam is a regular activity Fred takes her off the DNR list. Yes we take Fred's /Mod's word for it. I am not talking bad reviews, I am talking scamers, as you and I can both see the same girl and have 2 different sessions, one Great, and 1 not so not, but rather scams. I agree with you, it is not 100% perfect, but in life what is?
 

TTTWISTER

New member
Jul 28, 2006
168
0
0
Chicago
Although I am very new to this forum and my only real intrest here is to gather some (hopefully objective) information for an upcoming trip I have to add my $.02.

Sheik gives several examples and reasons for the NRP none of which hold any weight IMHO. Probably the most compelling argument is one of safety for SP's being stalked, threatened or otherwise harrassed. While a legitimate concern for the women working in this industry it seems to be far outside the scope of the function of this forum. When those kind of problems arise then Law Enforcement should be involved. I also doubt very seriously that a NRP or any other action on the part of this board would have any impact on somebodys propensity to commit such an offense.

Towards the end he talks about peoples posts being pulled and their being legitimate reasons for this. Again IMHO, in an open forum, the only valid reason that I could see for this happening is in the case of verifiable slander or open threats.

Probably most troubling to me are Fred Zeds comments " Boards provide the user with different ways of interacting with other members and ladies all for free " (the emphasis is mine). " We never guarantee we will carry reviews of all the ladies out there. Learn to make the best use of what you have instead of asking what you cannot get." It is this kind of pompous attitude that infuriates me. It seems to me that this forum exists only on the good graces of the people who use it for information. The minute the integrity of that information (through commission or ommision) becomes suspect this board becomes worthless.

I would be curious to know how many of the SP's on that list are paid advertisers. I may be wrong but it seems to me to be a case of the tail wagging the dog.
 

Thais

New member
Apr 29, 2006
238
1
0
Calgary
A response to those who say that "no reviews" automatically equals bad service:

Some people who participate in this lifestyle are not into writing reviews. They may find them distasteful, or compromising privacy. Some would lurk and read the reviews, others would stay away from boards alltogether.

And sometimes, the bulk of a girl's clientele may consist of such people.

I find it ironic. I was so torn on the subject of reviews: should I allow them, or not, or should I request that they are non-graphic? Finally, I decided to keep my fingers crossed and not say anything.

Apparently, I consistently meet people who don't write reviews. This may be an anecdote and have no statistical significance, but it happens too.
 
Last edited:

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
A response to those who say that "no treviews" automatically equals bad service:

Some people who participate in this lifestyle are not into writing reviews. They may find them distasteful, or compromising privacy. Some would lurk and read the reviews, others would stay away from boards alltogether.

And sometimes, the bulk of a girl's clientele may consist of such people.

I find it ironic. I was so torn on the subject of reviews: should I allow them, or not, or should I request that they are non-graphic? Finally, I decided to keep my fingers crossed and not say anything.

Apparently, I consistently meet people who don't write reviews. This may be an anecdote and have no statistical significance, but it happens too.
Not all reviewers are jerks. And some of us do enjoy the reviewing part. I do. I don't for an instant think that a girl on the list would instantly mean bad service, but if she isn't wanting to be a part of my pooning experiance I would like to know so I am not wasting my time with research, contact, possible travel issues etc. One look at the list eliminates these people from my list.....very helpful.
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
Not all reviewers are jerks. And some of us do enjoy the reviewing part. I do. I don't for an instant think that a girl on the list would instantly mean bad service, but if she isn't wanting to be a part of my pooning experiance I would like to know so I am not wasting my time with research, contact, possible travel issues etc. One look at the list eliminates these people from my list.....very helpful.
I am repeating this as I just don't want to have to even see girls on the list.
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
Okay.........


- if a lady is on the DNR and has received 3 or 4 bad reviews over a period of say a couple of months. Some from known and some from unknown reviewers you may or may not pull their names. In the meantime some of us could very well have spent time and money and could have avoided this with access to the list information. No one is going to offer to refund my money that is spent while others are judging for me what is fair treatment.

-The list is here to stop girls from being reviewed so it will be serving its purpose without tyeing up your time.

-If a lady isn't putting her pic out there that is her business. If her rates are out of my reach I would not care as I would not be seeing her. There will be idiots whining about every issue going.......look at this thread.....In my opinion not a great reason to not post list.

-Not having alot of experience other than casually looking at TERB and MERB I can't say if the membership likes or dislikes how the DNR list is handled. I understand that it is different for each. Terb hides while Merb displays their lists. Perhaps we would like to see this board modeled on the Merb style rather than the Terb style........but we don't have input on that end of things or do we?

-Yes Fred's boards are the most stable and have the best database right now. And mistakes happen. Of course the rules are going to be argued about. But this issue isn't about posting habits, or unpaid advertising its about hiding information that is valuable to the membership. Simply put how can someone make an informed decision without access to the names on the list? They can't....

-In closing I agree that the input from the ladies is good for all.
 
Last edited:

giantfeet

New member
Apr 1, 2006
3
0
0
There are hobbyists out there who don't want to read reviews before seeing a girl. They want to read the ads and see her pics, but don't want to know with how many guys she'd been with in how many positions. Remember, this hobby is about fantasy.....

These guys will prefer seeing the ladies on the non-review list.

If a girl doesn't mind losing some customers because she is on the list that's her choice.
 

TheGuy

Banned
Jul 26, 2003
1,183
7
0
Vancouver
No review list

I have seen SP's who provided great service but when I mentioned the review board they specifically asked me NOT to review. They were concerned that information might be provided that could over time expose this work to their family.

There are more and more SP's that show pics of their faces but many still would not want this work exposed.

I respected this request of course.
 

wilde

Sinnear Member
Jun 4, 2003
3,041
48
48
If a lady is on a DNR list and she consistently gets bad reviews, all of her bad reviews get reinstated and she is removed from the DNR list. How do we know this? Because we can see the deleted reviews. We usually pull them off the DNR after the 3rd or 4th bad review that is verifiable. (meaning from known & respected reviewers, not newbies)
Well thank you for clearing that up but tell me how many times have this happened exactly? Just curious.


.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
With all do respect Fred and Sheik,
the general concensus now isn't whether or not a DNR List should exist but why it isn't publically posted as a sticky with the displaying applicants.

When can we members, SPs and pooners, expect to see the list publically posted? It benefits everyone if it is.
 

wilde

Sinnear Member
Jun 4, 2003
3,041
48
48
Fred n a few others own this board & can do whatever they want. If someone doesnt like it he or she can hang elsewhere
You should loosen up that leash just a little bit.;) Many have and more will follow.

.
 

Ryan C Crust

Banned
Jan 4, 2007
42
0
0
Metrotown
There are hobbyists out there who don't want to read reviews before seeing a girl. They want to read the ads and see her pics, but don't want to know with how many guys she'd been with in how many positions. Remember, this hobby is about fantasy.....

These guys will prefer seeing the ladies on the non-review list.

If a girl doesn't mind losing some customers because she is on the list that's her choice.

Sorry I don't mean to sound astonished at your naivety but... if a guy doesnt want to read about an escorts other clients or her service from other guys.... an ESCORT REVIEW BOARD is the last place he should be hanging out since that is the PURPOSE of the place!

If all he wants to do is see her ads and pics then go to an advertising site like "Escorts-Canada" or "Hollywood North"..... don't go to a REVIEW BOARD!
And if he does go to a REVIEW BOARD then AVOID THE REVIEW FORUM and JUST visit the advertising forum.... it's not rocket science! lolololol!!!

Holy crap! :p
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts