No Review List???

Status
Not open for further replies.

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
I'm not sure that this is really the case. It seems to me that the overwhelming majority of the SPs receiving positive reviews are those in the average to above average donation rate. I really think that a scan of the board members seems to indicate members are prepared to part with $$.5 to $$$ relatively easily. Hence, a look at the advertisers shows the same trend.
That's why I said "for instance". Kehoe was mentioning that it would be in the SPs best interests commercially if they allowed reviews to be posted on them. What I was displaying was that in a few cases I've observed SPs were bashed repeatedly and they just happened to be out of reach for the average PERBERT, so to speak.
 

jjinvan

New member
Apr 4, 2005
684
0
0
You know, there isn't really much of a reason to actually post the list.

If a search for a girl's name doesn't turn up quite a few reviews, by different people who are known not to be her alter-ego shills, then don't bother seeing her.

Also, everyone pretty much knows which girls get a significant number of their reviews deleted and so are on the 'no negative reviews' list. Don't bother with them either.

No reviews = Bad reviews.
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
You know, there isn't really much of a reason to actually post the list.

If a search for a girl's name doesn't turn up quite a few reviews, by different people who are known not to be her alter-ego shills, then don't bother seeing her.

Also, everyone pretty much knows which girls get a significant number of their reviews deleted and so are on the 'no negative reviews' list. Don't bother with them either.

No reviews = Bad reviews.
I disagree.....a new member will not be in the know about these ladies. Possibly until to late. If the list is visible he/we can decide to see them or not. Its ridiculous to not be showing it to the membership.......
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
You know, there isn't really much of a reason to actually post the list.

Also, everyone pretty much knows which girls get a significant number of their reviews deleted and so are on the 'no negative reviews' list. Don't bother with them either.

No reviews = Bad reviews.
That's a pretty pathetic, shallow assumption and argument.

If I recall, when a SP applies to be on the DNR List, any reviews currently available on the database accessible by the search function, will be removed.

And so by your logic if I should ask to be placed on the DNR List in the near future, I would be considered a service deficient SP.:rolleyes:

jjinvan said:
If a search for a girl's name doesn't turn up quite a few reviews, by different people who are known not to be her alter-ego shills, then don't bother seeing her.
It was one or a couple of people. Can't you move on? Are all SPs on the DNR List a reflection of those poor experiences/examples that abused the privilege of being placed on the List?
 

Stephanie

Banned
Mar 6, 2007
17
0
0
A few days ago a thread popped up about a certain SP (not Large Lips). The SP being asked about posted a response indicating that she was on a "no review list" and that if the thread was not terminated immediately, she would remove it herself.

I, in turn, added my 2cents. My feeling was that this is a review board and and that as such, guys come here to either post reviews (positive or negative) or to research SPs so as to make an informed decision.

Strangely enough, the thread, very shortly thereafter, disappeared.

Is it true that there is a "no review list" on this board? Can any SP simply because she doesn't like any negative comments have the option of becoming "invisable" or "off limits" to the members of this board?
Look, this isn't about you. If a girl doesn't want to be reviewed that is up to her and none of your business. Deal with it.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
Look, this isn't about you. If a girl doesn't want to be reviewed that is up to her and none of your business. Deal with it.
Hi Steph, Steph here. I originally had the handle you are currently using. I didn't think it could be used again. Weird. I actually thought my handle had been changed back when I saw it. It freaked me out.

If you read the thread throughly you'd see Scubadude was beginning to understand the List from a SP's perspective.
 

wilde

Sinnear Member
Jun 4, 2003
3,041
48
48
Are all SPs on the DNR List a reflection of those poor experiences/examples that abused the privilege of being placed on the List?

No but my money is on a large portion of the SPs on the DNR list do so because of consistent negative reviews.

.
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
Look, this isn't about you. If a girl doesn't want to be reviewed that is up to her and none of your business. Deal with it.
Actually it is our business....we are the paying customer. I do not want to see an SP that will not be reviewed. If she is on a list that is not public it impacts my ability to pursue my hobby in a manner that makes me happiest. The fact she doesn't want reviews is secondary to not having that info at the onset of the process......I would then not waste my time and money, or her time for that matter.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
It's true, Steph. *that's so weird*

Actually it is our business....we are the paying customer.
We all want to strike a balance with the DNR List pooners and SPs. Pooners will make their own decision on whether to book with an SP on the DNR List. You say it's none of the pooners business if a SP places themself on a DNR List, I say it's none of the SPs business if a pooner declines to book an engagement with them. And really, what is gained or lost from either perspective? It's an easy compromise.

This name/handle/former handle thing is freaking me right out, by the way.
 

TotallyTouchin

TOTALLY TOUCHABLE
Oct 22, 2005
600
4
0
45
Vancouver
To add to what CLM is saying though

there was a time way back when...

ok NOT WAAAY back when

that I wanted to be on the do not review list simply because my reviews became...for lack of a better word...SHIT SHOWS.

I requested kindly to a mod once that he remember that I had asked to be on the DNRL and no response. Then I told him I thought it was silly that we have this and in the mean time allow a circus to take place.

His response was "What is silly are people like you who advertise here and do not want reviews."

I cannot remember what mod it was...but it was a mod who obviously did not like the idea of the do not review list.

I know I was not unkind in my request and I think at the time it would have been in the best interest of the board for me NOT to have been reviewed as there were many antics that seemed to always follow them....that was my reasoning for the request in the first place.

So, a do not review list should exsist in my opinion but it should be totally public. It does not mean the lady is a bad provider but she should not have to explain her reasonings.

If someone is a crazy ripoff than the neighborhood watch would be the section for that I would imagine.

I think that it would be nice though if the mods upheld the do not review list. This particular one blatantly seemed against it and as a result, I told them "never mind" put me on the review list. Have been ever since...
 

john23

Member
Apr 1, 2006
601
0
16
123
www.elsewhere.org
The problem for any SP not allowing any reviews for themselves, assuming they are hoping to get business via this board, is that its likely they are not going to get that much business via perb. The only people who, rationally, would want to be on a no review list here would be people who are willing to sacrifice business from here.

Personally, I'm very wary of seeing anyone with no reviews unless:
1) their information (via craigslist, website etc) is valid - photos being a good benchmark
2) have identifiable posts here or somewhere else and seem relatively intelligent
3) aren't obviously part of an agency (ie a bunch of people have the same phone number)

3 makes me think we should maybe review agencies/mps more often rather than restricting reviews to only the individual workers. Often the agency management is more of a problem than the workers in my experience.

With 2 above I'd be suspicious if the person was on here for a long time and never got reviewed.

1 is obviously a crap shoot but I've had pretty good luck as professional "porn" photos have a very distinct look (no shadows at all). Also, a closeup pic of someone's ass doesn't really give me much info to go on and as a result I will pass.

In some ways just going to a place and meeting the girls is the easiest as its pretty obvious the ones who hate their job and the ones who don't. I have made mistakes in the past but mostly its worked out. Also, with the all inclusive places its unlikely that they are going to globally change their rates just because one person becomes popular by virtue of a good review. 3 above notwithstanding there are some places that I go to that aren't too bad. Unfortuately the one full service place I used to go to had gotten alot worse the last time I went there.

I think alot of the problems with reviews as TTT pointed out would go away if there were paid moderators and a clear mandate to eliminate character assassination of any member. Ironically, what I hear is competing SPs (and agencies) are often more of a problem than customers.
 

LeBeau

New member
May 26, 2006
160
0
0
there was a time way back when...

ok NOT WAAAY back when

that I wanted to be on the do not review list simply because my reviews became...for lack of a better word...SHIT SHOWS.
That caused me to laugh so hard, I nearly fell out of my chair. The way you expressed yourself was too funny.

Thanks for the laugh...:)

Regarding the "No Review List." Fred Zed has the final say and he says it ain't going to happen. That is, there will not be any publishing of those on the No Review List and there will continue to be a No Review List.

But, if there was a possibility of Fred changing his mind, I would suggest, at least publishing those SP's on the No Review List in the sticky section.

:)
 

visiting

Active member
Oct 23, 2005
997
1
38
right behind you!
Look, this isn't about you. If a girl doesn't want to be reviewed that is up to her and none of your business. Deal with it.
Stephanie, I think the logic is that your guilty of being a Bad Sp, until you have proven otherwise. If your on the Public DNR list, then maybe pooners will cut the SP's some slack, as thinking she has been around for a while, can't be that bad. Also if an SP is regularly bad, Fred Zed said he would not honor the DNR request, so I think a public list would not hurt the SP as much...

It's an easy compromise.

This name/handle/former handle thing is freaking me right out, by the way.
Stephanie #1, I was going to say you have 2 handles, and that you posted from a different computer and did not pay attention! LOL
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
Comprimise

I wonder if there is a way to reach some kind of comprimise. CLM and Tiff have brought up valid points as to the SPs perspective of reviews. However, as a pooner, it really pisses me off when I give up my hard earned cash on session that is shit because I was either unable to find proper info (a review ) to make an informed decision or I didn't bother to check the board on a particular lady because I was in a horny stuper and couldn't wait to check my computer.

The thread I was referring to when I first launched this thread was started as an inquiry (411) about a certain SP. The initiator was not posting a review, but rather seeking info. The SP immediately responded by having the question deleted. Not a review. There wasn't even an opportunity for anyone to provide the member with a "non-detailed" response from someone who may have had knowledge.

If there was a policy that allowed for a DNR list to be published but still allowed the opportunity for enquiries to be made without details. Perhaps to alleive any feelings that their security maybe comprimised. Would this be acceptable to all involved?
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
Stephanie, I think the logic is that your guilty of being a Bad Sp, until you have proven otherwise. If your on the Public DNR list, then maybe pooners will cut the SP's some slack, as thinking she has been around for a while, can't be that bad. Also if an SP is regularly bad, Fred Zed said he would not honor the DNR request, so I think a public list would not hurt the SP as much...



Stephanie #1, I was going to say you have 2 handles, and that you posted from a different computer and did not pay attention! LOL
While I have no problem with a girl not wanting to be reviewed......how is Fred going to know if a girl is a scammer or rip off? The DNR policy will effectively stop the flow of info? Are we to pm the mods with all our complaints about the girls on the list and let them sort out our differences like referees? I think they have enough on their plates just trying to keep the place running never mind being judge and jury for us. And if the members of the board have no input into who is judging for us what is a scam and what isn't why would any of us trust those decisions?
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
Yeah, just stick something up somewhere else. Especially effective if they are advertising on CL.
No need to be an asshole big guy.....sheesh. She has a right to her opinion without the harsh backlash........
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Vancouver Escorts