No Review List???

Status
Not open for further replies.

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
Ok. The lady doesn't want the details of a review posted. Would it be acceptable to everyone if someone was to simply ask if the members of the board would recommend a DNR in the 411 section? Those with knowledge could simply respond with a yea or nay.
 

jjinvan

New member
Apr 4, 2005
684
0
0
You can try to ask for info about a girl with no visible reviews in the 411 section, but make a point of asking for the info to be PMed to you because any negative comments on the thread would lead to the girl 'demanding' that the thread be deleted...
 

anonanon

Vancouver Blond Expert
Aug 29, 2006
1,228
4
0
Downtown Vancouver
If there is a no review list, we should be able to see it. It's only fair.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
You can try to ask for info about a girl with no visible reviews in the 411 section, but make a point of asking for the info to be PMed to you because any negative comments on the thread would lead to the girl 'demanding' that the thread be deleted...
It's a so-so way. PM is not that much better. Rumours are spread that way, I would know having been the subject of many recently.

To combat that problem the inquirer should carefully consider what is being told to them. Information on SP and their service and nothing else. Anything more is BS until you hear, see, feel it from the SP themselves.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
Ok. The lady doesn't want the details of a review posted. Would it be acceptable to everyone if someone was to simply ask if the members of the board would recommend a DNR in the 411 section? Those with knowledge could simply respond with a yea or nay.
Now we're talking.
 

visiting

Active member
Oct 23, 2005
997
1
38
right behind you!
I am trying to figure out what is better, for the ladies who don't want to be reviewed. to be on a public DNR or not?


I can see that some people would go on another board and post a review, if it gets deledted on perb, so I wounder if there are less chances of it happening if Perb had a public DNR list?


Am I wrong to think it is easy for a girl to escape reviews or confusing us by simply changing her name?
 

jjinvan

New member
Apr 4, 2005
684
0
0
So, let me get this straight:

A girl having a website with her phone number, photos with unblurred face, rates and services doesn't put her in danger.

The same girl putting an ad on perb in the SP section doesn't put her in danger.

The same girl posting fake positive reviews of herself in the reviews section doesn't put her in danger.

But, the moment someone posts a negative review of her, with NO 'personal revealing details' other than what is publically available in her own advertising, she runs to the mods yelling about her privacy and that she's in physical danger because of the review and it gets deleted.

Ok, I understand now.
 

jjinvan

New member
Apr 4, 2005
684
0
0
It's a so-so way. PM is not that much better. Rumours are spread that way, I would know having been the subject of many recently.

To combat that problem the inquirer should carefully consider what is being told to them. Information on SP and their service and nothing else. Anything more is BS until you hear, see, feel it from the SP themselves.
So.. anything we hear about an SP is BS unless we hear it from her herself, eh?

And of course, anything the SP says is always 100% true, of course.

Let me guess, you're on the no review list, right?
 

kehoe

I shoulda been a farmer
Apr 16, 2003
784
0
0
this whole "no review list" is bullshit. It doesn't help protect anyone, the only thing it does is prevent us from posting and seeing lousy reviews of marginal providers. The best local ladies are reviewed here regularly and they have no privacy problems that I've heard of. If the ladies are providing a good consistent service then this board will be the best form of advertising they could have and they will never have to worry about "fake" negative reviews. Also, by entering this business there is an accepted risk for all involved, pooners and providers alike. Pooners aren't forced to take part in this hobby and neither are the independent ladies and probably 99% of the agency, micro or mp girls. You have to be able to balanc the good with the bad.
 

jjinvan

New member
Apr 4, 2005
684
0
0
Interesting that they always trot out the 'fake reviews' angle..

Take a look on the review threads, some of the SPs who aren't on the 'no review list' have had bad reviews and some of those reviews have been complete BS (the guy who complained that Izzy was the height it states clearly on her website, but he 'thought she was taller' for example), look what happens.. A half dozen guys call bullshit on the twit (not twat, twit) and it is made clear to anyone reading the review that it's BS.

So, I guess the whole 'fake reviews' angle is kinda a red herring, eh?
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
Well I am of the opinion that the DNR list should be a sticky on the board. All the girls on the list are visible for all to see. Not their reasons for being non review-able. I for one am not interested in seeing any providers that are against reviewing. And I know that I am not alone in this. If the policy of this board is to hide this information that is a shame. I would think that with the new competition from emerging boards, that do not share the Vail of secrecy that seems to permeate this place, Perb would consider a change of policy concerning this issue. Of course Fred will do whatever he deems to be in the best interest of this board. And other boards will do what they consider to be in their best interests.
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
Integrity of the review board ? ...Unless the lady is a rip - off or scam artist then of course she can opt for no review. Boards provide the user with different ways of interacting with other members and ladies all for free, we never guarantee we will carry reviews of all the ladies out there. Learn to make the best use of what you have instead of asking what you cannot get.
And how are we to discern if the ladies are scam artists or a rip off if the policy of the board is to censor our information? Are you going to judge what is true and correct for me? We will all continue to make the best of the situation......never fear.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
jjinvan said:
The same girl posting fake positive reviews of herself in the reviews section doesn't put her in danger.
I was only speaking of those who take this business seriously and honourably.

jjinvan said:
So.. anything we hear about an SP is BS unless we hear it from her herself, eh?
For matters of a personal nature, yes.

jjinvan said:
And of course, anything the SP says is always 100% true, of course.
Again if it's of a personal nature, information that isn't divulged loosely, yes.

jjinvan said:
Let me guess, you're on the no review list, right?
You've been on PERB long enough to know how to use the search function. Here I'll help you out. No, I'm not on the DNR List.

jjinvan said:
But, the moment someone posts a negative review of her, with NO 'personal revealing details' other than what is publically available in her own advertising, she runs to the mods yelling about her privacy and that she's in physical danger because of the review and it gets deleted.
scubadude said:
This is where I have difficulty understanding the logic behind the policy.
You can't paint all SPs on the DNR list with the same brush. Sure when it comes to perception one bad apple ruins it for the bunch but we've evolved enough to know that and to take a risk. Risk can result in failure but success can't come without it.
 
Last edited:

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
this whole "no review list" is bullshit. It doesn't help protect anyone, the only thing it does is prevent us from posting and seeing lousy reviews of marginal providers. The best local ladies are reviewed here regularly and they have no privacy problems that I've heard of. If the ladies are providing a good consistent service then this board will be the best form of advertising they could have and they will never have to worry about "fake" negative reviews. Also, by entering this business there is an accepted risk for all involved, pooners and providers alike. Pooners aren't forced to take part in this hobby and neither are the independent ladies and probably 99% of the agency, micro or mp girls. You have to be able to balanc the good with the bad.
That's not necessarily true. For instance, SPs have been ragged on for being out of the average PERBERTs price range. So what would be the point in the SP advertising via review if the average review board contributor isn't the SPs target demographic?
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
So, let me get this straight:

A girl having a website with her phone number, photos with unblurred face, rates and services doesn't put her in danger.

The same girl putting an ad on perb in the SP section doesn't put her in danger.

The same girl posting fake positive reviews of herself in the reviews section doesn't put her in danger.

But, the moment someone posts a negative review of her, with NO 'personal revealing details' other than what is publically available in her own advertising, she runs to the mods yelling about her privacy and that she's in physical danger because of the review and it gets deleted.

Ok, I understand now.
This is where I have difficulty understanding the logic behind the policy.
 

athaire

Inactive Pooner
Aug 18, 2006
2,452
14
38
60
Land of the living skies
CLM as much as I enjoy your input on the boards on this topic I'm going to have to disagree with you. If a girl doesn't want to be reviewed I'm okay with that.......but It should be made public and that will give the Clients the choice to see her or not. I am not into Anyone deciding for me what is a good or not. And by hiding this list it ensures that I am not making informed decisions about where I spend the hard earned money that I do......
 

scubadude

New member
Sep 14, 2003
376
0
0
Lower Mainland
That's not necessarily true. For instance, SPs have been ragged on for being out of the average PERBERTs price range. So what would be the point in the SP advertising via review if the average review board contributor isn't the SPs target demographic?
I'm not sure that this is really the case. It seems to me that the overwhelming majority of the SPs receiving positive reviews are those in the average to above average donation rate. I really think that a scan of the board members seems to indicate members are prepared to part with $$.5 to $$$ relatively easily. Hence, a look at the advertisers shows the same trend.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
CLM as much as I enjoy your input on the boards on this topic I'm going to have to disagree with you. If a girl doesn't want to be reviewed I'm okay with that.......but It should be made public and that will give the Clients the choice to see her or not. I am not into Anyone deciding for me what is a good or not. And by hiding this list it ensures that I am not making informed decisions about where I spend the hard earned money that I do......
In case you missed it
Creole Lady Marmalade page 2 post#20 on this thread said:
The list should exist as requested from the SP out of respect not to be abused but should be posted publically.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Vancouver Escorts