New guideline - 1 review per provider, every 2 months

[Forum mod]

We have had a number of complaints about guys posting multiple reviews of the same provider, over and over, sometimes more than 1 per week.

This is being perceived as shilling at worst, unpaid promotion and spam have also been brought up.

Effective immediately, 1 review per provider from a pooner, every 2 months is all that will be allowed. We don't want to limit people, but some of these situations are out of control.

Thanks

 

[masterpoonhunter]

Are we allowed to provide a follow up review of our own review?
Example, I find a new SP, visit and want to share the experience.
2-3 wks later I visit again and the experience is either confirmed or has changed. Is a re-review allowed?
I agree that many are acting as pretty serious fanbois in their constant reviews (promotions) but I for one find the regular commentary very helpful.
Thanks!!

 

[ExpCharlee]

Are we allowed to provide a follow up review of our own review?
Example, I find a new SP, visit and want to share the experience.
2-3 wks later I visit again and the experience is either confirmed or has changed. Is a re-review allowed?
I agree that many are acting as pretty serious fanbois in their constant reviews (promotions) but I for one find the regular commentary very helpful.
Thanks!!

maybe a reply to the review that's already there?

 

[Forum mod]

It's fine if you are posting a review that's a major change from a previous review. If a rave review is followed by a disappointing one or vice versa. We don't need to hear 2 weeks after a glowing review that everything is still wonderful. So, no, a re-review in that case is not warranted.

 

[MissingOne]

I assume that replying to comments about one's review, including providing additional information and reiterating points already made, is OK?

 

[Forum mod]

I assume that replying to comments about one's review, including providing additional information and reiterating points already made, is OK?

Correct.

 

[Kikoolol]

Can we have one thread per provider with all reviews in that single thread?

 

[vanperb]

Can we have one thread per provider with all reviews in that single thread?

Asking a lot when posting in the right category / forum still seems to be a challenge.

 

[PuntMeister]

Can we have one thread per provider with all reviews in that single thread?

Or maybe a “Love-Sick Puppy” room where all the live sick puppies can post their litany of glowing reviews that we can ignore unless we need a chuckle.

 

[ExpCharlee]

Or maybe a “Love-Sick Puppy” room where all the live sick puppies can post their litany of glowing reviews that we can ignore unless we need a chuckle.

anyone who does this for me is required to pay me $50 per soppy review

 

[MixedDude]

Can we have one thread per provider with all reviews in that single thread?

Personally I find it harder to sift through threads when looking for specific info when this is done. I'm thinking of those endless Tiger review threads from back in the day.

 

[westwoody]

Can we have one thread per provider with all reviews in that single thread?

Some boards do this. Their mods tend to over edit the reviews and context gets lost.
Not really fair to sp’s who get pushed off front page either.
Perb system is better because it is more current.

 

[Forum mod]

Can we have one thread per provider with all reviews in that single thread?

No, this is impossible given the rules in place for necro posting and the need to keep things current. Some providers will go a full year or more between reviews.

 

[2bfair]

This is all so hard to follow which is right and which is wrong when posting your review of someone. I have yet to see a mod write a review example or two, so we have templates to follow.
ie. If you see an sp 4-7 weeks after you saw her the first time and she was .... ,.... you have to wait another one to 4 weeks to post your review it appears. 2 months between reviews I read. Sometimes the second visit is nothing like the first visit. Am I on or off track?

 

[Fiona]

This is all so hard to follow which is right and which is wrong when posting your review of someone. I have yet to see a mod write a review example or two, so we have templates to follow.
ie. If you see an sp 4-7 weeks after you saw her the first time and she was .... ,.... you have to wait another one to 4 weeks to post your review it appears. 2 months between reviews I read. Sometimes the second visit is nothing like the first visit. Am I on or off track?

If that was how it was it wouldn’t be a problem , but literally the same guys are reviewing their same girl every couple weeks . Pretty boring news .
I see tons of girls coming in & out of Victoria new & on tour and never new reviews , just the same dude reviewing the same girl as she’s asks him to , over & over 😑 zzzz

 

[Mike Nite]

Tomorrow I’m going to post a review of a fantastic duo gig that I had.

I followed up with a one on one booking with one of the girls. I’d like to review her separately. Is that allowable under these rules? Or can I add the second review somehow to the duo thread?

I just don’t want to run afoul of your guidelines.

 

[rainmon]

What if I see the girls 3-4 times in a month?

 

[Forum mod]

What if I see the girls 3-4 times in a month?

1 review every 2 months. Doesn't matter how much you see her. Couldn't be more clear. In fact, if you are seeing her that often, there's no way at all you can be or would be able to objectively discuss her services.

 

[Forum mod]

Tomorrow I’m going to post a review of a fantastic duo gig that I had.

I followed up with a one on one booking with one of the girls. I’d like to review her separately. Is that allowable under these rules? Or can I add the second review somehow to the duo thread?

I just don’t want to run afoul of your guidelines.

Sorry missed this one, I think a solo vs. duo review would be fine, but no more than that, within 2 months.

 

[angry anderson]

What if you cross the international date line?