Israel & Hezbollah

rollerboy

Teletubby Sport Hunter
Dec 5, 2004
903
0
0
San Francisco
sdw said:
I actually pasted a link to the source material in a prior post in this thread.

Inside the link there are further links to additional source material.

I post links rather than copying copywrited material because I really don't think that it's a big deal to go to the actual material.
Fair use was meant to protect relevant excerpting.

If I was Syria or Iran I would be monitoring Israel's Submarines and their Airforce. If a Submarine took off on a voyage, I would shadow it. If Israel loaded a F16 I would shoot it down as soon as it neared my border.
And Syria has been so successful in the past at interdicting Israeli F-16's and F-15's.

Hope springs eternal.

The source material is pretty definate on both yield and delivery system.
So, the Jericho II simply doesn't exist? In spite of the fact that modified variants carried Israeli satellites into orbit?

The FAS article you linked to was last updated 6 years ago. Even so, it refers to the existence of the Jericho and Jericho II missiles, and at the end cites Farr's article as a source. I don't know how you read the article, and its sources, and concluded that Israel's nuclear triad had a reach of 60-120 miles. This is a nation with demonstrated space launch capability.
Since 19 September 1988, Israel has worked on its own satellite recon- naissance system to decrease reliance on U.S. sources. On that day, they launched the Offeq-1 satellite on the Shavit booster, a system closely related to the Jericho-II missile. They launched the satellite to the west away from the Arabs and against the earth's rotation, requiring even more thrust. The Jericho-II missile is capable of sending a one ton nuclear payload 5,000 kilometers.
http://www.fas.org/nuke/guide/israel/missile/popeye-t.htm
In May 2000 Israel is reported to have secretly carried out its first test launches from two German-built Dolphin-class submarines of cruise missiles capable of carrying nuclear warheads. The missiles launched from vessels off Sri Lanka in the Indian Ocean are said to have hit a target at a range of about 1,500 kilometers [about 930 statute miles]. Israel is reported to possess a 200kg nuclear warhead, containing 6kg of plutonium, that could be mounted on cruise missiles.
 
Last edited:

sdw

New member
Jul 14, 2005
2,185
0
0
rollerboy said:
Fair use was meant to protect relevant excerpting.


And Syria has been so successful in the past at interdicting Israeli F-16's and F-15's.

Hope springs eternal.


So, the Jericho II simply doesn't exist? In spite of the fact that modified variants carried Israeli satellites into orbit?

The FAS article you linked to was last updated 6 years ago. Even so, it refers to the existence of the Jericho and Jericho II missiles, and at the end cites Farr's article as a source. I don't know how you read the article, and its sources, and concluded that Israel's nuclear triad had a reach of 60-120 miles.
googling Jericho II got me this piece:

http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/...

The Daily Times (Pakistan)
Tuesday, May 09, 2006

Israel will hit Iran in the next few
months: Israeli official

By Khalid Hasan

WASHINGTON: Israel will strike Iran's nuclear
facilities in the next "month or two or three," an
Israeli official has been quoted here as saying.

The unnamed official told Arnaud de Borchgrave,
editor-in-chief of the United Press International
(UPI), at the recently held national day reception
at the Israeli Embassy that he believed Israel would
strike Iran first in the next two or three months and
that fighter bombers would not be involved as they
had been to take out Iraq's Osirak nuclear reactor
before it went critical in 1981. For Osirak, Israel
had used 14 F-15s and F-16s. This time, the Israeli
said, it would be missiles.

Asked if Israel would employ Cruise missiles, he
replied, "with a gesture of his hand that went up
and down again", which meant that it would be
the weapon of choice.

Asked if tunnel entrances to widely scattered Iranian
nuclear facilities would be targeted, he responded
that Israel had its own geo-stationary spy-in-the-sky
satellite taking constant pictures of Iran with a
resolution down to 70 centimetres. "We know far
more than anyone realises," he added.

De Borchgrave's report quoted a poll of conservative
Republicans by a conservative web-based news service,
which showed overwhelmingly strong support for
bombing Iran. Almost 60,000 people took part in the
poll and 88 percent agreed that Iran poses a greater
threat than Saddam Hussein did before the Iraq War.
To the question, "Should the US undertake military
action against Iran to stop their (nuclear) programme?"
77 percent replied yes, 23 percent said no. Forty-five
percent said that military action should be taken by
the United States, while 35 percent wanted Israel to
do that. Twenty percent said neither. As for whether
US efforts to contain Iran's nuclear weapons are
working, 93 percent said they were not, while 89
percent said the US should not rely solely on the
UN.

According to de Borchgrave, "Israel has developed
some 100 Jericho-II medium-range ballistic missiles
(which entered service in 1989). Jericho II's range
varies from 1,500 to 3,500 kilometres, depending on
payload weight. They are deployed in underground
caves and silos. Israel has several satellites in orbit
- Ofeq-1 through Ofeq-5 - that were launched by
Shavit space launch vehicles (SLV). The first two
stages of the Shavit were Jericho II missiles. There
are unconfirmed reports of an upgraded Jericho-3
missile with a range of over 3,000 kilometres.


If Israel uses missiles to strike Iran, we are going to be looking at WWWIII.

The main players are already lined up. The US on Israel's side and China on Iran's side. China has already supplied silkworm missiles to Iran and the French and Germans have been supplying the equipment for Iran's nuclear program.
 

rollerboy

Teletubby Sport Hunter
Dec 5, 2004
903
0
0
San Francisco
sdw said:
If Israel uses missiles to strike Iran, we are going to be looking at WWWIII.

The main players are already lined up. The US on Israel's side and China on Iran's side. China has already supplied silkworm missiles to Iran and the French and Germans have been supplying the equipment for Iran's nuclear program.
If Iran thinks it can use its handful of new fission weapons against Israel, it courts annihilation. Israel wields a full nuclear triad with hundreds of warheads, including thermonuclear, overwhelming air superiority, satellite recon and AWACS, naval superiority, and missile defenses.

China hasn't sided with anybody. They've traded weapons technology with Israel for decades. The indigenous Chinese J-10 jet fighter derives from the IAI Lavi fighter design (itself based on the F-16) provided by Israel. In fact, the Israeli's jobbed us by sharing sensitive military secrets such as the Tactical High Energy Laser (THEL) with the Chinese. Silkworms are just anti-ship missiles, the French will sell the comparable Exocet to just about anybody who needs to sink a NATO vessel. China will not engage in nuclear suicide on Iran's behalf. Germany, as you pointed out, built several of the largest and most advanced conventional subs in the world for Israel.

Ultimately, nuclear war in the Middle East is practically inevitable. The Israelis gained nuclear capability thirty years, but refrained from using it. Once nuclear weapons proliferates throughout the Islamic world, with its history of instability and unrestrained violence, a nuclear attack on Israel becomes only a matter of time. Retaliation will be devastating and total.

I see no reason to extend the madness of the Middle East Conflict to the wider world. I'd feel sad for the millions dying (on both sides) for no sane purpose, but zero inclination to engage in mutual nuclear annihilation with Russia or China.
 
Last edited:

sdw

New member
Jul 14, 2005
2,185
0
0
rollerboy said:
If Iran thinks it can use its handful of new fission weapons against Israel, it courts annhilation. Israel has a full nuclear triad with hundreds of warheads, including thermonuclear, overwhelming air superiority, satellite recon and AWACS, naval superiority, and missile defenses.

China hasn't sided with anybody. They've traded weapons technology with Israel for decades. The indigenous Chinese J-10 jet fighter derives from the IAI Lavi fighter design (itself based on the F-16) provided by Israel. China is not going to engage in nuclear self-destruction on behalf of Iran. Germany, as you pointed out, built several of the largest and most advanced conventional subs in the world for Israel.
It seems to me that many nations engage in the arms trade for commercial profit only and don't adhear to any concept of morallity.

China, Germany and France seem to be quite unbiased on who they will provide technology to.

One of the reasons that I think that Israel doesn't deserve the support they get from the US and UK is that Israel is also unbiased about who they transfer technology to.

Israel traded technology with China as you pointed out, they have also traded technology with South Africa and others.

Israel has been caught a number of times spying on the US submarine program and also other programs. Israel also sank a US warship some years ago.

If an Arab nation had sunk that US warship, what do you think the US response would have been?

Today, we are watching the UK throw their airports into turmoil because they discovered a plot to blow up American, Continental and United flights.

Scotland Yard has arrested 21 and is looking for up to 50 more people.

People are not allowed to load with hand luggage and liquids and electronic devices including key fobs are not permitted on aircraft.

Obviously the Brits feel they have good information on the type of devices that were/are to be used. (depends on if the Brits succeed in thwarting the plot)

From what they are not allowing on aircraft, it would appear that the terrorists were planning on using peroxide http://www.jar2.com/cryptome.ru/1/H/bomb-sec-pto.htm which is easily made. Peroxide is widely used in Palistine and was the explosive of choice in the subway bombs. Another possible substance is nitroglycerine. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitroglycerine Nitroglycerine is fairly easy to produce and can be disquised as hair gel etc.

The reality is that the Brits, Israelis and Americans will use conventional weapons and tactics in a WWWIII. The Arab/Islamic world won't. They will use the tools at hand.

Conventional weapons and tactics are not working in Iraq. Israel is finding that they don't work against Hezbollah.

One of the problems we have is that we are busily accepting as refugees the very people we have given the greatest reasons to hate us.

The US, Canada and UK rescued 1000s of people from Lebanon. How many of those people had their homes destroyed, their businesses destroyed, their relatives killed? Most of them hold dual citizenship in Lebanon and the country that they were rescued by.

If my home was blown up, my business destroyed and my relatives killed; I would not be your friend.

From the press reports from the UK today, it appears that a number of the terrorists that were targeting US airliners are from Pakistan.

A year ago the UK had it's subway attacked, Spain also had it's trains attacked.

It seems to me, that we have to decide to be at peace with Islam or if we wish to continue to support Israel and blow up their property and people, we must not allow them into our countries.

Our opennes, laws and commercial instinct make us easy to attack.

The people that we are attacking don't have to declare war on us as a nation. Their nations can continue to deny knowledge and complicity even as they direct their attacks against us.

The Americans, Brits and Israel are shadow boxing with an opponent who doesn't have to declare a nationality, nation or open war.

After Vietnam, Iraq and now Lebanon; it should be obvious that it is not possible to win a military victory against a shadow opponent.
 
Last edited:

rollerboy

Teletubby Sport Hunter
Dec 5, 2004
903
0
0
San Francisco
sdw said:
It seems to me that many nations engage in the arms trade for commercial profit only and don't adhear to any concept of morallity.
Hard to argue that there's much morality to be found in the arms trade. Small arms account for millions of deaths each decade, far more than glamorous death machines like jet fighters.
One of the reasons that I think that Israel doesn't deserve the support they get from the US and UK is that Israel is also unbiased about who they transfer technology to.
The DoD concluded in a report that Israel spies on us more than any other ally. We get stuff back from them, though. For instance we gained a lot of intelligence about Soviet weapons, captured by the Israelis during the '67 and '73 wars.
Israel traded technology with China as you pointed out, they have also traded technology with South Africa and others.
Missile technology with South Africa and India. Plus, I believe they worked on the advanced avionics in the SU30MKI.

I'm sure they will try to sell/trade our stealth fighter technology, which is why their participation in the F-35 program has been partially restricted.

If an Arab nation had sunk that US warship, what do you think the US response would have been?
Are you referring to the USS Liberty? That incident occurred during the Six Day War in '67, and was ruled an accident. The USS Stark was severely damaged by accidental fire from an Iraqi Mirage during the Iran-Iraq War, under circumstances resembling the Liberty incident.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Liberty_incident http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Stark_(FFG-31)

I dunno, what would the response have been if 19 of the 911 hijackers had been Israelis. We clearly have a permissive attitude toward some of our "allies."
The reality is that the Brits, Israelis and Americans will use conventional weapons and tactics in a WWWIII. The Arab/Islamic world won't. They will use the tools at hand.

Conventional weapons and tactics are not working in Iraq. Israel is finding that they don't work against Hezbollah.
I'd assert that it's more a failure of politically sensitive warfare, rather than conventional weapons and tactics alone. We oversold ourselves on the fantasy of surgical warfare. Conventional war can be utterly devastating: Europe was levelled by it, twice.

Don't go to war if you are unwilling or unable to kill very large numbers of innocent people. If the Nazis could have protected themselves by hiding amongst the civilians, they certainly would have.
 
Last edited:

sdw

New member
Jul 14, 2005
2,185
0
0
rollerboy said:
The USS Cole was basically crippled by Al Qeda operating from Yemen.
I believe that Clinton launched cruise missile attacks against known al Queda bases. I think they specifically targetted bin Laden. In the 911 committee report it is clear that the Clinton administration warned the Bush administration about the activities of al Queda.
 

rollerboy

Teletubby Sport Hunter
Dec 5, 2004
903
0
0
San Francisco
sdw said:
One of the problems we have is that we are busily accepting as refugees the very people we have given the greatest reasons to hate us.

The US, Canada and UK rescued 1000s of people from Lebanon. How many of those people had their homes destroyed, their businesses destroyed, their relatives killed? Most of them hold dual citizenship in Lebanon and the country that they were rescued by.
The Lebanese I know are loyal Americans.

We killed many millions of Germans and Japanese during WWII. That didn't make Germans and Japanese bad candidates for immigration.

It seems to me, that we have to decide to be at peace with Islam or if we wish to continue to support Israel and blow up their property and people, we must not allow them into our countries.
Hey, Islam, we've decided to be at peace with you!

Peace with Islamic militants means you cave in to every one of their demands until they are satisfied, for the moment. However, now that you have established that you are weak and a coward, and shown that violence against you will win great concessions, you will reap a reward of endless extortion. Osama bin Laden's interview regarding America's withdrawal from Somalia is particularly illuminating on this point.

The people that we are attacking don't have to declare war on us as a nation. Their nations can continue to deny knowledge and complicity even as they direct their attacks against us.

The Americans, Brits and Israel are shadow boxing with an opponent who doesn't have to declare a nationality, nation or open war.

After Vietnam, Iraq and now Lebanon; it should be obvious that it is not possible to win a military victory against a shadow opponent.
It's not like we woke up one day and decided to invent Islamic radicals. Islamic radicals came at us, and they will keep coming, until their power bases in Syria and Iran are destroyed. The Saudi's must stop bankrolling terrorism, and spreading anti-Western hatred through the mosques and madrassas they sponsor throughout the world.

Hafez Assad crushed the Muslim Brotherhood in Syria. Saddam similarly tightly controlled religious activities in Iraq. The Saudis keep their clerics on a short leash when it comes to internal politics, although any venom may be spewed against America and Israel. Attaturk saw the radical Islamists in his day as the main obstacle to establishing modern Turkey. Successfully banishing them from public life allowed him to succeed in building a strong, secular Turkish state.

Terrorists are not invincible. Indeed, if they were, civilization would be a lost cause. Any disaffected segment of society would need only resort to terrorism to achieve its objectives. This would then lead to poverty, anarchy, and lawlessness or despotism.

Israelis wrongly believed that by withdrawing from Southern Lebanon six years ago, they could secure peace. And yet the stockpile of rockets arrayed against them across the border grew dramatically in size and capability. The only concession they can make, which will appease their enemies, is to die.
 
Last edited:

dirtydan

Banned
Oct 7, 2004
1,059
0
0
59
sdw said:
The Israeli nuclear weapons program was provided by France beginning in 1956.

http://www.fas.org/nuke/guide/israel/nuke/

Israel has three German made submarines that have the ability to fire Nuclear single warhead missiles with a range of 60 to 120 miles. The same missile can be truck mounted or fired from a F16. The warhead yield is thought to be 20 megatons
20 megatons? I might believe 20 kilotons but not 20 megatons. Your information must be very faulty. In fact most nuclear warheads are well under 20 megatons as the accuracy of ballistic missiles and cruise missiles has greatly improved.

I do believe the Israelis were experimenting with arming a sub-launched Harpoon missile with a small nuclear warhead. I don't know if they went ahead with the program. I've never heard of a Harpoon launched from a land based vehicle, but there could very well be such a variant. The IDF I think still might use the old Lance battlefield missile than can be armed with a small nuclear warhead. The Israelis also developed their Jericho series of ballistic missiles, of which the latest could be in the IRBM catagory, which would match or perhaps exceed the longest reaching missiles used by some Arab countries.
 
Last edited:

dirtydan

Banned
Oct 7, 2004
1,059
0
0
59
sdw said:
It seems to me that many nations engage in the arms trade for commercial profit only and don't adhear to any concept of morallity.
Very true and including Canada. When the Turks were taking their frustrations out on the Kurds the Turkish air force used some of the old CF-104 Starfighters they bought from Canada during the mid 1980's. But that's minor compared to the Brazilians and the Chinese, both of whom sold weapons to Iraq and Iran during that 8 year war.

sdw said:
China, Germany and France seem to be quite unbiased on who they will provide technology to.
The Chinese will sell to almost anybody. The Germans and French have been somewhat selective when it depends on the weapons system another country wants to buy. A fair bit of Germany weapon systems used by other countries was bought second hand from countries who bought from the German several years ago. But with the end of the Cold War, countries looking for arms sales are more willing to sell with the world not as divided into blocs.

sdw said:
One of the reasons that I think that Israel doesn't deserve the support they get from the US and UK is that Israel is also unbiased about who they transfer technology to.

Israel traded technology with China as you pointed out, they have also traded technology with South Africa and others.
That's old news. Hell the Israelis did business with Iran, that is when the Shah was still in power.

sdw said:
Israel has been caught a number of times spying on the US submarine program and also other programs. Israel also sank a US warship some years ago.
You must be referring to the USS Liberty, which was a ELINT spy ship used by the USN. During the time of the Six Day War the Liberty was in Med and the Israeli air force attacked it, despite the large US flags that were painted on port and starboard sides of the ship's upper works. Some may still spin the bullshit that the attack was an accident. It wasn't. It was deliberate and carried the political message as well that Israel would bite the hand that fed it if they felt there was a need to do so.

sdw said:
If an Arab nation had sunk that US warship, what do you think the US response would have been?


Gees the Gulf of Tonkin comes to mind. I wonder why?

sdw said:
Today, we are watching the UK throw their airports into turmoil because they discovered a plot to blow up American, Continental and United flights.

Scotland Yard has arrested 21 and is looking for up to 50 more people.

People are not allowed to load with hand luggage and liquids and electronic devices including key fobs are not permitted on aircraft.

Obviously the Brits feel they have good information on the type of devices that were/are to be used. (depends on if the Brits succeed in thwarting the plot)

From what they are not allowing on aircraft, it would appear that the terrorists were planning on using nitroglycerine. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitroglycerine Nitroglycerine is fairly easy to produce and can be disquised as hair gel etc.
I don't doubt for a moment there was some kind of bomb plot. However when I see such mass arrests I begin to wonder if the respective police force is going overboard.


sdw said:
The reality is that the Brits, Israelis and Americans will use conventional weapons and tactics in a WWWIII. The Arab/Islamic world won't. They will use the tools at hand.
WW3 being what exactly?


sdw said:
Conventional weapons and tactics are not working in Iraq. Israel is finding that they don't work against Hezbollah.

One of the problems we have is that we are busily accepting as refugees the very people we have given the greatest reasons to hate us.

The US, Canada and UK rescued 1000s of people from Lebanon. How many of those people had their homes destroyed, their businesses destroyed, their relatives killed? Most of them hold dual citizenship in Lebanon and the country that they were rescued by.
There are a great many Lebanese that have dual citizenship when it comes to Canada, as we took in a lot of refugees during the Lebanese Civil War. Some when back to Lebanon to live, others go back to visit family and friends.


sdw said:
If my home was blown up, my business destroyed and my relatives killed; I would not be your friend.

From the press reports from the UK today, it appears that a number of the terrorists that were targeting US airliners are from Pakistan.
Say Pakistan is an ally of the US. And the Pakistan military has weapons of mass destruction including nuclear weapons.

sdw said:
A year ago the UK had it's subway attacked, Spain also had it's trains attacked.
With the tighter security at airports other transportation terminals become targets. The premise being not everything can be so greatly defended.

sdw said:
It seems to me, that we have to decide to be at peace with Islam or if we wish to continue to support Israel and blow up their property and people, we must not allow them into our countries.
Canada's policy in regards to Israel and Lebanon should be calling for a cease fire and not blabbing about Israel's measured response.

sdw said:
Our opennes, laws and commercial instinct make us easy to attack.
Fearmongering?

sdw said:
The people that we are attacking don't have to declare war on us as a nation. Their nations can continue to deny knowledge and complicity even as they direct their attacks against us.
We are attacking? Please clarify.


sdw said:
The Americans, Brits and Israel are shadow boxing with an opponent who doesn't have to declare a nationality, nation or open war.

After Vietnam, Iraq and now Lebanon; it should be obvious that it is not possible to win a military victory against a shadow opponent.
The toughest war to win is the one against a popular idea. Be it Vietnamese nationalism, or throwing off the shackles of Western influence in the ME.
 

BcMod

SEMI RETIRED FROM PERB
Jul 7, 2006
269
8
18
I am keeping an eye on this thread. Mostly a good discussion, with different view points. I have deleted several posts referring to the wish for mass murder - I won't let this turn into our own little war.

Different views are welcome, when respectfully stated and are not outrageous.
 

metoo113

Member
Aug 2, 2002
407
0
16
Somewhere Down The Crazy River
The Chinese will sell to almost anybody. The Germans and French have been somewhat selective when it depends on the weapons system another country wants to buy. A fair bit of Germany weapon systems used by other countries was bought second hand from countries who bought from the German several years ago. But with the end of the Cold War, countries looking for arms sales are more willing to sell with the world not as divided into blocs.
And who is the worlds largest arms dealer. It's the good old US of A.

http://www.globalissues.org/Geopolitics/ArmsTrade/BigBusiness.asp#ArmsSalesBySupplierNations
 

gotsome2004

Bun wrapped wiener
Oct 15, 2004
452
0
0
Montreal
Noam Chomsky!

Nothing like reading Noam Chomsky to cut through the bullshit.
Found this online:
http://www.chomsky.info/interviews/20060807.htm

On Israel, Lebanon and Palestine

Noam Chomsky interviewed by Kaveh Afrasiabi

Middle East Online, August 7, 2006

Do you agree with the argument that Israel's military offensive in Lebanon is "legally and morally justified?"
Noam Chomsky: The invasion itself is a serious breach of international law, and major war crimes are being committed as it proceeds. There is no legal justification.

The "moral justification" is supposed to be that capturing soldiers in a cross-border raid, and killing others, is an outrageous crime. We know, for certain, that Israel, the United States and other Western governments, as well as the mainstream of articulate Western opinion, do not believe a word of that. Sufficient evidence is their tolerance for many years of US-backed Israeli crimes in Lebanon, including four invasions before this one, occupation in violation of Security Council orders for 22 years, and regular killings and abductions. To mention just one question that every journal should be answering: When did Nasrallah assume a leadership role? Answer: When the Rabin government escalated its crimes in Lebanon, murdering Sheikh Abbas Mussawi and his wife and child with missiles fired from a US helicopter. Nasrallah was chosen as his successor. Only one of innumerable cases. There is, after all, a good reason why last February, 70% of Lebanese called for the capture of Israeli soldiers for prisoner exchange.

The conclusion is underscored, dramatically, by the current upsurge of violence, which began after the capture of Corporal Gilad Shalit on June 25. Every published Western "timeline" takes that as the opening event. Yet the day before, Israeli forces kidnapped two Gaza civilians, a doctor and his brother, and sent them to the Israeli prison system where they can join innumerable other Palestinians, many held without charges -- hence kidnapped. Kidnapping of civilians is a far worse crime than capture of soldiers. The Western response was quite revealing: a few casual comments, otherwise silence. The major media did not even bother reporting it. That fact alone demonstrates, with brutal clarity, that there is no moral justification for the sharp escalation of attacks in Gaza or the destruction of Lebanon, and that the Western show of outrage about kidnapping is cynical fraud.

Much has been said about Israel's right to defend itself from its enemies who are taking advantage of Israel's withdrawal from Gaza, thus causing the latest chapter in the Arab-Israeli conflict. Do you agree?

NC: Israel certainly has a right to defend itself, but no state has the right to "defend" occupied territories. When the World Court condemned Israel's "separation wall," even a US Justice, Judge Buergenthal, declared that any part of it built to defend Israeli settlements is "ipso facto in violation of international humanitarian law," because the settlements themselves are illegal.

The withdrawal of a few thousand illegal settlers from Gaza was publicly announced as a West Bank expansion plan. It has now been formalized by Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, with the support of Washington, as a program of annexation of valuable occupied lands and major resources (particularly water) and cantonization of the remaining territories, virtually separated from one another and from whatever pitiful piece of Jerusalem will be granted to Palestinians. All are to be imprisoned, since Israel is to take over the Jordan valley. Gaza, too, remains imprisoned and Israel carries out attacks there at will.

Gaza and the West Bank are recognized to be a unit, by the United States and Israel as well. Therefore, Israel still occupies Gaza, and cannot claim self-defense in territories it occupies in either of the two parts of Palestine. It is Israel and the United States that are radically violating international law. They are now seeking to consummate long-standing plans to eliminate Palestinian national rights for good.

The United States has refused to call for an immediate cease-fire, arguing that this would mean a return to the status quo ante, yet we are witnessing a "back to the past" re-occupation of parts of Lebanon, and Lebanon's rapid decline to political chaos by the current conflict. Is the US policy correct?

NC: It is correct from the point of view of those who want to ensure that Israel, by now virtually an offshore US military base and high-tech center, dominates the region, without any challenge to its rule as it proceeds to destroy Palestine. And there are side advantages, such as eliminating any Lebanese-based deterrent if US-Israel decide to attack Iran.

They may also hope to set up a client regime in Lebanon of the kind that Ariel Sharon sought to create when he invaded Lebanon in 1982, destroying much of the country and killing some 15-20,000 people.

What will be the likely outcome of this "two-pronged" crisis in Lebanon and the occupied territories, in the near and long-term?

NC: We cannot predict much. There are too many uncertainties. One very likely consequence, as the United States and Israel surely anticipated, is a significant increase in jihadi-style terrorism as anger and hatred directed against the United States, Israel, and Britain sweep the Arab and Muslim worlds. Another is that Nasrallah, whether he survives or is killed, will become an even more important symbol of resistance to US-Israeli aggression. Hezbollah already has a phenomenal 87% support in Lebanon itself, and its resistance has energized popular opinion to such an extent that even the oldest and closest US allies have been compelled to say that "If the peace option is rejected due to the Israeli arrogance, then only the war option remains, and no one knows the repercussions befalling the region, including wars and conflict that will spare no one, including those whose military power is now tempting them to play with fire." That's from King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia, who knows better than to condemn the United States directly.

What steps do you recommend for the current hostilities to be brought to an end and a lasting peace established?

NC: The basic steps are well understood: a cease-fire and exchange of prisoners; withdrawal of occupying forces; continuation of the "national dialogue" within Lebanon; and acceptance of the very broad international consensus on a two-state settlement for Israel-Palestine, which has been unilaterally blocked by the United States and Israel for thirty years. There is, as always, much more to say, but those are the essentials.
 

westwoody

Well-known member
Jun 10, 2004
7,877
7,835
113
Westwood
America does it so it's okay

Perhaps Hezbollah is learning from Rumsfeld and will build their own Guantanamo and fill it with Israeli detainees.
 

sdw

New member
Jul 14, 2005
2,185
0
0
The UN passed the motion to stop the Israeli/Hezbollah fight today.

That won't stop Israel from continueing to kill people for a few more days.

Israel struck a convoy organized by the UN and Lebanese army today. There were 600 - 1500 (depends on media report) civilian cars that thought being escorted by the UN and Lebanonese army would keep them safe.
 

dirtydan

Banned
Oct 7, 2004
1,059
0
0
59
sparkymacker said:
Oh my, if only we had sold the Turks our Sea Kings...the Kurds would have definately won!



And the Shah has been dead how long? More old news?



Ok, this is going to be a bit tougher.....let me guess...the gun boats were actually piloted by Israeli navy commandos



Exactly Dan, especially when we all realize that 9-11 was due to a clerical error.



Hmmm...I think this is a trick question....World War Three?



And I have noticed on the news some when back to Montreal to protest, wave Hezbollah flags and pictures of Hassan Nasrallah.



Ok, "Pakistan is an ally of the US" (not as tough as I thought it was going to be)



Ah yes....so when you are getting your next Chai Tea at Starbucks...be vigilant Dan!



Yes and while the world is waiting breathlessly for us to demand a ceasfire, let's go all the way and demand world peace...now...or else...we are not kidding around here!!



Is that anything like fear mongering?



at·tack (ə-tăk')

v., -tacked, -tack·ing, -tacks.

v.tr.
To set upon with violent force.
To criticize strongly or in a hostile manner.
To start work on with purpose and vigor: attack a problem.



Well I am certainly no expert like you Dan, but I am pretty sure a war against an unpopular idea is not all that easy either. Be it the Nazi invasion of Poland or flying an airplane into an office building.

Very incoherent. :rolleyes:
 

Rod Steel

Incredible Member
Dec 11, 2005
389
0
0
www.auntjemima.com
sparkymacker said:
Oh my, if only we had sold the Turks our Sea Kings...the Kurds would have definately won!



And the Shah has been dead how long? More old news?



Ok, this is going to be a bit tougher.....let me guess...the gun boats were actually piloted by Israeli navy commandos



Exactly Dan, especially when we all realize that 9-11 was due to a clerical error.



Hmmm...I think this is a trick question....World War Three?



And I have noticed on the news some when back to Montreal to protest, wave Hezbollah flags and pictures of Hassan Nasrallah.



Ok, "Pakistan is an ally of the US" (not as tough as I thought it was going to be)



Ah yes....so when you are getting your next Chai Tea at Starbucks...be vigilant Dan!



Yes and while the world is waiting breathlessly for us to demand a ceasfire, let's go all the way and demand world peace...now...or else...we are not kidding around here!!



Is that anything like fear mongering?



at·tack (ə-tăk')

v., -tacked, -tack·ing, -tacks.

v.tr.
To set upon with violent force.
To criticize strongly or in a hostile manner.
To start work on with purpose and vigor: attack a problem.



Well I am certainly no expert like you Dan, but I am pretty sure a war against an unpopular idea is not all that easy either. Be it the Nazi invasion of Poland or flying an airplane into an office building.
Seems clear to me.
 

Randy Whorewald

Orgasm donor
Sep 20, 2005
3,319
0
0
Greek Islands
www.randydyck.com
Well, with the cease fire about to be implemented, Hezbollah, Iran and Syria must be just laughing right now. They managed to kill a lot of Israelis, make Israel look bad and all it cost them was a few bucks and over 1000 Lebanese lives. They (Hezollah) will still be in Lebanon (although a large UN force will also be there). They will still be armed and in a position to stir up more shit in the not too distant future.
 

uncleg

Well-known member
Jul 25, 2006
5,645
828
113
Interesting points of view from all, but what is the real reason for the mess in the Middle East, in particular in allowing Israel a free hand ? If the "West" wasn't still feeling guilty about WW2 and what happened to the Jews, there would be no Israel, and no problem in the Middle East. You can't take a bunch of European Jews, place them in the Levant and take land away from the locals and expect peace. What we forget in North America, is that there are feuds in that part of the world, and even in Europe, that have been going on longer then there has been an America or Canada. This is not going to go away. It's like herpes, it'll keep flairing up.
 
Vancouver Escorts