Carman Fox

If you are using the word "seen" you are most likely using the wrong word.

johnnydepth

Average Sized Member
Nov 14, 2015
1,644
452
83
winnipeg
When did it become common place to use the word "seen" instead of the grammatically correct "saw"?
From a semantic point of view "seen" is fine because it still makes sense, but grammatically it is just wrong.
Have you seen XXXX? makes sense.
Did you seen XXXX? wrong.
I seen XXXX last week. wrong.
I seen XXXX many times. wrong.

My thought for the day.
 

penguy

Active member
Feb 8, 2010
341
125
43
how about instead of...

I seen XXXX many times.

I've seen XXXX many times.
 

JimDandy

Well-known member
May 17, 2004
3,073
649
113
68
Lower Mainland, B.C.
Many years ago I briefly dated a woman that had emigrated from the UK. She was always correcting me on exactly what op posted. I hope the lesson stuck in my case though, if I'm being honest, I'm not sure I would be aware if I started using the word seen incorrectly again.

JD
 

uncleg

Well-known member
Jul 25, 2006
5,653
829
113
While we’re on the topic of grammar and dictation how about the sound of some words and their meanings, for instance the word “dictator”, sounds like some kind of penis shaped potato patty’s. — — Sally quit playing with your food and swallow your dictators
You mean like this...?????


 

Jon Snow

New member
Jul 3, 2018
10
0
0
+ 1

With an odd sense of overwhelming relief that this drives someone else nuts too.
 

nwtl

daffodil fairy
Aug 24, 2016
412
131
43
When did it become common place to use the word "seen" instead of the grammatically correct "saw"?
From a semantic point of view "seen" is fine because it still makes sense, but grammatically it is just wrong.
Have you seen XXXX? makes sense.
Did you seen XXXX? wrong.
I seen XXXX last week. wrong.
I seen XXXX many times. wrong.

My thought for the day.
I never seen anyone use seen that way :p
 

Vpete

Active member
Oct 29, 2017
106
49
28
I seen this grammatical error a lot lately in the various forums. I also notice a lack of proper paragraph use too as well
as commas. However the use of prepositional phrases remains the single greatest offence on Perb.

Do wordz better!!!
 

Ms Erica Phoenix

Satisfaction Provider
Jun 24, 2013
5,319
6
0
59
In Your Wildest Dreams!
I seen this grammatical error a lot lately in the various forums. I also notice a lack of proper paragraph use too as well
as commas. However the use of prepositional phrases remains the single greatest offence on Perb.

Do wordz better!!!
Now you're just tormenting the masochist in me that knows how this thread will cause ne pain, but I can't stop reading it!!!
 

nightswhisper

Member
Feb 20, 2016
784
8
18
I used to believe that speaking properly was imperative. I made it a goal to use proper verb moods, eliminate passive voicing, and speak eloquently.

Then I realized one very important matter - Language is used to disseminate information. The least number of words used to communicate the most amount of information is the most effective.

The English language used to be vastly more complex. However, due to colonisation and the subsequent Anglicisation of various British colonial properties, English began to simplify. It simplified because people from diverse backgrounds and origins needed a common way to communicate. Verb moods and tenses like dative, subjunctive and genetive began to die off. Now, we have a simple language that can be understood and spoken by a third of the world, and that is more important than holding on to arbitrary rules and traditions. Comparatively, Finnish ,Swedish and Norwegian are so frustratingly difficult because they've never really been used widely as colonial languages. Other colonial languages like French, Spanish, and Chinese have all seen simplification.

So, if we start using "Seen" without the present perfect helper "have", and it indicates something that happened in the past (and the person listening to this understands it) then it's one abbreviated word with the same meaning conveyed.
 
Last edited:

Quarter Mile'r

Injected and Blown
May 17, 2005
3,597
134
63
Out of Town
Like as in "taught" this word alone is in the past tense even though it is used in the present.
English is such a confusing language when analyzed. LOL!

So you can say I was taught a good lesson today. Or, you will be taught in a manner
you have never experienced before. Both pre and past tense.

So with all that bullshit aside I like to say what nightswhisper posted above is that
we have been "teached" a good lesson for the day. :lol:





.......................QM'r
 
Vancouver Escorts