Globe and Mail Prostitution Editorial

Avery

Gentleman Horndog
Jul 7, 2003
4,770
22
38
Winnipeg
They seem to get it. This was in yesterday's edition:

The prostitution knot

From Monday's Globe and Mail

Opposition members of a federal justice subcommittee on solicitation laws have it right. The full force of the law should descend upon those guilty of acts of exploitation, violence or trafficking involving prostitutes, instead of "criminalizing consenting adults who engage in sexual activities for money." It is a shame that Conservative MPs on the subcommittee resisted reforms to prostitution laws that might have resulted from the majority's lucid analysis.

Instead, the political fight will only ensure that Canada will endure a perpetuation of laws that the report shows create a "two-tier sex trade," where the better-off majority -- escorts -- operate with relative impunity, while a much smaller number of street prostitutes are subject to 90 per cent of all prostitution-related incidents involving police. The street prostitutes are already the more vulnerable and marginalized group, and their situation is only worsened by police activities which encourage a dangerous, furtive lifestyle, compounding their risk.

If the Conservative MPs are sincere when they declare that "all prostitution has a social cost," they should be prepared to acknowledge the significant contribution to that cost made by the country's laws, laws which the report says "marginalize prostitutes, often leaving themisolated and afraid to report abuse and violence to law enforcement authorities." If they need evidence of the enormouspotential human cost of such vulnera-bility, they need look no further than the fact that street prostitution persists, and does so in the face of a great deal of violence directed at prostitutes, including dozens of killings or disappearances in Canada.

The Criminal Code bans solicitation, forcing prostitutes to cut hasty deals with clients before climbing into their cars. Its outdated bawdy-house laws make it difficult for prostitutes to organize their own businesses. It results in police raids on massage parlours, sometimes in cases where such businesses have operated without complaint or even the awareness of nearby businesses. Prostitution itself is a legal activity in Canada, and consenting adults should be able to engage in it without harassment.

Certainly this is a complex issue. Police crackdowns on street prostitution are motivated in part by legitimate concerns about the impact of such activities on communities. Nobody can pretend that allowing prostitutes to ply their trade on residential streets, or even brazenly in business districts, is in any way desirable. The report argues that existing nuisance, public-disturbance and loitering laws are sufficient for the purpose, and that those rules when enforced would not stigmatize prostitutes in the same way.

The challenge, were the government enlightened enough to pursue the subcommittee majority's recommendations, would be to find a way to balance the safety of prostitutes with the safety and harmony of communities. It could not be a worse result than the status quo.
 
Vancouver Escorts