Dear anonanon,
Gift-giving in this business can be a complicated issue. Depending on the stage of your "relationship" with the SP, she may perceive your generosity as overly familiar and perhaps crossing some comfort-level boundary. Of course, she will never tell you that. Other SPs really do enjoy a thoughtful gift, which is perfectly natural. Who doesn't like gifts?
But I ask you, what is your motivation for this? If it is for any other reason than being genuinely friendly I suggest you reconsider. Most SPs are clever enough to spot attempts to curry favour or buy a girlfriend.
Anyway, if you want to bring a gift that is not cliched and pedestrian, my recommendation is the same for any woman, SP, SO, GF, whatever: buy something specific to her! That's really the best approach.
For a first time gift it can be difficult to avoid the standards. And keep in mind that some women (like some men) truly do enjoy chocolate, wine, etc. so just because it is common doesn't mean it is a poor choice. But once you know a woman's particular tastes, keeping going with the chocolate displays a real lack of imagination. There is no one optimal gift; any of music (live or recorded), books, clothes (and not just lingerie) works just fine. Be open-minded, my friend. Your only limits are your wallet and your imagination. I would avoid gift certificates unless she has expressed a strong interest in a particular store and her home is replete with their stuff.
I've seen more than a few SP websites indicate what category of gifts they like, and occasionally even specifics relating to brand, style, etc. The first part is fine but that last part really deflates my interest and I can't help but be cynical about its true purpose.
What I've done in the past, especially for my first session with a given SP, is to offer to bring something that seems to correspond with her tastes - e.g. a particular food, wine, etc. It demonstrates that you are considerate while still being appropriate. And she has the option to decline your offer without embarrassment. For me it makes sense since my work schedule only permits breakfast or dinner times.
I've given gifts at special occasions such as holidays, birthdays, etc. for a few select few SPs. These gifts have always been graciously accepted, or so I assume. I warn you, though, not to expect reciprocity on the SP's part. It's nice when it happens but it is relatively rare. She can't buy every client a gift or even a card and it is a waste of her time to do so. Are you going to stop seeing her if you don't get a card at Christmas?
Happy shopping!
VF