In short, no.
The US is use to having it's own way and if others don't like it; it does not bother many Americas much. What is the worst that can happen to us, others won't like us? Just a minute they don't anyway.
US only respects those that are New York in your face type of people.
Canada is more like the battered wife. They complain about the way they are treated, but they keep coming back for more.
I am always amazed at the bargaining strength Canada has and how little they use their strength. Instead they approach the US the way one would approach another Canadian. What is fair for everyone? What is the win win resolution?
If I was negotiating for Canada, I would approach it very differently.
- I would immediately raise the price of electrical power being exported to the US. I know there are power contracts in place that fix the price, but screw you. Pay my price or I will cut you off. Let's watch the New England States go dark as the Canadian power is shut off.
The lumber. I would say we are no longer exporting logs. Hardwood softwood I don't give a shit. Take dimensional lumber, or don't take anything. The US housing boom is driving the entire US economy. No one will screw with an interruption of the supply of wood. 90% of the house are constructed with fir or hemlock. Where do you think that wood comes from?
Natural gas. Canada has huge reserves of natural gas. US needs that natural gas.
Water. The US needs large amounts of potable water. Canada has huge surplus of water. So think like the drug dealers. Supply water for free for a short time. Once everyone is addicted to the water imports then slap huge increases on the cost of water.
But that is just me talking. A know nothing American. Canada needs to be liked and by giving in (like the battered wife) you think you will have peace and we will all just get along.