Are you a member of the Erotic Review and did you pay to use it?

[Chessmen]

I'm interested in some of the reviews on there but it is private and you have to buy membership or contribute quality reviews to get access.
Is it worth it, for the ones who use it?

 

[badbadboy]

Some of the reviews are a little graphic but that's what they expect .

The best thing is they organize the information much better than on other forums. Easier to search and track and cross-reference.

I was a member there for years. Their mods/admin will not publish a review unless it fits their Penthouse forum format. I got tired of 3 or 4 demands for re-writes to satisfy their policies.

Stating BBBJ and CIM will get a possible 8 or higher for the SP. Stating CBJ is typically a 6 or 7.

The reason I mention this is because some providers don't want it broadcast about CIM since it may be a YMMV scenario; you could possibly find that provider may not see you again.

Also there has been a high incidence of Fake reviews on many providers across Canada. Someone back east also used their platform for "getting back" at some providers too. Their credibility has taken a beating and many providers prefer not to be reviewed there anymore.

I agree about the format being universal. It does help with searching.

 

[burcs]

The site is set up nicely. But the way it's run and the content is no better (and often worse) than perb.

That being said it's probably still the best single resource for travellers.

 

[BORKO]

I was a member there but never paid, just contributed reviews, I think I put about 18 there.

It seems fine if you want the graphic details like other say.

 

[hankmoody]

I was a member there for years. Their mods/admin will not publish a review unless it fits their Penthouse forum format. I got tired of 3 or 4 demands for re-writes to satisfy their policies.

Seriously?
They actually made you rewrite them raunchier?
That's effed up.

 

[lenny]

Never paid there & probably never will, though i'd pay to use PERB & have paid at ISG.

 

[BORKO]

Seriously?
They actually made you rewrite them raunchier?
That's effed up.

Well they have little drop down boxes to fill in if the lady spits/swallows or does anal etc...

 

[sevenofnine]

yes I did but that was a few years ago, I think I paid one year out of three or something, I never saw enough new ladies, to write reviews, no point when you only see one lady,

um, I found a few years ago, that most sp's have an in with a mod or the owner of a sight. they could pretty much delete anything they didn't like said about them.
so I liked the honesty of the erotic review. as far as I know ladies couldn't have anything deleted once it passed. no so on other sights, not sure about this one,

and I like the details, like cim and if she swallows, etc etc,
that is what I look for if and when I see a new sp. anything goes. or as much as possible anyway,

 

[CrazedandAbused]

It's pricey but you get way more info on the girls and the reviews are better than here.

They also list a ton of girls who never show up on perb

Especially good if you poon in multiple cities.

 

[bdan]

It's pricey but you get way more info on the girls and the reviews are better than here.

They also list a ton of girls who never show up on perb

Especially good if you poon in multiple cities.

I disagree the reviews are better. More graphic for sure but better? No.

I found there demand for graphic content distasteful. Only did a few. 5?

 

[oneoldone]

I was a member there for years. Their mods/admin will not publish a review unless it fits their Penthouse forum format. I got tired of 3 or 4 demands for re-writes to satisfy their policies.

Stating BBBJ and CIM will get a possible 8 or higher for the SP. Stating CBJ is typically a 6 or 7.

The reason I mention this is because some providers don't want it broadcast about CIM since it may be a YMMV scenario; you could possibly find that provider may not see you again.

Also there has been a high incidence of Fake reviews on many providers across Canada. Someone back east also used their platform for "getting back" at some providers too. Their credibility has taken a beating and many providers prefer not to be reviewed there anymore.

I agree about the format being universal. It does help with searching.

Tried it for a month was not overly impressed have to agree with bbboy not really worth it.