another stupid subjective poll. The chances are very good that for most people (and individual choices will vary as YMMV) that the winner for any given person is probably not on this list.
Of course that doesn't mean that the ladies on the list aren't the winners in some guys hearts.
A review board's not the same thing though. With a review board all the information is subjective, sure, but you can pick and choose what you want to use from the input of all the members, and you can filter accordingly. What's different about these polls is that you're being asked to choose from the subjective choices of one member that are imposed on you, as opposed to selecting what you want from all of them. That would make your extrapolation faulty!
can't argue about the revealing who's honest and ethical part though.