Massage Adagio

why i hate gift cards

Very Veronica

Banned
Aug 2, 2004
1,766
7
0
Vancouver
Couldn't agree more with this article. Of the few cards i've received (that i can even remember), 2 were never used, a couple had small balances/expired & at least one had me going to the exclusion of a merchant i preferred (and hanging my head in shame..starbucks vs jjbean) plus i just don't agree with giving a big box retailer credit. Companies love these cards but they're definitely not in the consumer's interest.

And who needs more clutter in their wallet? Fyi, cash (and chocolate & wine ;)) are never clutter :p nor are thoughtful gifts from the heart.

Gift cards. The little plastic store-branded ‘I-can’t-think-of-a-real-gift’ way to say ‘I spent money on you’. Going to a store and giving them money so that you can give someone else a little plastic card for the same amount of money, but restricting the use of that money to a single store.

And who thought up the rechargeable gift card? I get a gift card, use it up, and they want me to give them MORE money IN ADVANCE so they can sell me something in the future. Is there really anyone that uses this?? It boggles the mind.

The idea that a company can sell a product or service in the future is a very attractive. The company takes your money, and promises to someday give you something of value in exchange. Phone cards were the precursors to most of the gift card craze. People purchased phone minutes at a pre-set rate which was usually a little lower than the predominant rate. The phone-card company bought blocks of minutes from the larger phone carriers (at a discount) and passed on some of the deal to the end user. Nice case of win-win.

Today however, the companies have gotten wiser to the situation and are cutting out the middleman altogether. Offering someone a service or product later for a payment now can float a profit margin up where it would normally not be. Money comes into the company coffers, but no expenditures happen until someone uses the cards. It’s been turned into a win-possibly lose situation.

Gift-card use is on the rise. With Starbucks, Best-Buy, Barnes&Nobel, and even a large number of restaurants using branded gift cards, people are giving them as gifts more and more. Merchandise stores use them for return credit, rather than reimbursing people in cash. Giving the cards is a convenient way to get last-minute gifts, or gifts for that ‘hard to get for’ person, but there are a few hidden drawbacks to being the recipient of these cards.

Gift card drawbacks;

Money is locked up – Putting money on a gift card restricts it’s use to only those stores that accept the card. If you don’t care for any of the products at that store? Tough. Go pick your prize and deal with it. No choice. And just TRY getting cash back for the balance on the card.

Card is Lost/Never Used – This is the merchant’s ultimate dream. The gift card is purchased, given, then the receiver NEVER USES IT. I still have some gift cards with balances on them from years ago.

Time Cost of Money – As time goes on, the value of money is eroded by rising prices and inflation. Your money is tied up on the card, not earning any interest, and slowly losing it’s value. The longer you leave it on, the less it will be worth when you finally use it. Use it! Now! Not tomorrow! Now, Now, NOW!!. What are you waiting for!! Go, Go, GOOOO!

Small Balances on Cards – Another slightly insidious plot is the small remaining balance ploy. The situation occurs when you’ve used the balance on the card down to a couple of dollars. You have one of two choices 1) Look HARD to find something REALLY CLOSE in price to what’s remaining, or 2) Buy what you want, use the remaining small balance, then PAY THE DIFFERENCE. Either way, the company makes more money off of you than they are truly entitled to. How many out there have bought something you don’t want or need just to get the remaining balance off the card?

The short answer is, if you can’t think of something to give someone, just admit it and send them cash. Moolah, Cold hard simoleons. Dosh, whatever you want to call it. Do yourself and your recipient a favor and stay away from the hassle of today’s gift cards.
http://www.creditwithdrawal.com/2007/09/25/why-i-hate-gift-cards/
 

Dgodus

Banned
Nov 5, 2011
855
0
0
Here and There
For things like cloths I'll buy a gift card as buying something that didn't fit her right cause misery in my life for a short while. Just not worth the potential hassle. Besides there isn't much difference between a gift card and a spa gift certificate. Something like electronics seems like a dumb idea, unless you don't know the slightest thing about electronics.

And every year I tell my folks I don't want any presents, so they send me gift cards for the gas station. Can't go wrong with free gas and that's one card you can always get the full balance on.
 

virginjohn

New member
Apr 1, 2010
240
5
0
Vancouver
Couldn't agree more with this article. Of the few cards i've received (that i can even remember), 2 were never used, a couple had small balances/expired & at least one had me going to the exclusion of a merchant i preferred (and hanging my head in shame..starbucks vs jjbean) plus i just don't agree with giving a big box retailer credit. Companies love these cards but they're definitely not in the consumer's interest.

And who needs more clutter in their wallet? Fyi, cash (and chocolate & wine ;)) are never clutter :p nor are thoughtful gifts from the heart.

http://www.creditwithdrawal.com/2007/09/25/why-i-hate-gift-cards/
Gift cards have caught on b/c they offer a solution for two gift buying problems: someone you don't know that well (and you are expected to buy something) and the person who is hard to shop for (even if you know them well). Giving cash is sometimes perceived as offensive even though as you say it is objectively better than a gift card (certainly would come across as rude in the first category, no?).

But not all gift cards are equal, I think an Amazon gift card is pretty good b/c Amazon sells everything from luxury high end watches to books to pet food. Also you shop online and so you don't have to give your gift card to retailer and ask how much is in it.
 

violetblake

New member
Jul 24, 2011
541
0
0
Downtown Vancouver
I love gift cards! Both to give or to get. I'm a tricky size because I'm so small, so there's never a point in buying me clothes, so that's why gift cards are great for that. And I like giving them because that way it shows I know the person well enough to know their favourite stores, but they can pick whatever they want so they get the perfect gift, and I don't embarrass myself by getting something they hate! :p
 
Dec 2, 2002
3,408
5
0
Poon City
Same here i love gift cards. Especially places like future shop or for chatr for their phone service. Only gift cards i hate is to restaurants i dont go to like Dennys or Boston pizza or something lame.

I love gift cards if they are for a store I actually shop at. They encourage me to get something I was pining for but felt was too extravagant to purchase for myself. Victoria's Secret, nail salons/spas, home depot, liquor store...all good!

If a close friend gave me one I would feel they had been lazy but there are many people in my life where a gift card would be more than appropriate.
 
Mar 10, 2011
517
0
0
Dear Santa,
I would like to change my request for that yellow dump truck that i have been waiting for,
for 50 fucking years.
I would like to change it to a gift certificate to see and fuck VV.
i know you are still pissed that i gave you marijuana cookies back in the sixties , and you have been giving me coal forever ....but get the fuk over it dude.
it made for a interesting night i,m sure.
i,m not sure where you get the VV fuckfest certificate , but maybe ask one of them elves.
 

Pillowtalk

Banned
Feb 11, 2010
1,037
3
0
Credit card gift cards are really the answer. Can be used for anonymous online purchasing just about anywhere. Shoppers has Vanilla Mastercard in a bunch of different denominations on the same rack as all the other gift card options, and Canada post does a Visa that can be loaded with any amount over 25 bucks. Downside is an activation fee usually starting at $4.00, and upside is the recipient can use it just about everywhere and it is not store specific. The recipient sets up the card with info like name, address, postal code, phone #, which is used when making purchases to verify the card. Or a fake name if they want, as long as they are consistent when making the purchases.
 

virginjohn

New member
Apr 1, 2010
240
5
0
Vancouver
I gave a $500 MasterCard as a gift. Never again. The person only got to spend less than $400 and every transaction was a phone call to authorize. They were treated as a thief each time. The card "expired" with $80 on it and I'm still "discussing" the whole thing with MasterCard.
I had the same problem with a VISA gift card. Strangely enough the gift card you would think is closest to cash is pretty damn inconvenient.
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts