Worrying legislation proposal

john23

Member
Apr 1, 2006
601
0
16
123
www.elsewhere.org
A conservative MP from Manitoba is proposing this "anti-trafficking" bill.

This is a quote from the above press release (literally copied verbatim in the National Post today).

transmitting, distributing, or advertising any information for the means of sexual exploitation would be illegal
The problem is not so much putting an end to sexual exploitation. I'm sure we'd all agree on that. What is worrying is how are they going to determine "exploitation." For example, if I give someone a number for an AMP could that be determined to be "exploitation" if one of the women working there doesn't have their papers. Note that "exploitation" can apply to anyone of any age. The penalties are much higher if they can show that the victims were minors.

Right now, we have a similar problem with the common bawdy house law. Its extraordinarily broad. This law has been a great way to prevent sex workers from organizing and taking control of their work environment.

I think, unless there is some clear language on what actually constitutes "exploitation" this law will be misused. There is a real danger unless the test for exploitation is absolutely watertight that it could be used as a way to try and shut down these review forums.

The MP sponsoring this bill, Joy Smith gained notoriety for trying to introduce the "Clean Internet Act" which would have required all ISPs to be licensed by the CRTC and would have mandated them to restrict access to the internet for certain customers (eg sex offenders). This bill was roundly criticized for its attempts to erode freedom of expression.
 
Vancouver Escorts