What's it gonna cost?

littlejimbigher

New member
Jun 21, 2006
1,438
4
0
surrey
The commonly accepted length of the last deep depression is from 1929 to 1938. There are people that will argue for the start being in 1923 and there are people who will argue the end was in 1947. It depends on how you dice it. Europe was in deep recession by 1923 but it didn't really affect people in North America until 1929. Remember, we didn't have the degree of global trade back then. By 1939 North America was already ramping up war production (people like the British Prime Minister wouldn't admit war was inevitable, but everyone knew war was coming), however global trade didn't really resume until 1947.

This one is going to be much worse. What we are seeing right now is akin to 1923. That is when people with political theories on avoidance get elected. The fact that people elect people with theories on avoidance is actually tacit admission that it is inevitable. In 1923 the Germans elected Adolph Hitler because they hoped that his policies would help them avoid depression. In 2008 the Americans elected Barack Obama because they hope that his policies will help them avoid depression. There is a great deal of difference between the policies of the two men, but the reason they were elected is the same. There is a tacit admission by the electorate that there is going to be a deep depression.

In 1929 there were already active hostilities being engaged in by Germany (Spain) and Japan (China and Russia), North America and portions of Europe tried to pretend that it could be contained, but the electorate was already electing war leaders.

The difference this time is the degree of interdependence of the global economy and money supply. Only fools can pretend that the problems won't affect them.

We are probably looking at a really bad 20 years and a return to pre-WWII levels of social programs. That means no Government funded pensions, no Government funded health care, no Government funded housing and a reliance on Churches to provide the social safety net for the disadvantaged and unlucky.

We are also looking at a die off of substantial numbers of the world population.

The health care programs, food programs and intervention programs that we are used to aren't going to be funded past the next 2 or 3 years. Those programs are what keeps a large portion of the world's population alive.

People should look at what happened with the League of Nations once governments didn't have the funds to spare for it's funding. The same thing is going to happen with the United Nations.
You better check out you dates a bit more.
Hitler was elected in 1933.
Spanish civil war (aided by Germany )was 1936-37
Japan invaded China in 1931
 

normisanas

Banned
Nov 23, 2009
603
1
0
edboy1, krustee, dood and alinburnaby are all right in what they say. I'm glad to hear that there are people with such knowledge. I would like to add the following:

The fiat currency that was introduced by the United States, or more specifically, the default currency to transact oil purchases, was a brilliant move. It allowed the US to value the goods of other countries against its own currency and thereby have significant impact on the relative prices. It also allowed the US to export its debt through the purchase of US dollars (ie: bonds and other instruments of debt) when other countries needed US dollars in reserve to further more oil transactions. Now this has basically been covered by others here, but what I am adding is that the US not only took advantage of this, but exploited it to the point it wrecked its own foundations.

Here are the ways it was done. It was deemed that the US would have a much better economy and quality of life to change its economic infrastructure from the dirtiness of manufacturing and resource exploitation to an economy of financial and intellectual services. Other countries would provide such back breaking work at prices that ultimately are manipulated by relative currency values based on the US dollar. It was a plan that worked very well, and the IMF was set up as an instrument to further this. A recent example where the IMF was used shows clearly the US strategy for world economic dominance: the Asian financial crises of the 90's, promulgated by the Federal Reserve's increased interest rate which drew investment capital out of the economies of Korea and Singapore, Thailand, and such, brought their respective economies to their knees. Their currencies devalued to almost nothing and while this would have increased exports, it was ineffective because what they would get in exchange was next to nothing. The complaint issued to these countries that their inherent instability, due to their own banks that were by domestic legal edicts, restricted from significant involvement in international financial markets, was the cause of the problem and expressed as not meeting international "standards" and "regulations". The fact of the matter was that their central banks were expressly prohibited to serve any interest outside of the country, but must instead finance domestic industries - and this strategy worked exceedingly well: it worked for Japan and it created the success of S.Korea, Malaysia and other Asian countries. But the rise of S.Korea was seen as a big threat by both the US and Japan - they did not need another Asian miracle. So with these countries prostate, the IMF created a "rescue" package that would put foreign investment into these countries in exchange for opening up their banks. Effectively it was opening their banks for total foreign ownership. These economies had no choice. The US was thus able to export its debt to these nations and import their profits, extending its "financial services" model of the new economy it had set for itself.

Today we hear rants about China's renminbi, that it is fixed to the US dollar and not allowed to "float free". There are various threats but the only practical action proposed by the US (ie: actions other than just complaining), is to have China open up its financial system for "regulation". It is the exact same strategy employed against S.Korea, however this time it is different. The US is unable to use the raising of interest rates to draw foreign capital away from other countries as effectively as it had before because there is not the same trust and expectation that the United States will be solvent and remain the #1 economy. Furthermore, the US had gone too far in exporting its debt to other nations and China is the 2nd largest holder of US debt already so the US is in no position to force China to open its financial markets.

The other way that the US exploited the fiat system to its own demise is by the establishment in its own populace of a decreased tax rate. The US is the #1 producer of arms (doubling the next largest), it has the largest economic infrastructure in the first world, manufactures almost nothing in comparison to the size of its economy and therefore exports almost nothing in comparison (other than arms), yet somehow it is able to keep its tax rate low. How are all these arms paid for? How is this massive economic infrastructure paid for? Taxes can't afford it, for the US runs a budget deficit every year. It is paid for by the export of its debt to other countries. Americans have enjoyed such wealth without paying the tax to afford it, and have done so for so long now that it is impossible to raise taxes. With the irresponsible Republican agenda to keep taxes low, it is eliminating even any faint hope it does have of climbing out of debt.

The wheels were set in motion long ago, long before the Clinton administration, to erode the US from being a world power. The policy of exporting manufacturing and resource exploitation to other countries has been a disaster. The arrogance to believe that 1st world nations should not have to do such "dirty work", meaning it could exploit other nations to further their domination was a big mistake. It should come as an embarrassment that after all this time since WW2, since modern industrialization, since world dominance, the number one product of the United States is military hardware - and we all know the effect on the welfare of peoples these products have.
 

FunSugarDaddy

New member
Aug 15, 2008
1,110
5
0
There are a number of interesting points you raised and a couple of comments, for lack of a better word are simply wrong.

The energy comments and Fiat money comments are insightful and yes the US has created it's only problems when they insist that taxes be lowered and entitlements raised, but I don't know what any of this has to do with fund managers. Fund managers buy and sell companies, and contrary to popular belief they're a pretty passive bunch, in anything they should be far more vocal then they are, especially about executive pay, bonuses and the like. If they had used the power in the manner that you suggested they do, then surely the bonuses would have essentially evaporated, because paying them was certainly contrary to the shareholders' best interest.

That said, jobs were certainly exported during the last 10-20 years and continue to this day, but that's a result of globalization more than anything. Absent this export of jobs, people would simply have to choose to pay more for American produced products than say Chinese produced produces and they would have to refuse to shop at Walmart etc. In other words if the purchaser of the products what things dirt cheap, guess what, they'll get what they want, but the production of their dirt cheap products isn't going to come from a high wage country, cause the two are incompatible. So companies wanting to survive and remain profitable had no choice but to shift production in low cost countries, either that or they would have to accept a lower market share and hope purchasers would be comfortable paying a premium for their product. The alternative is bankrupcy. So I don't disagree with your analysis, but I do disagree that this has anything to do with fund managers. Nor do I disagree that this can't be solved, albeit with some hard medicine to swallow. They could solve it by doing some or all of the following:

Slashing pension entitlements to government workers, and eliminating indexing, in make it similar to what the private sector receives.
reduce the military budget by 10-15%
introduce a VAT/HST tax of say 6%
Add a tax to fuel
raise the age of social security from 67 to 69 and eliminate the entitlement for high income earners.
eliminate the deductibility of mortgage interest
allow health insurance companies to sell insurance across state borders
cap the amount of liability doctors can face for malpractise
buy pharmacutical drugs in bulk, similar to what we do in Canada
simplify the tax act and consider a flat tax
eliminate farm subsidies

Consider this and other proposals be the recent bipartisan debt commission panel.

http://www.wisconsinagconnection.com/story-national.php?Id=2291&yr=2010

http://www.businessweek.com/investor/content/nov2010/pi20101112_509030.htm


That said, time is starting to run out, and essentially they left this fiscal mess for so long that all the easy choices are long gone. We at least made some of these hard choices awhile ago, particularly on CPP and now our retirement fund is in pretty good shape, especially considering the recent fiscal crisis we've just suffered.

All that aside if there's blame to assign for the banking collapse and the mess that resulted in all that, I would point to the credit rating agencies, cause without them, the whole scheme wouldn't have taken place, because many fund companies and pension funds wouldn't have been allowed to buy all of that toxic mortgage debt.

All Oil represents is cheap, plentiful energy. We have changed our energy source in the recorded past and it didn't cause a huge problem. King Coal was what drove the industrial revolution. The supply of Coal exceeds the supply of Oil by a large margin.

If we wanted too, we could go to Thorium Salt reactors to provide electricity tomorrow. The GE Thorium Salt reactor has been used safely for years and does not produce weapons grade material as a by-product. Since they fit in a standard 20 foot shipping container, they could be used directly to power a train and could be sited in neighborhoods to provide community power.

It really is Fiat money / the change from the Gold Standard that is what allowed the USA to get where they are now. Prior to Nixon finding an easy way to pay the Vietnam War Debt, politicians were constrained in how many social entitlement programs they could buy votes with. A nation had to have Gold reserves to back up their currency.

The problem the USA has is that they allowed the export of the jobs that employed the people that paid the taxes that backed up the American Dollar. At the same time, the USA kept adding to the entitlements that the Government guaranteed and reduced taxes that the service and information industries had to pay.

I actually sort of enjoy the karma of the whole thing. The driving force of the demand that companies reduce operating costs has been the fund managers. The reason that jobs are shipped out if the work is transferable is that wages and benefits are a very large portion of operating costs. However, the funds are the retirement savings of - - manufacturing workers. Therefore, when a fund manager insists on low operating costs as a condition of owning a companies shares, they are working in direct opposition to the interests of the people that buy their funds.

These are the same workers that use Walmart and the big box stores and drove down the prices of short life consumables. They didn't produce shoes, clothing and plastic kitchenware - so they weren't concerned when those jobs moved to low wage/low tax environments. It was only when the low wage/low tax environments started producing durable consumables that they began to have an inkling of how seriously they had screwed themselves.

Since the companies that now produced consumer goods were located off-shore and very often were not even an company traded on the American stock exchanges, fund managers needed to move their investments into new areas. Therefore, we got the tech bubble and the housing bubble. The funds were now "investing" in those areas. With the tech bubble, nobody factored in how fickle consumers are. With the housing bubble, well the bad thing about selling a house to a person that can't afford it is - - they can't afford it, especially if they become unemployed because their job has been sent off - shore.

When you have a government that is spending money to buy votes, whether it was an ill advised war, more entitlements, repayment of political debts and you have a population that is participating wholeheartedly in the destruction of the financial system - - there never was anything other than national bankruptcy on the horizon.

That resulted in a debt that cannot be paid, no matter what model a person uses. Increasing taxes won't work because service and information industry employees don't earn what a manufacturing industry employee earned. Taxing the "Rich" doesn't work because the rich people just move. Taxing the creative people doesn't work because the creative people just move.

Take a look at California. They are losing their creative people, that's why Canada has a film industry. They are losing the creative people that design software and microelectronics, that's why India has campuses for all the major computer companies, that's why the fastest computer is now in China.

Even the people that benefited most from all of the "recovery" programs have moved out of California. California is now paying it's debts with script that is only useful for paying future Californian taxes.

The same thing is going to happen across the USA.

There are going to be riots in the USA this year and for the following years as people discover that their governments cannot deliver what was promised.

There is going to be an outflow of educated Americans to other nations that can pay for whatever skill they trained for.

In Canada, we are expecting our Doctor and Nurse shortage to be solved before the end of next year. India is expanding their Health Care Industry, Australia is expanding their industry.

People with credentials that transport well have always been able to move if they are given sufficient reason.
 
Last edited:

jnewton

Loitering on PERB
Aug 9, 2010
378
0
0
The problem is, in a hyperinflation environment, the worth of those savings rapidly depreciates, especially if it is held in fiat money (paper currency).
Glad to see everyone likes that term. Such a useful description for something that is intrinsically worthless, that is really worth only what "we" collectively accept it to be worth. Since the value of fiat money will tank so quickly in a hyper-inflationary environment, rather than putting away cash in a bank in the form of savings, it might make more sense to convert savings to gold or an even more useful commodity, food.

As for paying down debt, if creditors are not allowed to raise rates on outstanding loans to keep pace with hyperinflation, it makes more sense to pay as little as possible now and wait to pay off until the value of the currency has dropped, thereby making the loan worth less. Simple math, if you have a loan for 10000 and inflation cuts the value of the currency in half, then the 10000 that you use to pay the loan off after inflation is worth only 5000 in pre-inflation money. In effect, you get a loan reduction of 50%.
The obvious response to this argument is to allow the creditors to raise interest rates on consumer debt to keep pace with inflation but in a hyper-inflationary environment, I doubt there will be the political will to let creditors push millions of voting debtors into bankruptcy by allowing the creditors to increase rates that much. The result will be a windfall to debtors, allowing them to pay down debt with devalued money, in essence giving debtors a discount on their debt at the expense of the creditors, just like the US government is planning on doing to China and other large holders of US debt.
 

juniper

New member
Apr 11, 2006
407
2
0
Hey Krustee--Im glad that you've brought up this subject. When it comes to catastrophes, most of us in North America pretend it's not going to happen or it will soon be fixed. In other climes, such as Israel, where I reside half the year, the mentality is just the opposite. Catastrophes in the form of war and terror attacks happen so frequently that the veteran Israeli just passes it off as normal. I've met old Israeli men who have participated in four or five wars and made no big deal about it. For Israel, this is the norm.

At any rate, I agree with you about the pending economic meltdown. It has to happen. The dollar (U.S.) has become nearly worthless. So it would make sense, as I understand it, to invest in gold, silver, commodities or real estate. In other words, the dollar bill has become too "abstract" and will soon lose most of its worth.

Having said that, I have a question for you. Several people on this forum have suggested that it's in their interest to pay down debt. Now, if people come to the realization that the dollar is nearly worthless (like the Deutschmark in WWII), then we will be in a period of hyperinflation. If that were the case, then the debts we have now will become meager during a hyperinflation period. So it should be easy to pay off a large debt once the money has become relatively worthless. Am I making sense? The point is, buy now and pay off later when the money is without worth.

Now, the second question is, while reading financial reports on gold, there were advocates who predicted not inflation but deflation. That is, paying off a debt over the next twenty years would become much harder than it is now because the dollar develops more net worth, not less. Can you render your opinion about the possibility of deflation as opposed to inflation. It just doesn't make sense to me.
 
Last edited:
Vancouver Escorts