I must say I really don't agree with this whole tipping practice. I mean basically you are paying someone extra for simply doing the job for which they are already getting paid.
Now I know that usually people that get tips aren't paid that well, but there are also many other jobs at similar pay that are just as difficult if not more so and there is no tipping. And why should only the servers get the tip? I mean if the food is really good, I might rather tip the chef.
Now many people will say they tip for service, but the thing is giving good service is part of the job. You shouldn't have to pay extra for that. If someone were to give up giving good service and forgo tips, they wouldn't be employed at that job for very long.
I think it's the fact that tipping is expected that bugs me. I mean frankly people should be glad to get a tip because there is no obligation (technically) for people to tip. But no, if you leave a small tip, you're just a cheap bastard who won't get good service next time.
To tell you the truth, I would probably be happy to tip if the service was good and I knew it wasn't required (and if the requirement wasn't a specific rate like 15%) Also, the concept of it being a percentage doesn't really make much sense either. You could order a more expensive meal than someone else which would require the same work from the server as a cheaper meal, but now the server gets a bigger tip?
The whole tipping thing has gotten out of hand.