I think there is a big difference between a review and an issue worthy of complaining to a licencing body.
On PERB we have a review section, and we have a rip off section. For SPs that are just trying to rip you, we don't put it in the review section, we put it in the rip off section. I would consider the rip off area the equivalent of a malpractice section for doctors. If there was an escort licencing body, we would probably take the trouble to report these rip offs.
However, 99%+ of interactions with your doctor are not going to result in a malpractice suit or be bad enough to lodge a complaint to the college. I'd also equate that to 90%+ of our interaction with SPs. Now if we were only reporting those 10% of bad SPs, how would we know what the vast majority of SPs are like? If an SP lies there like a dead fish while you hump her but otherwise gives you your full time, is that enough to say she is a rip off? I don't think so. That's just a lame SP. SPs will range from lame to exceptional without being a "rip off". And our reviews here help us know which ones are gems and which ones are to be avoided. The same would apply to doctors. Even though the doctor may not be doing anything wrong, he may not be giving you top service in regards to bedside manner, taking their time to address all your issues, and accurate diagnosis.
I don't know about other people, but I'd rather have some idea of what a doctor is like in those areas instead of going on a wild crap shoot. Maybe there would be some way for the college to endorse a review system that verifies you aren't a troll by checking your carecard number but keeps everything anonymous after that. I really doubt that, but I'm just wishing aloud ...
Of course when it comes to doctors, the 'gems' have really long wait lists and aren't taking any new patients.
Also, suppose your GP knows that Doctor A is the best one to send you to for your specific problem, based on experience sending patients to various doctors for that problem. But, you read a review that said that Doctor B was better, based on one person's experience, who wasn't qualified to judge either doctor's medical knowledge or techniques. Now what?
Heck I posted some info that was totally in agreement with everything being said by all the leading experts and in all the medical journals. Something that was basically common knowledge and agreed on by over 95% of physicians (according to a study dealing specifically with physician attitudes towards the idea) and a couple of people with no medical background whatsoever convince Shiek that it is 'questionable advice' and poof, I wind up banned. See what happens when medicine becomes a popularity contest?
And, there's the question of what happens to the doctor patient relationship and what the results of that are vs what happens in the pooner-sp relationship and the results of that.
Next you have the idea that a doctor might actually change his pattern of practice based on either luke warm reviews or a desire for good reviews. Medicine isn't a popularity contest, and often the doctors who produce the best results are those who stick to their principles and don't necessarily always give patients what they want. Again, we have enough of a shortage of things like MRIs etc, what happens if doctors start trying to win popularity contests by giving patients unnecessary tests that they want?
Back when I was working in the ER, we would get calls from some GPs who were trying too hard for their patients to like them. They would tell us that we had to give their patient priority when in fact there was no medical reason to do so. Usually the nurses would tell the GP off and then the patient would arrive, having been told by their GP that they would go right to the front of the line and not have to wait at all... of course they were then looking at a 3-4 hour wait, with plenty of people in the line in front of them. Guess who they took it out on? Now in that situation, is the GP who was acting totally unprofessionally and who created the problem the one who is going to get the 'bad review'? Nope.. the ER doc who is just doing his job the way he is supposed to, taking care of the sickest patients first, is going to take the bum rap.
Now throw in the fact that there aren't enough docs to go around already, so why make matters worse by increasing the demand for a smaller number of doctors?
not so simple, is it?