Random Thoughs

CalgaryJenn

I Love To Chat
Apr 15, 2006
1,209
0
0
54
Calgary, Alberta
I had to go to Red Deer tonight and the road work on Deerfoot got me thinking. Actually, I got thinking about a couple things. Maybe somebody can help me out with some answers.

If the City of Calgary doesn't pay for the maintenance of Deerfoot trail or shell money out for it's improvements, why are they allowed to cash in on Deerfoot with photo radar? According to the Alberta Infrastructure site, the province is foots the bill for Deerfoot Trail repairs.

Why is it that the government starts taking taxes from working kids at the age of 16, but they can't vote for the same politicians who are going to spend their tax dollars? Is that fair? The same 16 and 17 year olds who either
a: should have a say as they are tax payers,
or
b: don't give them a say until they are 18, but stop making them pay taxes for something they have no say in such as political issues, justice and so on. Tax payers are supposed to have rights and a voice. Strangely enough, a lot of 16 and 17 year olds are being taught more and know more about Canadian and American politics than a lot of 30 - 40 - and 50 year olds. I don't think 16 and 17 year olds should get a free ride until they are 18, but if they pay their taxes and are being forced to pay their taxes, maybe they should be entitled to the privledges of being a tax payer.
Anyhow, thats what has been going through my head tonight. I figured I could get more insight and opinions on these thoughs here. There is always a varied set of opinions on PERB, so it might be interesting.
 

kman32

New member
Jul 4, 2007
108
0
0
Random Answer

On the flipside of this argument. If a citizen doesn't pay taxes should he or she have the right to vote? No representation without taxation? Of course they'll always receive the benefits from taxes, they drive on paved roads, brightly lit and patrolled by police. If they get sick they have free medical care. They get their food, houses and cars inspected for dangerous elements. They have electricity in their homes. Working toilets. Public parks and fireworks in July. The list goes on and on. But if they don't contribute to the pool of money should they have a say on how it's spent? I'm sure the majority of pensioners, disabled workers, poor people and SP's wouldn't want their voting rights tied to their T4's.
 

georgebushmoron

jus call me MR. President
Mar 25, 2003
3,126
2
0
56
Seattle
Why is it that the government starts taking taxes from working kids at the age of 16, but they can't vote for the same politicians who are going to spend their tax dollars? Is that fair? The same 16 and 17 year olds who either
a: should have a say as they are tax payers,
or
b: don't give them a say until they are 18, but stop making them pay taxes for something they have no say in such as political issues, justice and so on. Tax payers are supposed to have rights and a voice. Strangely enough, a lot of 16 and 17 year olds are being taught more and know more about Canadian and American politics than a lot of 30 - 40 - and 50 year olds. I don't think 16 and 17 year olds should get a free ride until they are 18, but if they pay their taxes and are being forced to pay their taxes, maybe they should be entitled to the privledges of being a tax payer.
Anyhow, thats what has been going through my head tonight. I figured I could get more insight and opinions on these thoughs here. There is always a varied set of opinions on PERB, so it might be interesting.
You seem to have multiple questions, and I might attempt to rephrase them for you to get clarity.

One of your questions is, "is it fair to compel a person to pay income taxes, but not give them the right to vote". The answer is of course, "no". However, those who do not have citizenship similarly pay income taxes (if given the right to work), but do not have the right to vote. These people have permanent residency status. So perhaps your question should be, "should a person with citizenship and who is compelled to pay income taxes, have the right to vote?". That answer would be "yes". But it seems the government differentiates, among those with citizenship, by age when it comes to the right to vote. That age would be 18.

Which leads to your next question, which is based upon the ability of those under 18 to make an informed decision with regard to such things as voting and other important matters with respect to the country, personal livelihood (ie: holding a job), operating a motor vehicle safely, etc. It appears you believe they have the capacity to do many of these things, perhaps some better than others twice or thrice their age. So your 2nd question might be, "what should be the age of legal liability in Canada?".

200 years ago in North America and Europe, females aged 15 could marry. Many had their first children by 18, and this was seen as acceptable and common place. By the time they were 40, they might be grand mothers. This was also seen as acceptable and common place. 50 years ago, 15 year old females were escorted everywhere they went. However, it was not unusual for them to marry at 18 or 19, and have sex for the first time in their lives. If they had sex before marriage, this was not only deemed widely unacceptable, they were immediately ushered off to special Reform schools to "correct their behaviour". If they even spoke about sex before age 18, it was only for the purposes of procreation and never about pleasure. If they spoke about sex for pleasure, they were reprimanded by everyone. Today the world has changed again. It is highly likely that a 15 year old girl already has had sex. Not only that, she is encouraged by educators to discuss sex, and not only discuss sex for procreation, but for pleasure, and certainly would never have her behaviour corrected in a Reform school. If a 15 year old girl has sex, she is not reprimanded by everyone around her. In fact, it is likely she is encouraged to use birth control and condoms the next time she has sex. She may engage friends in discussion about oral sex, vaginal sex, and anal sex. In fact, sex and sexuality is a common theme among teenage discussions.

Those in power feel that those under the age of 19 ought to have special status under the law. They are permitted to do many adult things, but not be held legally liable for their actions. Why? I don't know, but my guess is that because they are thought to be children, and hence not able to understand or realize the consequences of their actions.

Case law upholds, again and again, children protected from criminal liability because they supposedly do not understand or realize the consequences of their actions. There are many cases where kids murder but don't go to jail, the reason is because they can not understand that what they did would cause a death.

The Justice system both in Canada and the United States is deeply flawed with regard to this, in my opinion. Those who make the laws fail to live in modern times, instead, they live in a period of their own youth, about 50 years ago. They do not open their eyes to understand the reality of young people. That reality is that young people today are not the same young people of 50 years ago.

But that is not their only failing. They also fail at Justice. It appears they believe there are 2 types of Justice, one for those under 18/19 and one for those 18/19 and older. Those older are made legally liable (criminally) if they break the law, regardless if they knew it was a law or not. This also means that they do not have to know the consequences of harm it may bring to others in being made legally liable. What this means is that older persons are not expected to know every law, but are liable based on knowing the difference between right and wrong (from which the law is based) only, and not upon the consequence of wrongful action. Younger persons, however, are not legally liable - and as we know from case law, the reason is because they do not understand the consequences of their actions. In other words, they do not have legal liability not because they may know an action is wrong or right, but because even if they know an action is wrong that they do not understand nor foresee the harm such an action brings. Here's where Justice goes bad.

Youth today are adulterized. It may be a valid argument that inexperience does not allow them the understanding that harm can be caused by particular actions, but this threshold for legal liability based on harm makes no sense when the threshold does not reflect the reality of youth today. Teens today know the difference between right and wrong, and I believe Law makers know this. It does not matter if a teen can foresee that beating someone with a baseball bat may result in their death, it is enough that the teen knows that doing such a thing is morally wrong. Law makers don't seem to want to discuss this, and judges seem to gloss this over when they have a teen before them accused of murder.

Why teens are given such a soft cushion on morality is beyond me. They know the difference between right and wrong, and if they don't quite yet, they ought to. We should expect more from them, not less. I say give them all the rights of adults, remove all laws that discriminate based on age over 12, but make them criminally liable as adults as well. It's been long overdue.
 

littlejimbigher

New member
Jun 21, 2006
1,438
4
0
surrey
I've never understood the US where you can join the Armed forces at 18 and kill or be killed but you have to be 21 to get a drink leagally.
 
Vancouver Escorts