I think the bottom line is Clarke is an idiot. He left Nonis with a lose/lose situation. When he played hockey there wasn't a player I hated more, but you wanted him on your team. Too many elbows to his head must have jarred something loose!
it wouldn't have been so bad if Clarke had made a reasonable offer likeKYG said:Nonis didn't have much of a choice. Nucks are a bit thin at centre and they need a centreman now not a second round in 2007.
Fuck you very much Bobby Clarke. Can't wait until your restricted free agents are coming up.
Clarke obviously sees something (speed?) in Kesler that gives him the confidence not only to pay him that kind of money, but give him a chance to battle it out with Jeff Carter for the No.2 spot behind Forsberg. If Kesler did end up playing with Philly, there'd be a possibility of Mike Richards, Sami KApanen, Kyle Calder, or RJ Umberger as his linemates. Not bad if u ask me, and instantly Philly would have a solid, young 3 line team rivalling the sabres and Kesler would have a break through year and end up growing into that salary. Let's not forget that quite a few ex-Canucks have had a habit of blossoming once they left the team. Let's hope this isn't the case here!The Lizard King said:I agree with you but it's also far too early to give up on a 22 year old 1st rounder when he has more upside than all but 4 of your forwards.
What Clarke did wasn't against the rules, but there is a gentlemens agreement between GMs that it's a no no to go after each others RFA. The league can't really put punitive or restrictive measures in place because it would basically render restricted free agency useless and the Players Association would certainly raise a stink. The other GMs can take punitive action though by going after Clarke's RFA and driving their prices up to teach him a lesson. With a cap in place Clarke's actions don't make any sense, driving up player prices doesn't benefit any team.KingLeer said:As it stands right now the new system has a lot of kinks that have to be worked out. There is also a lot of potential for abuse. For example, and I'm not suggesting in any way this is happening, Clarke goes to Kesler and signs him to an offer sheet at $1.9 knowing this will immediately double Kesler's salary. He also is fairly certain that the Canucks will match. He says before he signs his offer sheet, "there you go kid, I'll split the difference with ya".
The fact is, there is no punitive measures against any rogue GM who makes deals like this. All the burden is on the original club to match and then is prevented from trading the player for one year. Shouldn't there be some restrictions on the poaching club, like having to sign the player to a longer contract than one year? Or how about, if the original club matches, the poaching club has to pay 25% or 50% of the new contract?
Clarke put out a bluff on Vancouver and basically forced Nonis to make a hard decision given the tight cap environment. Basically it was a can't lose move by Clarke, since a) he would've happily accepted Kesler into the fold given his speed and given Primeau's retirement or b) the Nucks matching of the offer means all of their cap space is used up & thus weakening their prospects of going out for some last minute shopping.sirlickheralot said:What Clarke did wasn't against the rules, but there is a gentlemens agreement between GMs that it's a no no to go after each others RFA. The league can't really put punitive or restrictive measures in place because it would basically render restricted free agency useless and the Players Association would certainly raise a stink. The other GMs can take punitive action though by going after Clarke's RFA and driving their prices up to teach him a lesson. With a cap in place Clarke's actions don't make any sense, driving up player prices doesn't benefit any team.
Which makes you wonder why Clarke would break this 'Gentlemen's agreement'.sirlickheralot said:What Clarke did wasn't against the rules, but there is a gentlemens agreement between GMs that it's a no no to go after each others RFA.
I dunno about that. I think is sounds more like timing than anything. Look at the timing with Keith Primeau announcing his retirement. I think it was just a case of having some money freed up with Primeau's retirement, plus a need for a centre, plus knowing the Umberger and Kesler played together in college. TSN made it sound like Clarke was demonstrating to Ed Schneider that he's not behind the times and can still manage in the new NHL, but I don't really believe that.Dr.Naughtypants said:Sounds personal.
Why? Hate seems to be a rather strong word here. Nonis has not performed that badly, and although he has made a few mistakes, who hasn't in that situation. As far as Cooke is concerned, if he played with a little more discipline, which he may well do under Vigneault, if he is on the first line, he may have a great year. He did perform well with that line after the Bertuzzi suspension.Marvin said:Fuck I hate Cooke. Fuck I hate Nonis.
Yeah, hate is a strong word. As for Cooke, can you honestly tell me that he ranks among the top RW around the league? Could he play on any other team's top line? And same goes for Morrison for that matter.KingLeer said:Why? Hate seems to be a rather strong word here. Nonis has not performed that badly, and although he has made a few mistakes, who hasn't in that situation. As far as Cooke is concerned, if he played with a little more discipline, which he may well do under Vigneault, if he is on the first line, he may have a great year. He did perform well with that line after the Bertuzzi suspension.
You know you can't have it both ways. If he was among the top RW's in the league he'd be making a lot more than $1.5 million, now wouldn't he? Can't knock the guy just because he makes the best of whatever talent he has. Of course he's not a top rated winger, no one ever said he was.Marvin said:. As for Cooke, can you honestly tell me that he ranks among the top RW around the league? Could he play on any other team's top line? And same goes for Morrison for that matter.
Exactly, he is not a top RW so why put him there? As for his $1.5 million, he is over-priced at that rate - he is a fourth line $600,000 guy. That's my opinion and you are free to disagree.KingLeer said:You know you can't have it both ways. If he was among the top RW's in the league he'd be making a lot more than $1.5 million, now wouldn't he? Can't knock the guy just because he makes the best of whatever talent he has. Of course he's not a top rated winger, no one ever said he was.
Even if he wasn't hurt, do you think he is a top center on any of the other teams? We got our marquee goalie, now what we need is a top centerman. Again, my opinion.KingLeer said:As for Morrison, why don't you ask what the other players and coaches say about Morrison? He played mostly hurt last year, he still is hurting for that matter. The thing that hurt him most last year however, was exactly who his right winger was. Truth be known, 2/3's of that line was hurting and Bertuzzi was dysfunctional.
Yeah, in my opinion Morrison is a top centre. He was in New Jersey, he is here and he would be the first or second line centre on most teams. As for gettting a top centreman...i'm assuming you mean an elite centre, maybe someone like Sundin. You can say good bye to that wish, now that we have the salary cap. Unless you want to consider trading Luongo or Naslund (who still has a no trade clause).Marvin said:do you think he is a top center on any of the other teams? We got our marquee goalie, now what we need is a top centerman. Again, my opinion.
Right, that is your opinion and that it where we differ. He is at best a marginal second line center on most teams as far as I see it. As for elite center, Sundin - are you still in the 90's? When you say elite center, how about Joe Thornton? There is no hope of getting Thornton here for Naslund and why would you trade Luongo, the marquee goalie you just traded for?KingLeer said:Yeah, in my opinion Morrison is a top centre. He was in New Jersey, he is here and he would be the first or second line centre on most teams. As for gettting a top centreman...i'm assuming you mean an elite centre, maybe someone like Sundin. You can say good bye to that wish, now that we have the salary cap. Unless you want to consider trading Luongo or Naslund (who still has a no trade clause).





