What Ruffian was saying is that if the review is too good to be true and the person has only a couple of posts, then, he considers it a shill... It it can also go the other way as well, it the person has one or two posts and they talk harshly about an SP; not just a bad review but down-and-out attacking the SP.
When I read a review I often consider the post count as I read it... More often than not the review is genuine but I for one have called "shill" a couple of times because the style of writing, content and the number of posts would indicate such.
It is the same thing when you see someone with one or two posts coming on and giving a harsh review or making rude comments to other members of this board; I for one start to wonder if that person is just another member with multiple handles trying to stir the pot up for fun.
Anyone can jump to conclusions when it comes to the number of posts and registration dates but how it relates to what that person writes is what is the main point. There is so much crap happening these days that sometimes the bias is that people with single digit or lower posts counts almost have to prove themselves, but, that is human nature.
It took me a while to get into the flow of things and learn what not to say and here I am 700 some odd posts later. Do I deserve more than those who have less than 50 or 100 posts? NO, we are equal... But the amount of time that I have been on the board has given me the insight as to the personalities that exsist here and the foresight to self moderation when I write something.
I have respect and admiration for those who have many posts on this board, and, for those I have met in person it was great to match a face and voice to what I have read. And, I know it took time for me to gain even a fraction of the respect from them because I had to create this rep through my reviews and posts.
Everyone is welcomed with open arms and welcomed to their own opinions, but, if they start to trash others without cause and generally offend others for what is precieved as having fun by stirring up the pot, then they deserve the scrutiny of the moderators and the other veteran posters. If they are just very opinionated and are not directing any rude comments toward and one person, gender or race, then by all means bring on the healthy debate.
So, for me it comes down to this:
Do I respect others with a certain number of posts? Yes, because I have a number of other posts from them to read and make my own decisions about what they have written.
Do I agree with the opinions of those with a certain number of posts? I can agree or disagree with them, just because they have a large number of post does not mean that I automatically agree with what they say.
Do I automatically assume newbies are here to "shill" or stir the pot? No, but I tend to scrutinize what they post more until I see more from them to make my own judgements.
Do I even know what I am talking about? Well, I would like to think so but I could be wrong
Play safe and always be cool!
RR