Liberal Programs Axed under Tory Spending Cuts

westwoody

Well-known member
Jun 10, 2004
7,877
7,835
113
Westwood
Get rid of the Indian Act and render all the treaties null and void. Harper would save BILLIONS not millions. Of all the money poured into reserves hardly any does any good, come to Manitoba or NW Ontario and visit some of the reserves here and you'll be shocked and pissed off. The only way the natives will ever get the kind of equality their crooked Chiefs bitch about is to assimilate into mainstream society and give up the naive fantasy that they can go on maintaining the lifestyle of their ancestors in isolation while the rest of the world is in the 21st century.
As a side benefit a lot of civil servants would be made redundant, for every Indian there seems to be about ten civil servants.
 

hornyitalian06

New member
May 5, 2006
619
0
0
Edmonton
westwoody, I agree with you on this issue;) . Maybe you should talk to Minister of Indian Affairs as a Consultant and you could try introduce your plans:cool:
 

dr_pepper

New member
Oct 4, 2005
168
0
0
westwoody said:
Get rid of the Indian Act and render all the treaties null and void. Harper would save BILLIONS not millions. Of all the money poured into reserves hardly any does any good, come to Manitoba or NW Ontario and visit some of the reserves here and you'll be shocked and pissed off. The only way the natives will ever get the kind of equality their crooked Chiefs bitch about is to assimilate into mainstream society and give up the naive fantasy that they can go on maintaining the lifestyle of their ancestors in isolation while the rest of the world is in the 21st century.
As a side benefit a lot of civil servants would be made redundant, for every Indian there seems to be about ten civil servants.

You said it. It's time we all started moving forward together. I'm not exactly sure what the logic is of trying to live as your forefathers. I'm all in favour of trying to preserve and teach the core values and beliefs of your ancestors, but to think you can just freeze things in time - quickest pathway to extinction if you ask me.
 

steverino

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2004
1,613
1,167
113
I heard that....

Harper has cut $8475.00 from the HornyItalian budget. He no longer is supporting any pooning by hornyitalians.
 

dirtydan

Banned
Oct 7, 2004
1,059
0
0
59
westwoody said:
Get rid of the Indian Act and render all the treaties null and void. Harper would save BILLIONS not millions.

That's pretty ignorant. These treaties, whether one approves of them or not, were signed in good faith by both sides. The only way to end these treaties is not by unilaterial action by a predominatedly white government, but rather by negotiations with both sides. Do it your way and one can pretty much guarantee a future of voilence by both sides.

westwoody said:
Of all the money poured into reserves hardly any does any good, come to Manitoba or NW Ontario and visit some of the reserves here and you'll be shocked and pissed off. The only way the natives will ever get the kind of equality their crooked Chiefs bitch about is to assimilate into mainstream society and give up the naive fantasy that they can go on maintaining the lifestyle of their ancestors in isolation while the rest of the world is in the 21st century.
It's pretty easy to cast all chiefs as crooked. Our society accepts such ignorant bullshit because, afterall, these chiefs ain't white. That's not an accusation of racism directed at you, but rather pointing out a truism of Canadian society. Too often a specific group of people is targetted for some bad thing without most people thinking about what ol'Whitey does.

Also dude, assimilation was tried and in the end it failed big time and we are paying for it. I don't see the sense of redoing something that was so wrong in the first place. Furthermore the First Nations, Natives, Indians, or whatever they want to be called, are not looking to live the same way their ancestors did back in the 1800's. They want equality of opportunity like you and I have. If they want to do something in a different way, because they have their own culture, so fucking what?

westwoody said:
As a side benefit a lot of civil servants would be made redundant, for every Indian there seems to be about ten civil servants.
Oh yah, got some numbers for that?
 

rickoshadows

Just another member!
May 11, 2002
902
1
18
66
Vancouver Island
dirtydan said:
If they want to do something in a different way, because they have their own culture, so fucking what?
I have no problem with that, as long as we aren't funding it with our tax dollars and they aren't using tax free status to undercut other citizens.
 

westwoody

Well-known member
Jun 10, 2004
7,877
7,835
113
Westwood
dirtydan said:
These treaties...were signed in good faith by both sides.
The world has changed since those treaties were signed. The wording is often vague and contradictory, for example, what does the phrase "Ensure all members of a band receive education" mean? That all members are provided with a high school education, or that they can go to university for free? I -personally know one band member who has made a lot of money off her band by enrolling in UofW, UofM and then RRCC in different years, getting her expense and tuition cash, and then dropping out. So there's a load of money that could have been put to better use.negotiations with both sides. I know members from up north who get money from their band to visit relatives in hospital here in Winnipeg, but they just treat it as a free trip. Go to the St Regis and you can meet lots of them.
that's pretty racist
Spare me the NDP anti-racism broken record. The democracy on the reserves I visit would have made Ferdinand Marcos blush. If I see a band council all driving brand new Sierras and living in nice houses while the rest of the band lives twenty to a house I have every right to call them crooked. I saw one councillor sell logging rights and pocket the money. That's crooked.
They want equality of opportunity like you and I have. If they want to do something in a different way, because they have their own culture, so fucking what?
Do Sikhs or Muslims need a treaty to preserve their culture? Do they need their own government department to attend to their needs?
Oh yah, got some numbers for that?
...uuuhh, did I hit a nerve...you aren't a civil servant are you? I've been to the office on Portage and Smith and it looked like there was a lot of deadwood.
Did you read the column in the Sun a few days ago about how much paperwork there is in processing vision/dental/healthcare claims? I'm sure GreatWest could do it quicker and cheaper.
 
Last edited:

mick_eight

Banned
Feb 21, 2005
1,197
0
0
A relative of mine spent 1 yr teaching in northern MB. He was paid $100000 for 10 months , he had 12 students . He said they were incapable of learning, plus they had no desire at all to better themselves. I'd say the Gov. threw the money away. He was happy with it. So someone did benefit from the program, it just wasn't the students
 

gravitas

New member
Feb 7, 2006
2,165
0
0
westwoody said:
Do they need their own government department to attend to their needs?
Can I have my own ministry? Say the "Department of Providing 18 Year Old Virgins to Middle Aged White Guys"
 

badwolfcgy

red neck
Jan 26, 2006
197
0
0
I notice that people tend to take better care of things that they have to work for.
Give some one a house and they will split kindling in the livingroom and complain that the roof leaks.
A perfect example is Habitat for Humanity vs government lowcost housing. H for H housing requires that the future owner help build the house and some of their neighbours.
When have you seen someone trying improve their government lowcost house?
 

dirtydan

Banned
Oct 7, 2004
1,059
0
0
59
westwoody said:
The world has changed since those treaties were signed.
OK, then there would be a whole shit load of all kinds of treaties that are null and void. That's the principle you're advocating right?

westwoody said:
The wording is often vague and contradictory, for example, what does the phrase "Ensure all members of a band receive education" mean? That all members are provided with a high school education, or that they can go to university for free?
And this means the feds can unilaterially null and void their treaties with the Indians?

westwoody said:
I -personally know one band member who has made a lot of money off her band by enrolling in UofW, UofM and then RRCC in different years, getting her expense and tuition cash, and then dropping out.
Ok, then everything is to be judge on the actions of one individual.

westwoody said:
So there's a load of money that could have been put to better use.negotiations with both sides.
Sure there is, however your main arguement is to null and void, unilaterially, the treaties with the First Nations and the feds. Right?

No one has ever said that the Department of Natives Affairs is an outstanding example of a fine tuned bureaucratic machine. However society is essentially conditioned to shit all over one particular government department while giving little concern to other government wastage.

westwoody said:
I know members from up north who get money from their band to visit relatives in hospital here in Winnipeg, but they just treat it as a free trip. Go to the St Regis and you can meet lots of them.
Well if I were in the hospital, a Winnipeg hospital, hundreds and hundreds of miles away from my family I would sure like a visit from them.

westwoody said:
Spare me the NDP anti-racism broken record.
What on earth does the NDP have to do with this?

westwoody said:
The democracy on the reserves I visit would have made Ferdinand Marcos blush. If I see a band council all driving brand new Sierras and living in nice houses while the rest of the band lives twenty to a house I have every right to call them crooked. I saw one councillor sell logging rights and pocket the money. That's crooked.
Sure what that councillor, according to you, did was wrong. You want to condemn them all with this unilaterially null and void the treaties. On one hand you preach the hardships of the natives and on the other you advocate something that equates to shitting all over them.

westwoody said:
Do Sikhs or Muslims need a treaty to preserve their culture? Do they need their own government department to attend to their needs?

Do the Sikhs, Muslims, or anything ethnic group in Canada have a treaty?


westwoody said:
...uuuhh, did I hit a nerve...you aren't a civil servant are you? I've been to the office on Portage and Smith and it looked like there was a lot of deadwood.
The deadwood being who, the Indians or the government employees? And if I am a civil servant, what then? Maybe I'm like that Commie apparatchik in Dr. Zhivago who shouts at the doctor, "You have been noticed!"

westwoody said:
Did you read the column in the Sun a few days ago about how much paperwork there is in processing vision/dental/healthcare claims? I'm sure GreatWest could do it quicker and cheaper.
I don't read the Sun. I don't like a newspaper that's so bad that it makes the National Post look like a good quality newspaper that makes great strives to be consistently fair and balanced. I did however read a column in the Free Press by, I forget her name, about the same issue. Very interesting.
 

wolverine

Hard Throbbing Member
Nov 11, 2002
6,384
9
38
E-Town
westwoody said:
The only way the natives will ever get the kind of equality their crooked Chiefs bitch about is to assimilate into mainstream society and give up the naive fantasy that they can go on maintaining the lifestyle of their ancestors in isolation while the rest of the world is in the 21st century.
I don't think the First Nations ancestors had satellite dishes and ran golf courses and casinos. Rather than being a special-interest group that live in countryside ghettos and are only recognized if they dance pow-wows for the Queen, I'm all for making the natives an equal part of society. That includes having them actually paying taxes just like everyone else. And they can partake in our society without losing their heritage and spiritual beliefs.
 

westwoody

Well-known member
Jun 10, 2004
7,877
7,835
113
Westwood
dirtydan said:
OK, then there would be a whole shit load of all kinds of treaties that are null and void. That's the principle you're advocating right?
Many international treaties are constantly updated or subsumed to reflect changing conditions. Why should treaties between First Nations and the Crown be frozen in time?
And this means the feds can unilaterially null and void their treaties with the Indians?
I advocate a one-time buyout. Give each member of a band a one-time lump sum, and that's the end of it. And leave the band out of it so the councils don't screw it up. By the way, that one time lump sum would likely be more than most people get. The government has yet to give me a pile of cash.
Ok, then everything is to be judge on the actions of one individual.
She was just one example, I could wear out my fingers giving more.
However society is essentially conditioned to shit all over one particular government department while giving little concern to other government wastage.
Shame on me for picking on your department.I totally approve of wastage in all other departments...NOT.
Well if I were in the hospital, a Winnipeg hospital, hundreds and hundreds of miles away from my family I would sure like a visit from them.
When my mother was dying in Vancouver I didn't get any money from the government to go visit her.
What on earth does the NDP have to do with this?
I sometimes equate political correctness with the NDP. You said my comment was ignorant bullshit and that people would only say things like that because the chiefs were native. I would say to you that your parochial attitude is exactly what is preventing the First Nations people from getting anywhere. I called them crooked because I have seen their corrupt practices up close. The stuff that goes on on reserves would never be tolerated in a community like Vancouver or Winnipeg. Can you imagine if the mayor of Vancouver built a condo for all his relatives at taxpayer expense? But the same thing happens on reserves when councillors all live in nice new houses with running water and electricity, but people they don't like have to live in a squalor with a dozen or more others per house.
Sure what that councillor, according to you, did was wrong. You want to condemn them all with this unilaterially null and void the treaties. On one hand you preach the hardships of the natives and on the other you advocate something that equates to shitting all over them.
Hardly shitting on them,moving them into mainstream society is the best thing that could happen to the vast majority of natives. But there is a huge beaurocracy of civil servants and the native parallel government who would no longer be sucking on the taxpayer's teat. So the chiefs and their allies in the department have to keep on telling the First Nations people that they cannot exist in the white man's world without their help.
Do the Sikhs, Muslims, or anything ethnic group in Canada have a treaty?
If they can maintain their own culture without one why do the natives need them?
The deadwood being who, the Indians or the government employees?
Deadwood:The Assembly of First Nations, most provincial assemblies, at least half of all band councils, everyone at DINA. Why do First Nations have to have their own health plan when every province has one? Why do First Nations need their own educational system when every province has a ministry of education? Why do the First Nations have their own disastrously mismanaged children's aid organisations when the province does the same thing?
 

dirtydan

Banned
Oct 7, 2004
1,059
0
0
59
westwoody said:
Many international treaties are constantly updated or subsumed to reflect changing conditions. Why should treaties between First Nations and the Crown be frozen in time?

I'm not saying that these treaties have to be frozen in time. If changes are to be such cannot be done unilaterially, but rather be negotiated by the parties involved.

westwoody said:
I advocate a one-time buyout. Give each member of a band a one-time lump sum, and that's the end of it. And leave the band out of it so the councils don't screw it up.
Do it whities' way or get nothing, is this what you're trying to get across?


westwoody said:
By the way, that one time lump sum would likely be more than most people get. The government has yet to give me a pile of cash.
She was just one example, I could wear out my fingers giving more.
Shame on me for picking on your department.I totally approve of wastage in all other departments...NOT.
You make an assumption, do you know if it is correct or not?

westwoody said:
When my mother was dying in Vancouver I didn't get any money from the government to go visit her.
Do you have a treaty or some kind of agreement with the province or feds for such funding? Likely not.

westwoody said:
I sometimes equate political correctness with the NDP.
A little political lesson, all sides of the political spectrum have their brand of political correctness. To equate what we generally see as political correctness today and brand it as being left-wing or even as left of center can end up being off the mark.

westwoody said:
You said my comment was ignorant bullshit and that people would only say things like that because the chiefs were native.
Indeed, my comments alone attest to the fact I ain't politically correct. I also have found that people often resort to calling something politically correct as a means to cast something as wrong, and using the particular term is to be taken as the person being correct and no one should dare ask any questions.


westwoody said:
I would say to you that your parochial attitude is exactly what is preventing the First Nations people from getting anywhere.
Gees, I didn't know my posts were that powerful. :rolleyes:

westwoody said:
I called them crooked because I have seen their corrupt practices up close. The stuff that goes on on reserves would never be tolerated in a community like Vancouver or Winnipeg.
Are you suggesting that all chiefs and councilors be painted as being crooked? I ask that because essentially this is the jist of what you're saying whether or not you mean it that way.

westwoody said:
Can you imagine if the mayor of Vancouver built a condo for all his relatives at taxpayer expense? But the same thing happens on reserves when councillors all live in nice new houses with running water and electricity, but people they don't like have to live in a squalor with a dozen or more others per house.
It is far easier to report on any corruption that is said to go on at a reserve than it is to report on any corruption in a "white" government. Let's face about the only time the media reports on the reserves or other first nations issues is usually when something wrong has occurred. I not saying there is bad shit going on with a given band council, what I'm trying to get across is put in perspective, in that shit goes on with civic, provincial, and federal levels as well.

westwoody said:
Hardly shitting on them,moving them into mainstream society is the best thing that could happen to the vast majority of natives.
It was tried, for quite a long time. In the end the assimilation failed, although it left the first nations in a very bad way which they are trying to get out of. Fucking up all sorts of native across the country for a couple of hundred years can't be undone quickly. IMO, it will take a number of decades, because I'm willing to bet there will be types advocating going back to the failed policy of assimilation as the great solution.

westwoody said:
But there is a huge beaurocracy of civil servants and the native parallel government who would no longer be sucking on the taxpayer's teat.
So it's their fault? I always get a kick out of the ignorant that babble like they know everything and yet prove they know fuck all. Perhaps you know the type, they say dumb things that allude government employees are all bad because they are simple government employees.

westwoody said:
So the chiefs and their allies in the department have to keep on telling the First Nations people that they cannot exist in the white man's world without their help.

A sweeping generalization?


westwoody said:
If they can maintain their own culture without one why do the natives need them?
Are you saying the first nations don't have a culture or cultures?


westwoody said:
Deadwood:The Assembly of First Nations, most provincial assemblies, at least half of all band councils, everyone at DINA. Why do First Nations have to have their own health plan when every province has one? Why do First Nations need their own educational system when every province has a ministry of education? Why do the First Nations have their own disastrously mismanaged children's aid organisations when the province does the same thing?
Reads like more sweeping generalizations.
 

lovinithard

New member
May 28, 2006
117
0
0
between her legs
Anyways, back to the tax cuts...

When is the fucking subsidy to the oil and gas industry (1.5 billion/annum) going to get cut? If there is an industry that doesn't need a handout, it is this one.

But I ain't holding my breath, Alberta is Conservative country.
 

Randy Whorewald

Orgasm donor
Sep 20, 2005
3,319
0
0
Greek Islands
www.randydyck.com
westwoody said:
The Tories will go on a spending binge right before the next election.
That is Standard Operating Procedure.
 

hornyitalian06

New member
May 5, 2006
619
0
0
Edmonton
All parties spend money just before they call an election;) :p :cool: :) .
 
Vancouver Escorts