westwoody said:
Many international treaties are constantly updated or subsumed to reflect changing conditions. Why should treaties between First Nations and the Crown be frozen in time?
I'm not saying that these treaties have to be frozen in time. If changes are to be such cannot be done unilaterially, but rather be negotiated by the parties involved.
westwoody said:
I advocate a one-time buyout. Give each member of a band a one-time lump sum, and that's the end of it. And leave the band out of it so the councils don't screw it up.
Do it whities' way or get nothing, is this what you're trying to get across?
westwoody said:
By the way, that one time lump sum would likely be more than most people get. The government has yet to give me a pile of cash.
She was just one example, I could wear out my fingers giving more.
Shame on me for picking on your department.I totally approve of wastage in all other departments...NOT.
You make an assumption, do you know if it is correct or not?
westwoody said:
When my mother was dying in Vancouver I didn't get any money from the government to go visit her.
Do you have a treaty or some kind of agreement with the province or feds for such funding? Likely not.
westwoody said:
I sometimes equate political correctness with the NDP.
A little political lesson, all sides of the political spectrum have their brand of political correctness. To equate what we generally see as political correctness today and brand it as being left-wing or even as left of center can end up being off the mark.
westwoody said:
You said my comment was ignorant bullshit and that people would only say things like that because the chiefs were native.
Indeed, my comments alone attest to the fact I ain't politically correct. I also have found that people often resort to calling something politically correct as a means to cast something as wrong, and using the particular term is to be taken as the person being correct and no one should dare ask any questions.
westwoody said:
I would say to you that your parochial attitude is exactly what is preventing the First Nations people from getting anywhere.
Gees, I didn't know my posts were that powerful.
westwoody said:
I called them crooked because I have seen their corrupt practices up close. The stuff that goes on on reserves would never be tolerated in a community like Vancouver or Winnipeg.
Are you suggesting that all chiefs and councilors be painted as being crooked? I ask that because essentially this is the jist of what you're saying whether or not you mean it that way.
westwoody said:
Can you imagine if the mayor of Vancouver built a condo for all his relatives at taxpayer expense? But the same thing happens on reserves when councillors all live in nice new houses with running water and electricity, but people they don't like have to live in a squalor with a dozen or more others per house.
It is far easier to report on any corruption that is said to go on at a reserve than it is to report on any corruption in a "white" government. Let's face about the only time the media reports on the reserves or other first nations issues is usually when something wrong has occurred. I not saying there is bad shit going on with a given band council, what I'm trying to get across is put in perspective, in that shit goes on with civic, provincial, and federal levels as well.
westwoody said:
Hardly shitting on them,moving them into mainstream society is the best thing that could happen to the vast majority of natives.
It was tried, for quite a long time. In the end the assimilation failed, although it left the first nations in a very bad way which they are trying to get out of. Fucking up all sorts of native across the country for a couple of hundred years can't be undone quickly. IMO, it will take a number of decades, because I'm willing to bet there will be types advocating going back to the failed policy of assimilation as the great solution.
westwoody said:
But there is a huge beaurocracy of civil servants and the native parallel government who would no longer be sucking on the taxpayer's teat.
So it's their fault? I always get a kick out of the ignorant that babble like they know everything and yet prove they know fuck all. Perhaps you know the type, they say dumb things that allude government employees are all bad because they are simple government employees.
westwoody said:
So the chiefs and their allies in the department have to keep on telling the First Nations people that they cannot exist in the white man's world without their help.
A sweeping generalization?
westwoody said:
If they can maintain their own culture without one why do the natives need them?
Are you saying the first nations don't have a culture or cultures?
westwoody said:
Deadwood:The Assembly of First Nations, most provincial assemblies, at least half of all band councils, everyone at DINA. Why do First Nations have to have their own health plan when every province has one? Why do First Nations need their own educational system when every province has a ministry of education? Why do the First Nations have their own disastrously mismanaged children's aid organisations when the province does the same thing?
Reads like more sweeping generalizations.