Boy those EI guys are tough on their women...

westwoody

Well-known member
Jun 10, 2004
7,877
7,835
113
Westwood
The woman's safety is more important than political correctness. I have seen firsthand how some other cultures openly abuse their women and it pisses me off!
 

wilde

Sinnear Member
Jun 4, 2003
3,041
48
48
The Lizard King said:
http://www.mytelus.com/news/article.do?pageID=bc_home&articleID=2439375
Anybody think it's racist just to isolate on that community?
It ain't racism if it's the truth.

In my clubbing days frequenting the downtown core, you would see quite a few fights breaking out every night. And 2 out of 3 of those fights would usually involved or worst initiated by EI guys. I am not saying violence isn't associated with other cultures but it seems to be more prevalent amongst the EI culture whether it is towards women or in general.

.
 

Creole Lady Marmalade

No more reviews, please.
Dec 20, 2004
1,463
2
0
The Lizard King said:
http://www.mytelus.com/news/article.do?pageID=bc_home&articleID=2439375
Anybody think it's racist just to isolate on that community?
As Wilde said, not racist if it's the truth. But the kind of second class treatment towards women comes from the old country comes from a lot different countries. It it's just one particular ethnic group has more reported cases of violence against women than any other ethnic culture. In the reported cases there seems to be a clash of old school fundamental values and the progressive, evolved kind which is how we hear about it in the first place.
 

The Lizard King

New member
Jul 8, 2003
1,272
0
0
In my clubbing days frequenting the downtown core, you would see quite a few fights breaking out every night. And 2 out of 3 of those fights would usually involved or worst initiated by EI guys. I am not saying violence isn't associated with other cultures but it seems to be more prevalent amongst the EI culture whether it is towards women or in general.
Really? That's quite the statement. So because of your experiences clubbing we should be led to believe that violence is more prevalent in the EI culture? Wow. Well apparently you're Asian, how do feel when folks express that Asians are the worst drivers and a general nuisance on the streets? I have to admit, rightly or wrongly, I'm one of those people at times and I would never apologize for having those sentiments as that has really been MY experience. But at the same time I also don't expect society to necessarily feel the same way. So in general what are your thoughts on that and do you have any comment as to how that opinion's viewed within your own culture? Just wondering, not trying to fuck with you in a bad way.

But the kind of second class treatment towards women comes from the old country comes from a lot different countries. It it's just one particular ethnic group has more reported cases of violence against women than any other ethnic culture. In the reported cases there seems to be a clash of old school fundamental values and the progressive, evolved kind which is how we hear about it in the first place.
Well put.
 

westwoody

Well-known member
Jun 10, 2004
7,877
7,835
113
Westwood
jjinvan said:
Sikhs carry a dagger as a part of their religion.
What other religion requires members to carry a weapon? Does this obsession with having a weapon available not indicate a tendency to violence? And please no nonsense about the kirpan being a symbol and not a weapon-if it was only a symbol then carrying a picture of a kirpan would suffice.
 

KYG

Member
Jan 31, 2005
996
6
18
I know some nightclub owners / bouncers and they told me many EI patrons cause fights and as a result they do their best not to let them in. They are worried about the violence they cause and the bodily injury they could do to innocent people.
 

indian_boner

Born very sensual and horny
Jan 2, 2006
454
241
43
44
i would say that the percent of dom. violence is same as any other ethnic group. three isolated incidents does not mean that this is prevalent in our community. a community that is based on kinship love, god, morality, dedication, and a segment of india's universal culture do not believe in domestic violence. that is why family and in-law are a part of domestic life to help out as domestic violence would be more exposed in a home with a two adults which would give the male more freedom and less restraints to go and abuse their wives.

As an Indocanadian, the media just hypes it up as domestic violence is prevalent in every group. domestic violence indirectly mostly exists but at a lower rate. actually marriages, families, and domestic developments work out well that is why the community is prosperous with high standard of living, children getting education. indocanadian or south asians are a vry diverse group of people so we cannot generalize all indians east indians with this so-called domestic violence. 90% of east indians in canada are from punjab province in india and their religion is sikhism. sikhs make up 4% of india's population while the total populaton of all punjabis in india is probably 12%. due to change in modernity, new reality of work and home life, couples probably have issues due to this. in the past it was expected that love develops after marriage rather than before and that they would love each other. the divorce rate, suicide rate, custody rate etc..is low amongst punjabi or any other indian.

THE REAL PROBLEM IS THAT OTHER GROUPS DO NOT WANT RESEARCH AND LEARN IN ORDER TO UNDERSTAND THINGS. I CANNOT SAY MUSLIMS ARE FUNDAMENTALISTS, OR CHINESE ARE CHEAP JUST BECAUSE I SAW SOME OCCURRENCES OF THEM COLLECTING POP CANS.
 

beermontr

New member
Sep 21, 2004
2
0
1
To single out one community as being more violent towards women shows how many stupid ignorant people are still out there. These three incidents are no different than any other case other than the fact they all came within a short period of time. I know the women shelters in downtown weren't made for all the indo-canadian women so I guess that means Caucasians must really kick the crap outta their wives to have Shelters eh? To go by some of you ignorant morons theories, I guess all white people are child molesters and rapists? Not that I agree with that. I think its as stupid as any other stereotype. Every community has ass***** but the media here seems to get a rise out of prominently featuring those of ethnic minorities.
 

sirlickheralot

Gold Member
Mar 10, 2003
1,266
0
0
121
Vancouver
indian_boner said:
i would say that the percent of dom. violence is same as any other ethnic group.
Actually that isn't true, the United Nations did a study on domestic violence and found that the rate in India is pretty darn high, not the highest that dishonour goes to Egypt, Japan had the lowest. The study found that approx 70% of married women in India between the ages of 15-49 experience domestic violence. By comparison the rates in China another major source of immigration the rate was around 30%. It was until just recently that India even had laws protecting women from domestic violence. Domestic violence is so ingrained that studies showed 56% of Indian women believed wife beating to be justified in certain circumstances. Therefore it isn't that suprising that you would see higher rates of domestic violence from people who grew up in more traditional (old school) East Indian families than you see in the general population.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/6086334.stm
 

SG4EVAH

Banned
Sep 24, 2006
254
0
0
westwoody said:
The woman's safety is more important than political correctness. I have seen firsthand how some other cultures openly abuse their women and it pisses me off!
Good stuff! I concur:)
 

wolverine

Hard Throbbing Member
Nov 11, 2002
6,384
9
38
E-Town
I remember being in this bar years ago and overhearing this drunken dickweed from Trinidad complaining to his redneck buddies about not being able beat his woman here in Canada but it was perfectly acceptable back home. I wanted to tell him to go back there.

Racist or not, it's a fact that women are treated like breeding cattle in certain countries and cultures, therefore spousal abuse is not as frowned upon as it is here. In fact, I was once told what were apparently old words of wisdom from the Middle East: "If you see an old man, sit down and listen; if you see an old woman, throw a rock at her." But that's definitely an aspect of their culture that immigrants should leave behind them when they choose to live here.
 

VanBrownDude

Member
Dec 19, 2003
62
1
8
44
vancouver
jjinvan said:
Let's not forget our former premier's son (the LAWYER) who got arrested and plead no contest to assaulting up a police officer in a bar.

But, I think that the 'fights in a bar' issue is completely different, and is a fact of biology more than a fact of 'racism' or 'culture'.

Some people, and it is genetically determined, so it definately follows racial trends, do not have a certain enzyme which allows their body to break down alcohol properly, and so they get much more drunk on much (and I'm talking MUCH) less alcohol and are extremely prone to alcoholism.

Most Native indians have this problem, as do many east indians and a large segment of the asian population. The big difference as far as I can tell is that from my experiences anyway, the asians who have this problem tend to avoid drinking alcohol in bars...

That said, remember that the Sikhs carry a dagger as a part of their religion. They say that they would NEVER use it, etc, but there have been plenty of assaults and even a couple of murders committed in BC (one of which was a professor at UBC who gave a bad grade to a Sikh grad student) with those 'harmless' daggers that our courts have ruled a 12 year old can bring with him to school even if the school has a 'no knives' policy.

I'm just waiting for the courts to rule that beating their wives is protected under the charter as a cultural/religious freedom.

Where did this crap come from ?
 

ericestro_88

New member
Aug 16, 2003
97
0
0
westwoody said:
The woman's safety is more important than political correctness. I have seen firsthand how some other cultures openly abuse their women and it pisses me off!
I guess when white guys beat their women it doesn't piss you off so much.
 

ericestro_88

New member
Aug 16, 2003
97
0
0
jjinvan said:
Let's not forget our former premier's son (the LAWYER) who got arrested and plead no contest to assaulting up a police officer in a bar.

But, I think that the 'fights in a bar' issue is completely different, and is a fact of biology more than a fact of 'racism' or 'culture'.

Some people, and it is genetically determined, so it definately follows racial trends, do not have a certain enzyme which allows their body to break down alcohol properly, and so they get much more drunk on much (and I'm talking MUCH) less alcohol and are extremely prone to alcoholism.

Most Native indians have this problem, as do many east indians and a large segment of the asian population. The big difference as far as I can tell is that from my experiences anyway, the asians who have this problem tend to avoid drinking alcohol in bars...

That said, remember that the Sikhs carry a dagger as a part of their religion. They say that they would NEVER use it, etc, but there have been plenty of assaults and even a couple of murders committed in BC (one of which was a professor at UBC who gave a bad grade to a Sikh grad student) with those 'harmless' daggers that our courts have ruled a 12 year old can bring with him to school even if the school has a 'no knives' policy.

I'm just waiting for the courts to rule that beating their wives is protected under the charter as a cultural/religious freedom.
This thread has had some of the most prejudicial things I've seen written in awhile. It is kind of suprising because this board usually has thought provoking intelligence. But this thread, not so much.

What does the premier's son getting in a fight have to do with domestic violence in the east indian community. I guess you are trying to say that the men are just more violent. I guess somebody should investigation Todd Bertuzzi's marriage too.

This whole thread is a joke. Can you send me a link to the story about the UBC professor being stabbed by a Sikh student over a bad grade?

Also, can you send me the link to this enzyme study you were referring to?

Actually, better yet, post it here so we all know how much you bullshit.
 

lovinithard

New member
May 28, 2006
117
0
0
between her legs
indian_boner said:
As an Indocanadian, the media just hypes it up as domestic violence is prevalent in every group. domestic violence indirectly mostly exists but at a lower rate. actually marriages, families, and domestic developments work out well that is why the community is prosperous with high standard of living, children getting education. indocanadian or south asians are a vry diverse group of people so we cannot generalize all indians east indians with this so-called domestic violence. QUOTE]


It's not just white people who say there's a problem. There was a big meeting in Surrey on this very issue 2 days ago where a large number of EI leaders came out decrying the high level of domestic violence within their community.
 

indian_boner

Born very sensual and horny
Jan 2, 2006
454
241
43
44
India has many ethnic and caste groups. these punjabi (5% of india's population )bar brawlers who you are referring are the landowning/farmer and military caste known as the Jats. they make up 65% of the sikh population and yes they love to drink..so you cant say all east indians are like when only one caste/ethnic group does this. these are not the nerdy brillant scientist behind india's nuclear and space industry who are also not punjabi.

in regards to the kirpan, it is only worn by true baptised sikhs. there are 3 types of sikhs: clean-shaven sikhs called mona, drink,smoke, do kamasutra; turbaned sikhs (keshdhari) with trim beards and full hair and some with no full hair who drink etc.., and then there is amritdhari sikhs, totally full hair covered, full beard, some wear non-conventional turbans that are not curved and pointy. this third type which makes up 30 % of sikhs, while the keshdharis are the majority. the amritdharis only carry kirpan and the five k's and that is why you dont see turban sikhs (keshdharis) with kirpan.
kirpan is kept by baptized sikhs to personify righteousness, order, protection etc..they can never use it for self-defense etc...so must make distinction between regular indians ppl with a knife with baptized sikhs and they kirpan....
we thus cannot label a person with a knife as a person who has a kirapn, kirpans are totally different in appearance and most are -5 inches long.
 
Ashley Madison
Vancouver Escorts