You guys hit it square on. The young hotties can indeed be very hot. But they haven't got a clue who John Cougar, Neil Young, or Steppenwolf are. They've never heard of Johnny Bower or Bobby Orr. If they know who Brett Hull is, they think that Bobby is just his dad. They think that Trudeau is some guy that the Quebecois named an airport after, not a Prime Minister who gave the "Salmon Arm Salute" to the west.
The Cougars, on the other hand, know who those folks are, and much more. They can certainly hold their own, and mine, in the sack. I have seen at least one who I know to be a grandmother, and she blew Mr Happy like he had never been blown before......happier than almost any 20 year old. Hell, she could have learned the art by practicing on my father.....
Depends on what you want. The sweet little tighties are hot and sweet. The cougars are hot, sweet, practiced, experienced, so very talented, and just a generally better experience.
But each team needs a few rookies and a few vets. I still like to mix my roster up. Bench strength, it's all about bench strength.